Difference between revisions of "Code of Conduct"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
(+Nikki as author (Imported from MoinMoin))
(Reworded some entries for clarity. Expanded "voting" section. (Imported from MoinMoin))
Line 5: Line 5:
 
===Community Members===
 
===Community Members===
  
* Be polite. Remember that there's another person on the receiving end. Treat people as you'd wish to be treated yourself.  
+
* Be polite. Remember that there's a real person on the receiving end of any communication. Treat people as you'd wish to be treated yourself.  
* Remember that everyone was new at some point and a polite nudge in the right direction sometimes is all it takes.  
+
* Remember that everyone was new at some point and a polite nudge in the right direction is sometimes all that it takes to set them on the right path.  
* Don't get into flame wars, or at least try to keep a neutral position as possible.  
+
* Don't get into flame wars, and try to remain as neutral as possible. Do not attack someone personally because you don't agree with them.  
* [[MusicBrainz]] is a global community. Be mindful and respectful of the different languages, habitis and cultures of others.  
+
* [[MusicBrainz]] is a global community. Be mindful and respectful of different languages, habits and cultures.  
 
* Share knowledge freely. New members should not be embarassed for ignorance.  
 
* Share knowledge freely. New members should not be embarassed for ignorance.  
 
* Respectfully suggest other options. Not everyone wants to reconfigure their directories, change their OS or switch players and formats.  
 
* Respectfully suggest other options. Not everyone wants to reconfigure their directories, change their OS or switch players and formats.  
Line 16: Line 16:
 
* Set an example for others.  
 
* Set an example for others.  
 
* Don't abuse automod privileges, including applying controversial changes without a vote or making edits another person is already making (although this does happen accidentally sometimes).  
 
* Don't abuse automod privileges, including applying controversial changes without a vote or making edits another person is already making (although this does happen accidentally sometimes).  
* Remember that some new users, given the right guidance, have the potential to become automods themselves one day. Whereas many may never come back if they're insulted.  
+
* Remember that some new users, given the right guidance, have the potential to become automods themselves one day, whereas they may never come back if they're insulted.  
* In general, act responsibly. Automods are seen as a symbol of status, even if that wasn't the original intention, childish behaviour reflects badly on the [[MusicBrainz]] community as a whole.
+
* Act responsibly. Although it wasn't the original intention, automod rights seen as a symbol of status, and childish behaviour reflects badly on the [[MusicBrainz]] community as a whole.  
  
 
==Details==
 
==Details==
Line 35: Line 35:
  
 
* Never vote based on your personal attitude towards the editor. Vote only based on the facts and what you think is right or wrong.  
 
* Never vote based on your personal attitude towards the editor. Vote only based on the facts and what you think is right or wrong.  
 +
* If you are voting against an edit, make a habit of explaining why via an edit note. Nothing is more frustrating than entering a bunch of edits only to receive silent no votes.
  
 
===AutoEditors===
 
===AutoEditors===
Line 50: Line 51:
 
Always check an item's history before making a change that could be disputed. If you made an [[Auto-Edit|AutoEdit]] and then realise that it is disputed, you should:  
 
Always check an item's history before making a change that could be disputed. If you made an [[Auto-Edit|AutoEdit]] and then realise that it is disputed, you should:  
 
* Excuse yourself in a [[Moderation Note|ModerationNote]].  
 
* Excuse yourself in a [[Moderation Note|ModerationNote]].  
* If you offended someone, revert your edit as a simple matter of courtesy.  
+
* Revert your edit.  
 
* Temporarily disable your [[Auto-Editor|AutoEditor]] privileges and enter the edit again as one to be voted upon.  
 
* Temporarily disable your [[Auto-Editor|AutoEditor]] privileges and enter the edit again as one to be voted upon.  
  

Revision as of 02:14, 8 January 2006

Purpose

This Code of Conduct describes how members of the MusicBrainz community should interact and further details how AutoEditors (aka AutoModerators) should act; using their privileges in a responsible way.

Community Members

  • Be polite. Remember that there's a real person on the receiving end of any communication. Treat people as you'd wish to be treated yourself.
  • Remember that everyone was new at some point and a polite nudge in the right direction is sometimes all that it takes to set them on the right path.
  • Don't get into flame wars, and try to remain as neutral as possible. Do not attack someone personally because you don't agree with them.
  • MusicBrainz is a global community. Be mindful and respectful of different languages, habits and cultures.
  • Share knowledge freely. New members should not be embarassed for ignorance.
  • Respectfully suggest other options. Not everyone wants to reconfigure their directories, change their OS or switch players and formats.

AutoEditors

  • Set an example for others.
  • Don't abuse automod privileges, including applying controversial changes without a vote or making edits another person is already making (although this does happen accidentally sometimes).
  • Remember that some new users, given the right guidance, have the potential to become automods themselves one day, whereas they may never come back if they're insulted.
  • Act responsibly. Although it wasn't the original intention, automod rights seen as a symbol of status, and childish behaviour reflects badly on the MusicBrainz community as a whole.

Details

Community Members

Making Edits

  • Provide explanations when entering edits.
  • Include links that validate your edits.
  • Listen to the advice of existing community members. Ask for clarification if you're still unsure.
  • Refer to the StyleGuide and Wiki for clarification.
  • Ask question on the mailing list or IRC if you're unsure.
  • Edits should be based on objective data and not personal preferences.

Voting

  • Never vote based on your personal attitude towards the editor. Vote only based on the facts and what you think is right or wrong.
  • If you are voting against an edit, make a habit of explaining why via an edit note. Nothing is more frustrating than entering a bunch of edits only to receive silent no votes.

AutoEditors

Dealing With Open Edits

How should autoeditors deal with open edits, that they think are correct?

IIRC it was said, that autoeditors should not redo the same edit as an AutoEdit. While this might speed up the process of correcting MB data, it will make the other contributor's edit fail, and thus raise his FailedEditCount.

Making Disputed Edits

Autoeditors must never use their privileges to decide disputed edits in their favor.

Always check an item's history before making a change that could be disputed. If you made an AutoEdit and then realise that it is disputed, you should:

  • Excuse yourself in a ModerationNote.
  • Revert your edit.
  • Temporarily disable your AutoEditor privileges and enter the edit again as one to be voted upon.

Discussion

I think the Code of Conduct should be expanded to the community as a whole with a section specific for AutoEditors. I've already made some adjustments to allow for this. -- WolfSong 17:17, 07 January 2006 (UTC)


Authors: inhousuk, Nikki, WolfSong, DonRedman