History talk:Style/Track and release titles: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(New page: While discussing this guideline with reosarevok on IRC, he would prefer the intent of the guideline is clarified. The relevant parts of this discussion have been reproduced below: 12:5...)
(No difference)

Revision as of 12:04, 7 February 2011

While discussing this guideline with reosarevok on IRC, he would prefer the intent of the guideline is clarified. The relevant parts of this discussion have been reproduced below:

 12:53 <warp> even the capture the cover people probably do not want most western 
       pop releases to be ENTERED LIKE THIS in the database.
 12:54 <reosarevok> Yeah, that's clear... but what's the point on following the 
       cover when it doesn't show any intent, just the fact that the artist / 
       designer has no idea of how his own language works?
 12:54 <reosarevok> (am I supposed to also leave diacritics out because they can't
       be arsed to use them?)
 12:56 <warp> in general it is very difficult to determine what is accidental and 
       what is intentional.  if we're reasonably convinced an error is not 
       intentional, it should be fix -- wether that is a typo or capitalization.
 12:56 <reosarevok> Ok
 12:56 <reosarevok> Add that to the guideline and I'll agree with it :D
 12:57 <warp> ok :)