User:Hawke/Proposal/Data Quality Style

From MusicBrainz Wiki


Status: This page describes an active style guideline proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-Unassigned
Champion: Hawke
Current status: RFC




Guidelines

Normal is the default quality, and entities should be normal quality unless they qualify for some other quality level

Work

Low
No composer AR. no lyricist/librettist AR (if applicable)
High
Each related recording has a unique set of (title, artist, disambiguation)

Recording

Low
No duration. No related work (if applicable).
High
One (and only one) acoustID, or explanation for multiple acoustIDs described in annotation. Artist named in Artist Credit has performance AR to the recording. All other known related artists have ARs to the recording. Recording has a unique set of (title, disambiguation) within each artist contained in the AC.

Release

Low
The release does not have enough information to allow a user to positively determine whether a release they have in hand is the one on the site. Minimum is: year, label, catalog number
High
All recordings on the release are related to corresponding works, if applicable. All known ARs to the release have been created.

Release Group

Low
The earliest-dated release in the RG is known to not be the first release. All releases in the RG are of low quality.
High
All known releases are in the RG, and none are of Low quality.

Artist

Low
Artist has no start/end date. All the artist’s RGs are of low quality. Artist’s name is not unique, and artist has no disambiguation comment.
High
artist has some related URLs. All known RGs are present, and no RGs are of low quality. No recordings are of Low quality