Difference between revisions of "Release groups usage guideline"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
(New page: 21:32 <@ruaok> http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/5155 21:32 <@ruaok> this is the "release groups are confusing" ticket. 21:32 <@ruaok> we need to create a style guideline for using relea...)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
Current Musicbrainz server release feature a concept called '''Release Groups'''. Just as the name suggests, it groups several releases together in one entity. Since this is not obviously clear, this page aims to explain the difference and to give some guidelines on how to handle them.
  
21:32 <@ruaok> http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/5155
+
Both release groups and releases are "albums" in colloquial sense, but with a slight difference: a release is something you can buy as media, e.g. a CD box, a vinyl record etc, while a release group embraces the concept of an album -- it doesn't matter how many CDs it had or whether it has been released as a cassette. When an artist tells you "We've released our new album", he's talking about a release group. When his publisher says "This new album gets released next week in Japan and next month in Europe", he's talking about several releases belonging to the release group the artist has told you about.
21:32 <@ruaok> this is the "release groups are confusing" ticket.
 
21:32 <@ruaok> we need to create a style guideline for using release groups.
 
21:32 <@ruaok> I'd like to find a volunteer who could take this on.
 
21:33 <@ruaok> it would involve:
 
21:33 <@ruaok> 1. Talking to luks/me
 
21:33 <@ruaok> 2. writing up a preliminary guideline
 
21:33 <@ruaok> 3. put it up for review.
 
21:33 <@ruaok> 4. Edit and fix
 
21:33 <@ruaok> 5. publish by the server release date.
 
  
Content coming up!
+
Musicbrainz automatically considers a single release to be part of a release group, even if this group only contains this one release. Therefore, grouping releases only requires merging several release groups. The following criteria should help you to decide which releases should be merged and which should not.
 +
 
 +
Should be merged:
 +
 
 +
* Slightly different versions of the same release, e.g. variations of Nirvana's [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/0da3291e-e864-40de-9bc2-b64abf2c3795.html "Nevermind"]
 +
* A release with a bonus disc, e.g. The Corrs' [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/0816e5ac-e9e2-4b85-9e92-d86e19a36fe6.html "In Blue"]
 +
* A multiple-disc compilation, e.g. a release group [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/e28bca11-ee27-4a6a-be5c-9848fc7f26a1.html "Bravo Hits 64"] containing both CDs from the jewel case
 +
* A multiple-disc release in a box, e.g. Richard Wagner's [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/ad7b2786-404c-4d7b-a679-8de5e76c0507.html "Ring der Nibelungen"]
 +
* Multiple-disc "Best of" compilations, e.g. Joe Dassins [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/f627bff5-db93-40da-baad-2b3bc54d4b63.html "Intégrale"]
 +
 
 +
Should '''not''' be merged:
 +
 
 +
* Compilation series like "Café del Mar" or "That's what I call music!". A particular double-CD is usually a release group, but not the whole series.

Revision as of 00:04, 21 May 2009

Current Musicbrainz server release feature a concept called Release Groups. Just as the name suggests, it groups several releases together in one entity. Since this is not obviously clear, this page aims to explain the difference and to give some guidelines on how to handle them.

Both release groups and releases are "albums" in colloquial sense, but with a slight difference: a release is something you can buy as media, e.g. a CD box, a vinyl record etc, while a release group embraces the concept of an album -- it doesn't matter how many CDs it had or whether it has been released as a cassette. When an artist tells you "We've released our new album", he's talking about a release group. When his publisher says "This new album gets released next week in Japan and next month in Europe", he's talking about several releases belonging to the release group the artist has told you about.

Musicbrainz automatically considers a single release to be part of a release group, even if this group only contains this one release. Therefore, grouping releases only requires merging several release groups. The following criteria should help you to decide which releases should be merged and which should not.

Should be merged:

  • Slightly different versions of the same release, e.g. variations of Nirvana's "Nevermind"
  • A release with a bonus disc, e.g. The Corrs' "In Blue"
  • A multiple-disc compilation, e.g. a release group "Bravo Hits 64" containing both CDs from the jewel case
  • A multiple-disc release in a box, e.g. Richard Wagner's "Ring der Nibelungen"
  • Multiple-disc "Best of" compilations, e.g. Joe Dassins "Intégrale"

Should not be merged:

  • Compilation series like "Café del Mar" or "That's what I call music!". A particular double-CD is usually a release group, but not the whole series.