Community Project/BBC Review Cleanup

From MusicBrainz Wiki
< Community Project
Revision as of 13:03, 1 May 2013 by Hrglgrmpf (talk | contribs) (→‎Wrongly-linked reviews: Add "JS Bach - Complete Harpsichord Concertos")
Jump to navigationJump to search

This is a table of BBC reviews that are not linked to MusicBranz. If you find the correct release group, relate the review to it in MusicBrainz and add its MBID to the Release Group column. If you can also find which release it is for exactly, you can add that information to the Release column to help the BBC map them back to MB in their site. In many (but not all) cases after 2007, the right release will have been added by a BBC editor, so you can check if any of the releases in the right release group were added by an editor named BBC_name. Other ways to find the right release are of course reading the review, check the date of the review (you can’t review something in the future…), and prefer UK releases over identical non-UK releases. Also, comparing the cover images does help often (although in rare cases it is wrong…).

If you find a review that is currently mapped to MusicBrainz, but wrongly, you can add it to the table at the bottom of the page, again with the MBID for the right release group and, if possible, the right release. We'll also give that information to the BBC.

Corrected reviews can be moved to Community Project/BBC Review Cleanup/Old. See Community_Project/BBC_Review_Cleanup/Problematic for reviews that need to be checked for correctness.

Unlinked reviews

Review Release Group Release
Richard Thompson - Live at the BBC Not in MB yet
Ram Sampath - Delhi Belly Delhi Belly Probably not in MB
Rufus Wainwright - House of Rufus Not yet in MB Not yet in MB
Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy - Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara: Original Soundtrack Zindagi Milegi Na Dobara unknown, could be barcode 792097378796 or 8902894696296

Wrongly-linked reviews

Review Release Group Release
The Duke Spirit - Cuts Across The Land Cuts Across the Land
The Clash - London Calling - 25th Anniversary Edition correct The Clash - London Calling (25th anniversary edition)
Drive-By Truckers - Go-Go Boots correct Go-Go Boots
Peter Green - Man Of The World: The Anthology 1968-1988 correct Man of the World - The Anthology 1968-1988
Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath correct Black Sabbath
Dexys Midnight Runners - Searching For the Young Soul Rebels: 30th Anniversary Special Edition correct Searching for the Young Soul Rebels
Primal Scream - Screamadelica: Deluxe Edition correct Screamadelica (20th Anniversary Limited Collector's Edition)
R.E.M. - Fables of the Reconstruction correct Fables of the Reconstruction
Sly And The Family Stone - A Whole New Thing, Dance To The Music, Life, Stand!, There's A Riot Goin' On, Fresh, Small Talk multiple? seems to be a review for multiple release groups, so linking to one release seems impossible?
U2 - The Joshua Tree correct The Joshua Tree
Robert Fripp - Exposure correct Exposure
Deep Purple - Live In London correct Live in London
Joy Division - Still correct Still
Rush - Live In Rio (DVD) correct not in MB yet, most likely
Emerson, Lake And Palmer - The Original Bootleg Series From the Manticore Vaults Vols 1&2 not in MB yet / multiple not in MB yet / multiple
Various Artists - Gaz's Rockin' Blues not in MB yet not in MB yet
Various Artists - World 2003 World 2003 World 2003
Britten - Suites for Solo Cello
Poulenc - La Voix Humaine La Voix humaine La Voix humaine
Webern - String Quartets Complete Works for String Quartet and String Trio Complete Works for String Quartet and String Trio
Wagner - Scenes from The Ring Scenes From The Ring Scenes From The Ring
Richard Strauss - Orchestral Songs Orchestral Songs / Vier letzte Lieder
Dhafer Youssef & Wolfgang Muthspiel - Glow Dhafer Youssef & Wolfgang Muthspiel - Glow
Isaac Albéniz - Iberia Iberia Iberia
Isaac Albéniz - Iberia Iberia Iberia
JS Bach - St Matthew Passion St. Matthew Passion St. Matthew Passion
JS Bach - Complete Harpsichord Concertos Harpsichord Concertos / Triple Concerto BMW 1044 Harpsichord Concertos / Triple Concerto BMW 1044