Difference between revisions of "Community Project/BBC Review Cleanup"
(→Unlinked reviews: "Sun People - Nickodemus": bw9x -> w9dp (got deleted, see http://chatlogs.musicbrainz.org/musicbrainz-devel/2012/2012-03/2012-03-20.html#T16-13-46-352391)) |
(→Unlinked reviews: move a bunch to "old") |
||
Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
! align="left" style="width: 33%;" | Release Group |
! align="left" style="width: 33%;" | Release Group |
||
! align="left" style="width: 33%;" | Release |
! align="left" style="width: 33%;" | Release |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/w9dp Sun People - Nickodemus] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:4c4a9c7c-99a7-4899-a736-f91ed29776ae|Sun People]] |
||
− | | [[Release:f28a5efc-4244-4172-89bd-f190a0ebd709|Sun People]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/5gjw Basement Jaxx - Scars] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:86e92d9c-1146-4494-a68f-d0550d41fd7e|Scars]] |
||
− | | [[Release:d0c3db95-27da-384a-88ce-f3a258434600|Scars]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/qbw6 Various Artists - Warp20 (Box Set)] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:f86c7496-9f94-476b-8891-f75df12747d5|Warp20]] |
||
− | | [[Release:3d91913e-a9b4-43f7-b1f6-4dd4a7585e63|Warp20]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/w4cz Mötley Crüe - Dr Feelgood (Deluxe Edition)] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:17ca3011-430c-3063-af7b-4465fc82ec91|Dr. Feelgood]] |
||
− | | [[Release:d4d3976f-41c4-478a-a096-c4917c1731c8|Dr. Feelgood]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pxp2 David Bowie - Space Oddity: 40th Anniversary Edition] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:2e12918c-4973-3537-b9ab-e4723ae1ae1d|Space Oddity]] |
||
− | | [[Release:17ca3011-430c-3063-af7b-4465fc82ec91|Space Oddity]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/zrzb Dmitri Shostakovich - Symphonies 5 & 9 (feat. conductor: Vasily Petrenko; feat. orchestra: Royal Liverpool Philharmonic)] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:dbdaeac8-3623-4c90-9f40-744e712d488c|Symphonies Nos. 5 & 9]] |
||
− | | [[Release:e1b8c502-c3f6-41ec-b282-5b29cbfbcd92|Symphonies Nos. 5 & 9]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/8zfd GWAR - America Must Be Destroyed] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:e7a7ac2a-ea82-4cac-8296-c08136d22ebb|America Must Be Destroyed]] |
||
− | | [[Release:9529f3f5-87d2-3af0-93da-cffdf9372313|America Must Be Destroyed]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/33cg Squarepusher - Shobaleader One: d'Demonstrator ] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:822cded9-241f-4387-ba03-857a4b070bdb|d'Demonstrator]] |
||
− | | [[Release:e6b5be2c-0c1b-4778-9e3d-55e1333f33f9|d'Demonstrator]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/3bnv Joy Division - +-] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:db34d7b2-4e88-4469-a521-b34b11342e75|+-]] |
||
− | | [[Release:85bd4a0e-d28a-442c-922e-394b939e7af9|+-]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pf5c Various Artists - Upside Down – The Creation Records Story] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:55e94af0-a0af-454a-8f6d-db9a403f1113|Upside Down: The Creation Records Story]] |
||
− | | [[Release:dfbf72bc-e7c1-4cba-b1ca-4bf3ee326d4c|Upside Down: The Creation Records Story]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/294z Twelves - The Adding Machine] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:f036991b-cc56-4c9f-bdcf-61596dc8ab4c|The Adding Machine]] |
||
− | | [[Release:5ffdfbbe-0e29-464e-9c5f-045565357fe8|The Adding Machine]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/ndcg Weather Report - Live In Berlin 1975 ] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:d2d5af10-c9f3-406e-a23f-16c9f08c40c9|Live in Berlin 1975]] |
||
− | | [[Release:57dc2fc3-4934-4d2f-a4ae-86572107670e|Live in Berlin 1975]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/q6rj Chrissy Murderbot - Women’s Studies] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:c2814986-68a0-42d2-8951-e56018d1f736|Women’s Studies]] |
||
− | | [[Release:c9d557a3-7821-4447-ad8e-3c59d9d802df|Women’s Studies]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/8pzb Owiny Sigoma Band - Owiny Sigoma Band] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:9f0781be-483d-4ff4-a29c-dfa93378f76a|Owiny Sigoma Band]] |
||
− | | [[Release:b2ad46ee-0080-44e1-9772-9be1075ff51c|Owiny Sigoma Band]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/4mj9 Jóhann Jóhannsson - The Miners’ Hymns] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:546d3d38-1372-489a-aa4a-2a31d55169b5|The Miners’ Hymns]] |
||
− | | [[Release:98a5b3ae-d2d7-4416-8c78-ed47dc629dab|The Miners’ Hymns]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/fcpn Cults - Cults] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:8ba8cb38-75b1-4511-b5e3-4f5f14fb11b8|Cults]] |
