History:Label Future: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(@murdos (Imported from MoinMoin))
(Fixed tickets. Triaging (Imported from MoinMoin))
Line 12: Line 12:


* The subscription mail doesn't contain edits for subscribed labels (related to tickets [[Ticket:2675|2675]] & [[Ticket:884|884]])
* The subscription mail doesn't contain edits for subscribed labels (related to tickets [[Ticket:2675|2675]] & [[Ticket:884|884]])
* [[ModBot]] doesn't "collect" empty labels and doesn't delete them
⚫
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">I don't think the problem I describe is related. I don't receive any notification for edits that *are* attached to the labels entries (eg: merge labels). -- [[User:dmppanda|dmppanda]] 15:30, 11 April 2007 (UTC)
⚫
* [[Ticket:2682|2682]]: default label sort name
⚫
</ul>


==Easy enhancements==
==Easy enhancements==


List of suggested enhancements, supposedly easy to fix:
List of suggested enhancements, supposedly easy to fix:
* Style tasks:
===Style and doc tasks===
⚫
** discuss and rationalize the use of [[Special Purpose Label|SpecialPurposeLabel]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s (like [autorelease])
⚫
** discuss the use of collabs labels (see [[Talk:Label|LabelDiscussion]])


⚫
* discuss and rationalize the use of [[Special Purpose Label|SpecialPurposeLabel]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s (like [autorelease])
⚫
* discuss the use of collabs labels (see [[Talk:Label|LabelDiscussion]])
* Doc task: documentation is lacking a lot on label [[Edit Type|EditType]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s, and also [[Edit Label Page|EditLabelPage]]
* Doc task: documentation is lacking a lot on label [[Edit Type|EditType]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s, and also [[Edit Label Page|EditLabelPage]]
* Doc task: stuff examples in all existing documentation
* Doc task: stuff examples in all existing documentation
* Doc task: ACL and transclude all Label documentation
* Doc task: ACL and transclude all Label documentation

* [[Ticket:2696|2696]]: Direct search problem (probably not only label related)
===UI quirks / missing UI===
⚫
* [[Ticket:2687|2687]]: minor search for label hinch.
* [[Ticket:2684|2684]]: Nasty edits view sideways scrolling problem (Yet again)
⚫
* [[Ticket:2682|2682]]: default label sort name
* [[Ticket:2681|2681]]: Label graphs give error (verify this in a few days)
⚫
* [[Ticket:2675|2675]]: View label edits don't show [[Advanced Relationship|AdvancedRelationship]] edits related to the label
⚫
** see [[Ticket:884|884]]:


* [[Ticket:2674|2674]]: Add the possibility to search edits by label
* [[Ticket:2674|2674]]: Add the possibility to search edits by label
* [[Ticket:2669|2669]]: label pages lack inline voting frame.
* [[Ticket:2669|2669]]: label pages lack inline voting frame.
⚫
* [[Ticket:2687|2687]]: minor search for label hinch.
⚫
* [[Ticket:2658|2658]]: Server > Labels > "LabelX was renamed to LabelY" AR does not need begin & end dates
* [[Ticket:2657|2657]]: Server > Labels > New AR "ReleaseX was licensed from LabelY"
* [[Ticket:2684|2684]]: Nasty edits view sideways scrolling problem (Yet again)

===UI + back-end hack required===

* [[Ticket:2653|2653]]: Should get a warning/confirmation message when adding releases to holding label
* [[Ticket:2653|2653]]: Should get a warning/confirmation message when adding releases to holding label
* [[Ticket:2635|2635]]: Labels > Barcodes need to accept HYPHENS and SPACES
* [[Ticket:2635|2635]]: Labels > Barcodes need to accept HYPHENS and SPACES
* [[Ticket:2602|2602]]: Add a warning when duplicate barcodes are entered
* [[Ticket:2602|2602]]: Add a warning when duplicate barcodes are entered

===Questionnable enhancements===

* [[Ticket:2657|2657]]: Server > Labels > New AR "ReleaseX was licensed from LabelY"


==Other enhancements==
==Other enhancements==


List of enhancements with some (bigger or unknown) technical impact:
===List of enhancements with some (bigger or unknown) technical impact:===

* [[Ticket:2574|2574]]: Release date should not be mandatory in release event.
* [[Ticket:2574|2574]]: Release date should not be mandatory in release event.
⚫
* [[Ticket:2675|2675]]: View label edits don't show [[Advanced Relationship|AdvancedRelationship]] edits related to the label
⚫
** see [[Ticket:884|884]]:

===Wontfix for now:===

⚫
* [[Ticket:2658|2658]]: Server > Labels > "LabelX was renamed to LabelY" AR does not need begin & end dates
⚫
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">This raise the question of "extending" the AR tree so that it supports an extra information about AR (having dates or not) -- [[User:dmppanda|dmppanda]] 15:44, 23 April 2007 (UTC)
⚫
</ul>


==Needs research==
==Needs research==

Revision as of 15:44, 23 April 2007

Template:LabelsStatus

Template:LabelNavigation

Label future

Purpose

This page should be used to collect the various limitations and known bugs of the current label system in MusicBrainz, as well as ideas about how to enhance it and make it evolves toward a better model.

Outstanding bugs

  • The subscription mail doesn't contain edits for subscribed labels (related to tickets 2675 & 884)
  • ModBot doesn't "collect" empty labels and doesn't delete them
  • 2682: default label sort name

Easy enhancements

List of suggested enhancements, supposedly easy to fix:

Style and doc tasks

  • discuss and rationalize the use of SpecialPurposeLabels (like [autorelease])
  • discuss the use of collabs labels (see LabelDiscussion)
  • Doc task: documentation is lacking a lot on label EditTypes, and also EditLabelPage
  • Doc task: stuff examples in all existing documentation
  • Doc task: ACL and transclude all Label documentation

UI quirks / missing UI

  • 2674: Add the possibility to search edits by label
  • 2669: label pages lack inline voting frame.
  • 2687: minor search for label hinch.
  • 2684: Nasty edits view sideways scrolling problem (Yet again)

UI + back-end hack required

  • 2653: Should get a warning/confirmation message when adding releases to holding label
  • 2635: Labels > Barcodes need to accept HYPHENS and SPACES
  • 2602: Add a warning when duplicate barcodes are entered

Questionnable enhancements

  • 2657: Server > Labels > New AR "ReleaseX was licensed from LabelY"

Other enhancements

List of enhancements with some (bigger or unknown) technical impact:

Wontfix for now:

  • 2658: Server > Labels > "LabelX was renamed to LabelY" AR does not need begin & end dates
  • This raise the question of "extending" the AR tree so that it supports an extra information about AR (having dates or not) -- dmppanda 15:44, 23 April 2007 (UTC)

Needs research

  • There have been some discussion lately about concurrent/additional label identification systems in the wild, apparently dependent of the country. At that time, we lack informations about how these relate to the Label Code system, and there is no solution foreseen. Please provide input on that thread if you have more informations. Please AnswerMe if you do. -- dmppanda 19:28, 29 January 2007 (UTC)

NGS/Pie in the sky

None

Controversial

None

Wontfix

None

Template:LabelIntertwingling

Retrieved from "https://wiki.musicbrainz.org/index.php?title=History:Label_Future&oldid=7312"