Proposal:Artist Type Other: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(New page: {{Template:proposal |proposal=326 |discussion= |champion=hrglgrmpf |rfc= |rfv= |status= |ar= |style= |trac= }} =Artist Type: Other= This proposal is about a new [[Artist Type|ArtistType]...) |
(Update 1) |
||
Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
# Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type |
# Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type |
||
# "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote |
# "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote |
||
== Update 1 == |
|||
If this proposal passes and the "Other" type gets implemented, the [[Artist Type|old wiki page]] would get replaced by [[User:hrglgrmpf/Artist Type|this one]]. --[[User:Hrglgrmpf|Hrglgrmpf]] 00:39, 12 July 2011 (UTC) |
Revision as of 00:39, 12 July 2011
Status: This page describes an active proposal and is not official. |
|
Artist Type: Other
This proposal is about a new ArtistType "Other". Many artists don't fit into the Group/Person scheme, e.g.:
- Some fictional characters (animals, mythical creatures, ...), e.g.: Pumuckl and Elmo
- Some fictional artists are purely created to keep a series together, e.g. Die drei ???
- Companies that were created to credit them in a relationship, but that are not labels, e.g. Type2error
There are probably even more categories. Because all of them are pretty rare compared to Person/Group and are not really in the focus of this database, I suggest a catch-all type "Other" for them. Using "Unknown" is not a really good alternative, because
- Searching for "Unknown" artists should only show artists where further research will eventually result in another type
- "Unknown" artists can be changed to any type as auto-edit, so if someone wants to leave an artist "Unknown" on purpose, anybody can change the type without vote
Update 1
If this proposal passes and the "Other" type gets implemented, the old wiki page would get replaced by this one. --Hrglgrmpf 00:39, 12 July 2011 (UTC)