History talk:Edit Rating

From MusicBrainz Wiki

+1 -- mikemorr 17:01, 02 May 2008 (UTC)

I like the idea, but I am not sure all the actual items used to raise the rank are correct. Some of them might prove unfeasible anyhow (check Amazon track listing). But even if only some of the tests are implemented it should be an improvement. -- davitof 2008-05-02

  • Indeed, the exact checks and the amount they increase rating really needs debate. In a good implementation, tests and their outcome can be added, modified and removed as needed. While some tests (like the Amazon check) require more work, they're not really impossible by any means. -- foolip 18:55, 02 May 2008 (UTC)