Proposal:Featured Artists: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Add note on advantage of recording artist credits)
No edit summary
Line 15: Line 15:
== Guideline ==
== Guideline ==


At the track-listing level:
At the track-listing, release and release group level:


# File the track/release under the normal primary artist.
# File the track/release under the normal primary artist.

Revision as of 19:23, 13 July 2011


Status: This page describes an active style guideline proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-327
Champion: Gnu_andrew
Current status: Unknown



This guideline applies to cases in which one or more artists are featured on a track or release by another artist, but not equally as they would be in a collaboration. That is, they are given credit on the cover or track listing of a release by another artist in a manner which elevates their contribution above normal liner note credits. Often, the word "featured", "feat." or "featuring" proceeds their name(s).

Guideline

At the track-listing, release and release group level:

  1. File the track/release under the normal primary artist.
  2. Append the name of the secondary artist(s) to the Track Title/Release Title as follows:
    • "Put Your Lights On (feat. Everlast)"

We retain the following pre-NGS guideline while the legacy ws/1 guideline remains in place. This prevents legacy users suddenly being overwhelmed by the appearance of numerous "X feat. Y" pseudo-artists. These are created by the webservice as it doesn't handle artist credits.

At the recording level:

  1. Fill out the artist credits for the primary artist(s) in the usual manner.
  2. Add a join phrase of ' feat. ' (note the surrounding spaces)
  3. Add the first featured artist.
  4. Add additional featured artists, each separated by ', ' and the final one separated by ' & '.

This has the advantage that the recording is listed under all credited artists, not just the primary ones. In example three below, this makes the recording appear under all seven artists rather than just the one.

In both cases:

  1. Add Relationships of the appropriate Relationship Class (usually Performance) to link to the featured artist(s') entries in MusicBrainz.


Details

  • The TrackArtist/ReleaseArtist is the main artist a track/release is credited to. This means, the artist mentioned on the release cover (in most cases the front cover), package or any other labelled package like entity that describes the release (e.g. release page for online releases).
  • Featured artists tend to be performers, but they can also be contributors to the technical production process (mixers, producers, record engineers, etc.), remixers and others. The different roles are explained in Compilation Relationship Class, Composition Relationship Class, Production Relationship Class, Remix Relationship Class. Note, that composers are often the main artists of classical releases (see ClassicalStyleGuide) and remixers or compilers can also be main artists if they fit into 1.
  • If a track features both "Foo" and "Bar", it should be entered as "... (feat. Foo & Bar)". For more than two: "... (feat. Foo, Bar, Baz ... & Quux)".

Examples

The following examples give the appropriate credits at both track and recording level.

  1. Track-level: "Umbrella (feat. Jay-Z)" by Rihanna
    1. artist-credit-1: Rihanna
    2. join-phrase-1: ' feat. '
    3. artist-credit-2: Jay-Z
  2. Track-level: "4 Minutes (feat. Justin Timberlake & Timbaland)" by Madonna
    1. artist-credit-1: Madonna
    2. join-phrase-1: ' feat. '
    3. artist-credit-2: Justin Timberlake
    4. join-phrase-2: ' & '
    5. artist-credit-3: Timbaland
  3. Track-level: "Game Over (feat. Giggs, Professor Green, Tinie Tempah, Devlin, Example & Chipmunk)" by Tinchy Stryder
    1. artist-credit-1: Tinchy Stryder
    2. join-phrase-1: ' feat. '
    3. artist-credit-2: Giggs
    4. join-phrase-2: ', '
    5. artist-credit-3: Professor Green
    6. join-phrase-3: ', '
    7. artist-credit-4: Tinie Tempah
    8. join-phrase-4: ', '
    9. artist-credit-5: Devlin
    10. join-phrase-5: ', '
    11. artist-credit-6: Example
    12. join-phrase-6: ' & '
    13. artist-credit-7: Chipmunk