Difference between revisions of "History:CSG Standard/Mozart/Spurious"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
(16 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
Here is a list of tracks that have been attributed to Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart erroneously.
 
Here is a list of tracks that have been attributed to Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart erroneously.
   
  +
Also see [[CSG Standard/Mozart]]
   
  +
=Spurious Works=
 
{| border="1"
 
{| border="1"
 
|-
 
|-
 
| '''K6''' || '''K1''' || '''Mvmnt''' || '''Title''' || '''Real Composer ''(if known)'''''
 
| '''K6''' || '''K1''' || '''Mvmnt''' || '''Title''' || '''Real Composer ''(if known)'''''
 
|-
 
|-
| 61f || 105 ||1|| 6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: I. (spurious)|| Michael Haydn <ref>[http://www.mozartforum.com/Lore/article.php?id=031 MozartForum: "Not by Mozart in K1"]</ref>
+
| 61f || 105 ||1|| 6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: I. (spurious)|| [http://www.mozartforum.com/Lore/article.php?id=031 Michael Haydn]
 
|-
 
|-
 
| 61f || 105 || 2||6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: II. (spurious) || Michael Haydn
 
| 61f || 105 || 2||6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: II. (spurious) || Michael Haydn
Line 18: Line 20:
 
| 61f || 105 || 6||6 Minuets for Orchestra in G major, K. 61f/105: VI. (spurious)|| Michael Haydn
 
| 61f || 105 || 6||6 Minuets for Orchestra in G major, K. 61f/105: VI. (spurious)|| Michael Haydn
 
|-
 
|-
  +
|73u || 44 || 1|| Antiphon for Chorus and Organ in A minor, K. 73u/44 (spurious): "Quaerite primum regnum Dei" ||Johann Stadlmayr
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 1|| Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): I. Allegro moderato|| Giuseppe Puschmann?<ref>[http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%208.htm MozartForum: "Köchel Part 8"]</ref>
 
  +
|-
  +
| 186i || 91 || 1|| Kyrie in D major, K. 186i/91 (spurious) || Composed by Georg Reutter (the younger), not Mozart. Mozart simply made a copy of the work.
  +
|-
  +
|588a || 106 |||1|| Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): I. Overture in D major||[http://www.mozartforum.com/Lore/article.php?id=031 Unknown]
  +
|-
  +
|588a || 106 ||2|| Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): II. Contredanse I in D major||Unknown
  +
|-
  +
|588a || 106 ||3|| Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): III. Contradanse II in A major||Unknown
  +
|-
  +
|588a || 106 ||4|| Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): IV. Contradanse III in B-flat major||Unknown
  +
|-
 
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 1|| Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): I. Allegro moderato||[http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%208.htm Giuseppe Puschmann?]
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 2||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): II. Minuetto|| Giuseppe Puschmann?
 
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 2||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): II. Minuetto|| Giuseppe Puschmann?
Line 28: Line 42:
 
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 5||Divetimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): V. Rondo|| Giuseppe Puschmann?
 
| Anh C 17.01 || Anh 226 || 5||Divetimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): V. Rondo|| Giuseppe Puschmann?
 
|-
 
|-
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 1||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): I. Allegro||Josef Fiala?<ref>[http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%208.htm MozartForum: "Köchel Part 8"]</ref>
+
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 1||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): I. Allegro||[http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%208.htm Josef Fiala?]
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 2||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): II. Minuetto||Josef Fiala?
 
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 2||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): II. Minuetto||Josef Fiala?
Line 38: Line 52:
 
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 5||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): V. Finale||Josef Fiala?
 
| Anh C 17.02 || Anh 226 || 5||Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): V. Finale||Josef Fiala?
 
|-
 
|-
  +
| Anh. C 23.07 || K61 || || Sonata for Piano and Violin in A major, K. Anh C23.07/K3 Anh 290a/61 (spurious)|| [http://www.mozartforum.com/Lore/article.php?id=031 Herman Freidrich Raupach] (but doesn't seem to have been recorded)
 
|}
 
|}
  +
  +
  +
<span id="doubtful"></span>
  +
=Works of doubtful authenticity=
  +
{| border="1"
  +
|-
  +
| '''K6''' || '''K1''' || '''Mvmnt''' || '''Title''' || '''More Info'''''
  +
|-
  +
| 196c || 292 || 1|| Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): I. Allegro|| doubtful in [http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%202.htm Köchel]
  +
|-
  +
| 196c || 292 || 2|| Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): II. Andante|| Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| 196c || 292 || 3|| Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): III. Rondo. Allegro || Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| 271i || deest || 1 || Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): I. Allegro maestoso || Doubtful in [http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%202.htm Köchel]
  +
|-
  +
| 271i || deest || 2 || Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in G major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): II. Andante|| Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| 271i || deest || 3 || Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): III. Rondo. Allegro|| Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| 297B || Anh 9 || 1|| Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): I. Allegro || Doubtful in [http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%203.htm Köchel]
  +
|-
  +
| 297B || Anh 9 || 2|| Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): II. Adagio || Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| 297B || Anh 9 || 3|| Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): III. Andantino con variazioni || Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| Anh C 14.01 || Anh 9 || 1 || Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): I. Allegro || Doubtful in [http://www.mozartforum.com/Koechel%20part%208.htm Köchel]
  +
|-
  +
| Anh C 14.01 || Anh 9 || 2 || Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): II. Adagio || Doubtful in Köchel
  +
|-
  +
| Anh C 14.01 || Anh 9 || 3 || Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): III. Andantino & Variations I - IX & Variation X. Andantino - adagio - allegro - più mosso || Doubtful in Köchel

Latest revision as of 16:32, 10 January 2013

Here is a list of tracks that have been attributed to Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart erroneously.

