Proposal:Member Of Band Relationship Type modification

From MusicBrainz Wiki

Jump to: navigation, search


Status: This page describes an active advanced relationship proposal and is not official.


Proposal number: RFC-319
Champion: BrianFreud / reosarevok
Current status: RFV
Initial Discussion




Contents

Official Documentation: Advanced Relationships
  Relationship Classes > Musical Association Relationship Class > Member Of Band Relationship Type







This relationship type belongs to the Musical Association Relationship Class.

Description

This indicates membership of a person artist in a group artist.

Link Phrases

  • Artist has/had member(s) Artist
  • Artist is/was a member of Artist

    Attributes

    “start date”

    This is the date that the person artist joined the group artist.

    “end date”

    This is the date that the person artist left the group artist.
    • If the person artist is still a member of the group artist, leave blank.
    • If the group artist has itself has ended, and the person artist was a member at that time, use the date that the group artist ended.

    “additional”

    There is no guideline yet for how this attribute might be used.

    “founder”

    This attribute indicates that the person artist was a founding member of the group artist.

    Guidelines

    • Some person artists leave a group artist, then rejoin again later. This should be represented through the use of more than one relationship between the person and group artists, with the appropriate start and end dates set.
    • If a person artist is usually known by a particular performance name, use that performance name to link them to the group artist instead of their legal name. If the artist uses multiple performance names, the performance name that should be used is the one that they usually performed under whilst in the group artist.
    • The conductor or chorus master of a group is almost never also a member of that same group. The Member of Band relationship should only ever be used to link a conductor or chorus master to the conducted group if that person is credited as a member of the group; it should never be assumed without such evidence.

      Rationale

      Artists are usually credited by their performance names, rather than their legal names. In fact, the real names of some very well known members of group artists are quite obscure. If an artist's legal name were used to link them to the group artist, instead of their performance name, this would create confusion, and likely people would try to link the performance name anyway.

    History

    See Founding Member Dates Question for the original discussions which took place regarding how to handle founders.

    Examples

    Personal tools