Difference between revisions of "Proposal:Artist Type Other"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
(New page: {{Template:proposal |proposal=326 |discussion= |champion=hrglgrmpf |rfc= |rfv= |status= |ar= |style= |trac= }} =Artist Type: Other= This proposal is about a new [[Artist Type|ArtistType]...)
 
(Update 1)
Line 22: Line 22:
 
# Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type
 
# Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type
 
# "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote
 
# "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote
 +
 +
== Update 1 ==
 +
 +
If this proposal passes and the "Other" type gets implemented, the [[Artist Type|old wiki page]] would get replaced by [[User:hrglgrmpf/Artist Type|this one]]. --[[User:Hrglgrmpf|Hrglgrmpf]] 00:39, 12 July 2011 (UTC)

Revision as of 00:39, 12 July 2011


Status: This page describes an active proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-326
Champion: hrglgrmpf
Current status: Unknown



Artist Type: Other

This proposal is about a new ArtistType "Other". Many artists don't fit into the Group/Person scheme, e.g.:

  1. Some fictional characters (animals, mythical creatures, ...), e.g.: Pumuckl and Elmo
  2. Some fictional artists are purely created to keep a series together, e.g. Die drei ???
  3. Companies that were created to credit them in a relationship, but that are not labels, e.g. Type2error

There are probably even more categories. Because all of them are pretty rare compared to Person/Group and are not really in the focus of this database, I suggest a catch-all type "Other" for them. Using "Unknown" is not a really good alternative, because

  1. Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type
  2. "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote

Update 1

If this proposal passes and the "Other" type gets implemented, the old wiki page would get replaced by this one. --Hrglgrmpf 00:39, 12 July 2011 (UTC)