Also see CSG Standard/Mozart

Spurious Works

K6 K1 Mvmnt Title Real Composer (if known)
61f 105 1 6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: I. (spurious) Michael Haydn
61f 105 2 6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: II. (spurious) Michael Haydn
61f 105 3 6 Minuets for Orchestra in D major, K. 61f/105: III. (spurious) Michael Haydn
61f 105 4 6 Minuets for Orchestra in G major, K. 61f/105: IV. (spurious) Michael Haydn
61f 105 5 6 Minuets for Orchestra in G major, K. 61f/105: V. (spurious) Michael Haydn
61f 105 6 6 Minuets for Orchestra in G major, K. 61f/105: VI. (spurious) Michael Haydn
73u 44 1 Antiphon for Chorus and Organ in A minor, K. 73u/44 (spurious): "Quaerite primum regnum Dei" Johann Stadlmayr
186i 91 1 Kyrie in D major, K. 186i/91 (spurious) Composed by Georg Reutter (the younger), not Mozart. Mozart simply made a copy of the work.
588a 106 1 Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): I. Overture in D major Unknown
588a 106 2 Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): II. Contredanse I in D major Unknown
588a 106 3 Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): III. Contradanse II in A major Unknown
588a 106 4 Overture and 3 Contredances, K. 588a/106 (spurious): IV. Contradanse III in B-flat major Unknown
Anh C 17.01 Anh 226 1 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): I. Allegro moderato Giuseppe Puschmann?
Anh C 17.01 Anh 226 2 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): II. Minuetto Giuseppe Puschmann?
Anh C 17.01 Anh 226 3 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): III. Romance Giuseppe Puschmann?
Anh C 17.01 Anh 226 4 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): IV. Minuetto Giuseppe Puschmann?
Anh C 17.01 Anh 226 5 Divetimento for Wind Ensemble in E-flat major, K. Anh C 17.01/K3 196e/Anh 226 (spurious): V. Rondo Giuseppe Puschmann?
Anh C 17.02 Anh 226 1 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): I. Allegro Josef Fiala?
Anh C 17.02 Anh 226 2 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): II. Minuetto Josef Fiala?
Anh C 17.02 Anh 226 3 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): III. Adagio Josef Fiala?
Anh C 17.02 Anh 226 4 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): IV. Minuetto Josef Fiala?
Anh C 17.02 Anh 226 5 Divertimento for Wind Ensemble in B-flat major, K. Anh C 17.02/K3 196f/Anh 227 (spurious): V. Finale Josef Fiala?
Anh. C 23.07 K61 Sonata for Piano and Violin in A major, K. Anh C23.07/K3 Anh 290a/61 (spurious) Herman Freidrich Raupach (but doesn't seem to have been recorded)


Works of doubtful authenticity

K6 K1 Mvmnt Title More Info
196c 292 1 Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): I. Allegro doubtful in Köchel
196c 292 2 Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): II. Andante Doubtful in Köchel
196c 292 3 Sonata for 2 Bassoons (or Bassoon & Cello) in B-flat major, K. 196c/292 (doubtful): III. Rondo. Allegro Doubtful in Köchel
271i deest 1 Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): I. Allegro maestoso Doubtful in Köchel
271i deest 2 Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in G major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): II. Andante Doubtful in Köchel
271i deest 3 Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D major, K. 271i / K2 271a / KV deest (doubtful): III. Rondo. Allegro Doubtful in Köchel
297B Anh 9 1 Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): I. Allegro Doubtful in Köchel
297B Anh 9 2 Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): II. Adagio Doubtful in Köchel
297B Anh 9 3 Sinfonie concertante for Winds in E-flat major, K. 297B/Anh 9 (doubtful) (Robert Levin reconstruction): III. Andantino con variazioni Doubtful in Köchel
Anh C 14.01 Anh 9 1 Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): I. Allegro Doubtful in Köchel
Anh C 14.01 Anh 9 2 Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): II. Adagio Doubtful in Köchel
Anh C 14.01 Anh 9 3 Sinfonia Concertante for Oboe, Clarinet, Horn, Bassoon, & Orchestra in E-flat major, K. Anh C 14.01 / K3 297b / Anh 9 (doubtful): III. Andantino & Variations I - IX & Variation X. Andantino - adagio - allegro - più mosso Doubtful in Köchel