User:BrianSchweitzer/Live Performance Relationship Type Proposal
From MusicBrainz Wiki
| Status: Implemented! This page describes a proposal which is now official and has been implemented. |
|
|
Note 1: This relationship type is already approved. There is, however, no documentation for it. This proposal covers only the documentation. Note 2: The tour compilation attribute is not part of the relationship type as approved; it is part of ongoing discussion about the AR and its documentation. RFC2/RFV: The tour compilation attribute was added in RFC2; the proposal now adds that attribute as well as approving this doc.
|
This relationship type belongs to the Alternative Version Relationship Class.
Description
This indicates that a release is a live performance of a studio release.
Link Phrases
Attributes
“start date”
- There is no guideline yet for how the begin date fields might be used.
“end date”
- There is no guideline yet for how the end date fields might be used.
“tour”
- This indicates that the live performances occurred on multiple dates within the same tour, rather than all within a single performance.
- Link Phrases:
- Release is a tour compilation of Release
- Release was performed live as Release
- Link Phrases:
Guidelines
- Radio, TV, and internet-streamed performances are considered to be 'live'.
- Studio-recorded or demo tracks must not be present on the release.
- This relationship type should not be used to link from compilations of live performances, nor should it be linked to box sets.
- The song order of the live release does not have to match the song order of the studio release.
Tour attribute
- At least 80% of the tracks from the studio release must be present on the live release.
- At least 80% of tracks on the live release must be present on the studio release.
- For either of the above two guidelines, the 80% requirement may be lowered if sufficient reason exists, subject to agreement by voters.
- If the tour attribute is selected, then tracks compiled from multiple performances occurring within a single concert tour may be counted.
- All songs must be from the same concert tour.
- Every song from the studio release must be present on the live release.
- Every song on the live release must be present on the studio release, on singles/EPs released in support of that studio release, or be a cover song (as defined by Cover Relationship Type). No song on the live release should be from a different studio release by the same artist.
Examples
Categories: Proposal History | Passed Proposal | Relationship Type | Release-Release Relationship Family | Alternative Version Relationship Class