||
− | | [[Release:c35f343a-369b-4212-8528-41faf7569b6d|Cults]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/br3q Young Legionnaire - Crisis Works] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:f6d739a3-c5e8-4c99-abce-8b19f25963d7|Crisis Works]] |
||
− | | [[Release:d84c493c-91ba-4792-ae11-62a4004440c2|Crisis Works]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/jcpn The Pierces - You & I ] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:48da96ca-6425-4030-afc1-5dfd1c63b15d|You & I]] |
||
− | | [[Release:327d35f3-12f7-43a8-af7a-3b27132fc353|You & I]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/wz28 Various Artists - The Flowerpot Sessions] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:9a081f01-e8a5-4b8b-aa7e-eecacd7289c4|The Flowerpot Sessions]] |
||
− | | [[Release:21048e78-914b-437b-aa00-6d29ded200a5|The Flowerpot Sessions]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/9gnv Dinner At The Thompson’s - Off the Grid] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:7003d97e-412a-49e1-baf9-de4bb0d8dbe0|Off the Grid]] |
||
− | | [[Release:24846f54-a93e-4388-85cd-6b21b4f48228|Off the Grid]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/z4x2 Camille Saint-Saëns - Symphonie No.3 avec “Orgue”; Concerto pour Piano No.4 (feat. organ: Daniel Roth; piano: Jean-François Heisser; Les Siècles/François-Xavier Roth)] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:6f642e2c-ca91-4f44-b79a-1864b85c693a|Symphonie nº 3 "avec orgue" / Concerto pour piano nº 4 (Les Siècles feat. conductor: François Xavier Roth)]] |
||
− | | [[Release:ea84c6c8-1b8c-4d9a-974d-0132a4e86823|Symphonie nº 3 "avec orgue" / Concerto pour piano nº 4 (Les Siècles feat. conductor: François Xavier Roth)]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/gr3q Young Rebel Set - Curse Our Love] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:59a85b14-90a9-409a-94ad-4ee794868810|Curse Our Love]] |
||
− | | [[Release:674d30a5-c0f3-4f96-9162-e7b2612adb78|Curse Our Love]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/694z Nerina Pallot - Year of the Wolf] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:05656228-186a-4270-ab72-eb3229806bae|Year of the Wolf]] |
||
− | | [[Release:34773a48-b0d8-4cfc-b876-b47418973cfe|Year of the Wolf]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/v59p Hollie Cook - Hollie Cook] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:57c5d8b7-dd50-4789-b86e-c12197a8d391|Hollie Cook]] |
||
− | | [[Release:e1a2192a-6708-495e-8a19-c4ba13a4fd89|Hollie Cook]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/48d3 Emmy the Great - Virtue] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:9afaf213-a9c5-4d19-acaf-09a5f224a657|Virtue]] |
||
− | | [[Release:6b348977-3938-4415-af25-b098350bd8ce|Virtue]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pxhf Jakszyk, Fripp and Collins - A Scarcity of Miracles] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:2cc81708-b18d-4f4d-bac0-7eb0ddd2f5e9|A Scarcity of Miracles]] |
||
− | | [[Release:71551f6d-d7d8-4179-85de-feed82537ddf|A Scarcity of Miracles]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/qnb6 Kaiser Chiefs - The Future Is Medieval] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:4aed3c25-0aa1-4525-9f48-8685c67aeec2|The Future Is Medieval]] |
||
− | | [[Release:2620b57b-7024-4a5a-98e0-684778a0047b|The Future Is Medieval]] (yes, the review is about the digital release, not the CD) |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/xxhf Tommy Smith - Karma] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:ac4bc68e-ca7f-4c83-9173-f96a13f42889|Karma]] |
||
− | | [[Release:2cc81708-b18d-4f4d-bac0-7eb0ddd2f5e9|Karma]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/33gw White Denim - D] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:d691cc08-459b-49a5-beb2-3a73530ae23e|D]] |
||
− | | [[Release:dc16ccbf-ab90-4b3e-86a0-4e1b1b2404bb|D]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/22fd Jon Allen - Sweet Defeat] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:c46e122f-c972-46c1-89a0-1ec8467ab8a5|Sweet Defeat]] |
||
− | | [[Release:d673d3ff-e3fa-44d3-af86-de782e767d0a|Sweet Defeat]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/nnb6 Devon Sproule - I Love You, Go Easy] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:1a37aa48-424f-4a00-b6cb-3bf6e465982e|I Love You, Go Easy]] |
||
− | | [[Release:d2673ae6-41f8-4a4c-941c-aaa58977720a|I Love You, Go Easy]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/gj5c Sparrow and the Workshop - Spitting Daggers] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:de37e699-b825-4925-9e59-9b8829b20163|Spitting Daggers]] |
||
− | | [[Release:df8709da-64a0-4ac1-9a94-b1b2ab568b3d|Spitting Daggers]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/9drj Wonderland - Wonderland] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:4d17e849-4eee-479b-82c5-bc02c0c7593e|Wonderland]] |
