User:Reosarevok/Artwork ARs: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Reosarevok (talk | contribs) (New page: {{proposal|ar=true}} ==Cover art-related Relationships proposal== I propose a few enhancements to the general "cover art" category; the current three relationships are (in my experience) ...) |
Reosarevok (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{proposal|ar=true}} |
{{proposal|ar=true}} |
||
==Miscellaneous ARs for Artwork== |
|||
==Cover art-related Relationships proposal== |
|||
I propose a few enhancements to the general "cover art" category; the current three relationships are (in my experience) not very pliable to what's actually on many covers (i.e., on the covers I've seen). |
I propose a few enhancements to the general "cover art" category; the current three relationships are (in my experience) not very pliable to what's actually on many covers (i.e., on the covers I've seen). |
||
Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
** '''artist''' or '''URL''' ''provided photography for'' '''release''' or '''track''' |
** '''artist''' or '''URL''' ''provided photography for'' '''release''' or '''track''' |
||
** '''release''' or '''track''' ''has photography by'' '''artist''' or '''URL''' |
** '''release''' or '''track''' ''has photography by'' '''artist''' or '''URL''' |
||
** '''artist''' or '''URL''' ''provided front cover painting for'' '''release''' or '''track''' |
|||
** '''release''' or '''track''' ''has front cover painting by'' '''artist''' or '''URL''' |
|||
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">I've actually seen this on a release [[release:36cbbb31-c6eb-4452-b072-d495f4faa309|wiki:release:36cbbb31-c6eb-4452-b072-d495f4faa309]]; other similar albums (where the same artist created painted artwork from the cover) had only "cover art by". I don't see any harm adding "painting" -- it's the same with photography and illustration -- but if we multiply this for any back/front cover, booklet, etc., this could become huge. See the "Domains" proposal below. |
|||
</ul> |
</ul> |
||
Latest revision as of 00:41, 26 January 2011
Status: This page describes an active advanced relationship proposal and is not official. |
|
Miscellaneous ARs for Artwork
I propose a few enhancements to the general "cover art" category; the current three relationships are (in my experience) not very pliable to what's actually on many covers (i.e., on the covers I've seen).
First, I suggest to group all such roles under a general "artwork" category. (Or class, I don't know which is the preferred term.)
Below is a list of roles that should be in the category. The list contains the previously existing relationships (I assume they were added for good reasons), and a few more that I encountered on covers. Anyone who has encountered others should add them here. The list is hierarchical, I believe that's possible, right?
- artist or URL provided art direction on release or track
- release or track has art direction by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided design for release or track
- release or track has design by artist or URL (this is broken from "art design / illustration", I don't see why they should be together.)
- artist or URL provided graphic design on release or track
- release or track has graphic design by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided executive design on release or track
- release or track has executive design by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided layout for release or track
- release or track has layout by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided artwork for release or track
- release or track has artwork by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided cover art for release or track
- release or track has cover art by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided illustration for release or track
- release or track has illustration by artist or URL (this is broken from "art design / illustration", I don't see why they should be together.)
- artist or URL provided photography for release or track
- release or track has photography by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided typography for release or track
- release or track has typography by artist or URL
- artist or URL provided cover/artwork concept for release or track
- release or track has cover/artwork concept by artist or URL
- I don't know if it's worth it to differentiate these two, but I'm wary of another "art design/illustration" problem, so it may be a good idea to separate them.