Non-Album Track: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(plural ``s (Imported from MoinMoin))
 
(MusicBrainzIdentifier``s (Imported from MoinMoin))
Line 30: Line 30:
</ul>
</ul>
* '''''Submit'' the [[TRM]]s''':
* '''''Submit'' the [[TRM]]s''':
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">Non-album tracks with no associated TRMs are fairly useless, since they cannot be matched by track number or disc id, and matching by track name is unlikely to tell you anything you didn't already know. If you add a non-album track, it's presumably because you have an MP3 or other sound file for it. Tagging your file with MusicBrainzIDs is only half the work; you need to submit the TRM to the [[MusicBrainz]] database so that the entry is useful to others. If you don't, the entry is likely to be "garbage collected" for lack of TRMs later on.
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">Non-album tracks with no associated TRMs are fairly useless, since they cannot be matched by track number or disc id, and matching by track name is unlikely to tell you anything you didn't already know. If you add a non-album track, it's presumably because you have an MP3 or other sound file for it. Tagging your file with [[MusicBrainz Identifier|MusicBrainzIdentifier]]<code><nowiki></nowiki></code>s is only half the work; you need to submit the TRM to the [[MusicBrainz]] database so that the entry is useful to others. If you don't, the entry is likely to be "garbage collected" for lack of TRMs later on.
</ul>
</ul>



Revision as of 16:12, 27 October 2005

Non-Album Tracks

Musical tracks that are associated with an artist but have not been released on any album (or single, or compilation, etc.) are grouped together under the pseudo-album NonAlbumTracks.

While it's tempting for LazyModerators to use these as "a dumping ground for dodgy internet sourced mp3s," this tendency should be (and is) resisted; an AddTrack edit for a non-album track without a good ModerationNote is very likely to fail a vote. Although the StyleGuidelines don't spell this out explicitly (as they should) there are a few valid reasons for creating a NonAlbumTrack:

  • Internet-only release:
  • Often, before an album is released, songs from the album may be available on an internet site for download, and may be entered as non-album tracks; however, once the album (or single) with such a track is entered into the database, the non-album track should be removed with RemoveTrack. Less frequently, some such tracks are available for download, but are never included in any album or compilation.
  • Captured from broadcast performance:
  • A song may be performed as part of a TV or radio show or other non-concert performance; tracks captured from these events may be entered as non-album tracks if they are not part of any live album or bootleg compilation.
  • Pre-gap (track 0) tracks:
  • Tracks hidden in other tracks:
  • Another kind of HiddenTracks are those where a single (very long) track has music, then a long silence (or noise), followed by one or more (different) pieces of music. Since there is no support for TrackSections, these can be entered as non-album tracks, although there is not complete consensus on this.

Conversely, there are some cases that should not use non-album tracks, even though it might seem applicable:

  • MP3 CD-ROM collections:
  • Sometimes an artist or label will release a number of songs as MP3 files on a CD-ROM rather than as an audio disc; these should be entered as normal albums (or compilations, etc. if that is more appropriate). If there is no explicit track order in the filenames, they should be listed in alphabetical order as that is how most MP3 CD-ROM capable players will play them.
  • Track "99":
  • A third type of HiddenTracks are those that are separate tracks, but are preceded by dozens of short tracks of [silence]; since these can and should be listed as tracks of the album, they are not non-album tracks.

Finally, there are some other guidelines for use of non-album tracks:

  • Use informative titles:
  • Since non-album tracks don't have album release dates or other information associated with them, adding information like "(live, 2002-05-13: Radio One)" is very helpful. Using titles like "[untitled]" or "[unknown]" is sure to get the track voted down or removed.
  • Non-album tracks with no associated TRMs are fairly useless, since they cannot be matched by track number or disc id, and matching by track name is unlikely to tell you anything you didn't already know. If you add a non-album track, it's presumably because you have an MP3 or other sound file for it. Tagging your file with MusicBrainzIdentifiers is only half the work; you need to submit the TRM to the MusicBrainz database so that the entry is useful to others. If you don't, the entry is likely to be "garbage collected" for lack of TRMs later on.


Bug report 826167 suggests that non-album tracks be called something else, like:

or better yet, replaced with a general mechanism for non-album collections of tracks with no order.


Author: @alex