Additional Relationship Attribute: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(→Description: Move to talk) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===Possible Values=== |
|||
=Relationship Attribute "Additional"= |
|||
Either set, or it isn't. |
|||
'''Status:''' ''This is work in progress! The distinction between the different [[Advanced Relationship Attribute|AdvancedRelationshipAttribute]]s is not very concise, yet.'' |
|||
===Used with Types=== |
|||
This attribute can be applied to the following [[Advanced Relationship Type|AdvancedRelationshipType]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s: |
|||
* [[Arranger Relationship Type]] |
|||
==Examples== |
|||
* [[Art Direction Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Audio Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
The [http://musicbrainz.org/artist/deebc49a-6e06-418e-860f-8c7f770a8bac.html San Francisco Symphony Orchestra] performed together with [http://musicbrainz.org/artist/65f4f0c5-ef9e-490c-aee3-909e7ae6b2ab.html Metallica] in a series of concerts that were eventually released as the album [http://musicbrainz.org/album/43e86448-a344-4c1d-ab5e-5babdfeef9c4.html S&M (disc 1)]. Metallica are clearly the primary artist, and clearly the orchestra is related to the album with the [[Orchestra Relationship Type|OrchestraRelationshipType]]. Currently though, the orchestra has the "additional" flag. Possibly this is just due to the script that was run which removed the "feat." artists. |
|||
* [[Cataloguer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Chorus Master Relationship Type]] |
|||
==Discussion== |
|||
* [[Collaboration Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Composer Relationship Type]] |
|||
Would most or all guest performances be additional? --MichelleW |
|||
* [[Conductor Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Creative Direction Relationship Type]] |
|||
I've found a good example of an 'additional' remixing: [http://musicbrainz.org/track/8d41eea8-6970-4a3f-99df-3c1ee47ef965.html The Avalanches - A Different Feeling (Paperclip People remix) (Avalanches edit)]. Paperclip People remixed a song by The Avalanches, who themselves then edited it. Two remixing relationships are added: "... was remixed by Paperclip People" and "... was additionally remixed by The Avalanches". --[[User:thewilkybarkid|thewilkybarkid]] |
|||
* [[Design and Illustration Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Editor Relationship Type]] |
|||
----[[Needs Editing|NeedsEditing]] |
|||
* [[Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Graphic Design Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Instrumentator Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Librettist Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Liner Notes Author Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Live Sound Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Lyricist Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Mastering Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Member Of Band Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Mix Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Orchestra Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Orchestrator Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Performer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Photography Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Producer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Programming Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Recording Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Remixer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Samples Artist Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Samples Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Sound Engineer Relationship Type]] |
|||
* [[Supporting Musician Relationship Type]] |
|||
[[Category:To Be Reviewed]] [[Category:Relationship Attribute]] |
[[Category:To Be Reviewed]] [[Category:Relationship Attribute]] |
||
Revision as of 10:23, 24 March 2010
Possible Values
Either set, or it isn't.
Used with Types
This attribute can be applied to the following AdvancedRelationshipTypes:
- Arranger Relationship Type
- Art Direction Relationship Type
- Audio Engineer Relationship Type
- Cataloguer Relationship Type
- Chorus Master Relationship Type
- Collaboration Relationship Type
- Composer Relationship Type
- Conductor Relationship Type
- Creative Direction Relationship Type
- Design and Illustration Relationship Type
- Editor Relationship Type
- Engineer Relationship Type
- Graphic Design Relationship Type
- Instrumentator Relationship Type
- Librettist Relationship Type
- Liner Notes Author Relationship Type
- Live Sound Engineer Relationship Type
- Lyricist Relationship Type
- Mastering Engineer Relationship Type
- Member Of Band Relationship Type
- Mix Engineer Relationship Type
- Orchestra Relationship Type
- Orchestrator Relationship Type
- Performer Relationship Type
- Photography Relationship Type
- Producer Relationship Type
- Programming Relationship Type
- Recording Engineer Relationship Type
- Remixer Relationship Type
- Samples Artist Relationship Type
- Samples Relationship Type
- Sound Engineer Relationship Type
- Supporting Musician Relationship Type