||
− | | [[Release:20e6754d-8d9d-4b38-a2ff-5e81c449f55c|Wonderland]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/6xzb Take That - Progressed] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:727177ef-06e4-4d83-bbd5-3ad1fa9b1081|Progressed]] |
||
− | | [[Release:a30d3f5c-784f-459e-9693-32d5bee9b0e5|Progressed]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/3mfd Danny Schmidt - Man of Many Moons] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:500bd016-d901-49d2-8831-3eebe3052d34|Man of Many Moons]] |
||
− | | [[Release:c43855d3-6955-4c40-8b2f-486f8ec69412|Man of Many Moons]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/gf8r Lucy Wainwright Roche - Lucy ] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:82bff27c-4864-4ff8-a7eb-339511206511|Lucy]] |
||
− | | [[Release:9aaa19db-770e-4fcd-a67b-efed2683263a|Lucy]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pmfd JuJu - In Trance] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:5d8757ca-4175-446b-b3bf-8b32ed772afc|In Trance]] |
||
− | | [[Release:bafc24a3-9c5f-4c9e-a413-85dbf2dddff7|In Trance]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/cgq4 Vetiver - The Errant Charm] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:164cef61-bc4b-4268-b09c-866600c16098|The Errant Charm]] |
||
− | | [[Release:73547a65-7796-428e-8d38-396414fe891b|The Errant Charm]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/qc3q Ty Segall - Goodbye Bread] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:ef59dab8-0ff5-4b58-9ae7-83d61e0363c5|Goodbye Bread]] |
||
− | | [[Release:dc32e7b2-a1d6-4486-994c-90dee42229b7|Goodbye Bread]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/mvx2 Samiyam - Sam Baker’s Album] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:420a386f-53ad-4feb-937e-86a14955a640|Sam Baker’s Album]] |
||
− | | [[Release:c0350507-02d3-4dd4-8671-4f1f19520f7a|Sam Baker’s Album]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/cf8r Alicia Keys - Songs in A Minor: Collector’s Edition] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:5701e04b-efc2-3429-b8af-c6596f1d08cf|Songs in A Minor]] |
||
− | | [[Release:92223720-0406-4beb-a9dd-a3bb8885036e|Songs in A Minor (Collector’s Edition)]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/rbvh Woods - Sun and Shade] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:2687a756-64cf-414d-82b0-a6f2930d78b4|Sun and Shade]] |
||
− | | [[Release:cdd3b9ea-275e-457e-b61e-fe34bf3438cd|Sun and Shade]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/vj5c The Feeling - Together We Were Made] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:1cad7f89-4f2f-4367-838c-bd562fe61053|Together We Were Made]] |
||
− | | [[Release:13ba7b30-e274-4118-8e11-1c9cda1c1b0c|Together We Were Made]] Review has picture of Double Album version, but makes no mention of the extra songs/ disc. |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/rw4z Brontide - Sans Souci] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:113ab958-cfb8-4782-99af-639d4d9eae8d|Sans Souci]] |
||
− | | [[Release:fde538c8-ffef-47c6-9b5a-bd28f4070e5c|Sans Souci]] |
||
− | |- |
||
− | | [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/h9cg Jehst - The Dragon of an Ordinary Family] |
||
− | | [[ReleaseGroup:b8b3e14b-4d71-42ff-b4a7-32b74bb2b58d|The Dragon of an Ordinary Family]] |
||
− | | [[Release:0457eb29-7ff8-4787-9fa2-8b7a25a1cf5c|The Dragon of an Ordinary Family]] |
||
|- |
|- |
||
| [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pvx2 Richard Thompson - Live at the BBC] |
| [http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/pvx2 Richard Thompson - Live at the BBC] |
Revision as of 19:04, 26 April 2012
This is a table of BBC reviews that are not linked to MusicBranz. If you find the correct release group, relate the review to it in MusicBrainz and add its MBID to the Release Group column. If you can also find which release it is for exactly, you can add that information to the Release column to help the BBC map them back to MB in their site. In many (but not all) cases after 2007, the right release will have been added by a BBC editor, so you can check if any of the releases in the right release group were added by an editor named BBC_name. Other ways to find the right release are of course reading the review, check the date of the review (you can’t review something in the future…), and prefer UK releases over identical non-UK releases. Also, comparing the cover images does help often (although in rare cases it is wrong…).
If you find a review that is currently mapped to MusicBrainz, but wrongly, you can add it to the table at the bottom of the page, again with the MBID for the right release group and, if possible, the right release. We'll also give that information to the BBC.
Corrected reviews can be moved to Community Project/BBC Review Cleanup/Old. See Community_Project/BBC_Review_Cleanup/Problematic for reviews that need to be checked for correctness.