Difference between revisions of "History:Prefer Specific Relationship Types Proposal"
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search (Reorganized, added text to be added to other pages after implementation of RFC-251) |
m (CallerNo6 moved page Proposal:Prefer Specific Relationship Types to History:Prefer Specific Relationship Types Proposal: https://chatlogs.metabrainz.org/brainzbot/metabrainz/msg/3675767/) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
* Be as specific as possible and specify the type of engineering position that was held, but only if you have a source or if you can deduce this information. For details, see the [[Advanced_Relationship_Style#Prefer_Specific_Relationship_Types|Prefer Specific Relationship Types]] guideline. |
* Be as specific as possible and specify the type of engineering position that was held, but only if you have a source or if you can deduce this information. For details, see the [[Advanced_Relationship_Style#Prefer_Specific_Relationship_Types|Prefer Specific Relationship Types]] guideline. |
||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | ==Writer AR== |
||
| − | If/when the writer relationship is added, add: |
||
| − | * [[Proposal:Writer_Relationship_Type|Writer]]: prefer [[Composer_Relationship_Type|Composer]], [[Lyricist_Relationship_Type|Lyricist]] and/or [[Librettist_Relationship_Type|Librettist]] |
||
Latest revision as of 20:33, 28 August 2016
This proposal has now passed, see Advanced Relationship Style, however, two lines depend on other changes, those have been left here until the relevant changes happen.
RFC-251
When RFC-251 is implemented, change:
- Engineer: prefer Audio Engineer, Editor, Mastering Engineer, Mix Engineer, Recording Engineer, Sound Engineer and/or Programmer. If the Engineer type is either Balance Engineer or Tonmeister, the generic Engineer type should be used, and not one of the more specific Engineer types.
to
- Engineer: prefer selecting the correct information from the Engineer tree.
- Engineer Position: prefer selecting the correct information from the Engineer tree.
and on Engineer_Relationship_Type, change:
- In many cases, the Audio Engineer, Editor, Mastering Engineer, Mix Engineer, Recording Engineer, Sound Engineer and/or Programmer relationship types should be used instead. If the Engineer relationship type is either Balance Engineer or Tonmeister, the generic Engineer relationship type should be used, and not one of the more specific Engineer relationship types. For details, see the Prefer Specific Relationship Types guideline.
to
- Be as specific as possible and specify the type of engineering that was performed, but only if you have a source or if you can deduce this information. For details, see the Prefer Specific Relationship Types guideline.
and to Engineer_Position_Relationship_Type, add:
- Be as specific as possible and specify the type of engineering position that was held, but only if you have a source or if you can deduce this information. For details, see the Prefer Specific Relationship Types guideline.
