Style/Artist/With multiple names

Artists performing under different names

Some musicians perform using an "alias" which is different from their "real-life" name. The reasons for that vary - usually marketing, or to hide their actual identity (as to workaround legal issues when they signed exclusive contracts), etc...

In MusicBrainz, we refer to such monikers as PerformanceNames, as opposed to LegalNames. Note that PerformanceNames don't apply to groups.

Please also pay attention to the fact that "ArtistAlias" in MusicBrainz has a different meaning! (unlike what is done, for example, in Discogs).

Style

So, what name should I use for a musician: performance or legal name?

The simple answer is: PerformanceName - when entering a new release into the database, you should just use whatever name is credited as the PrimaryArtist.

In some cases obviously (if the artist is also performing under other PerformanceNames which already exist in the database), that indeed means creating a new distinct artist entry for the same person.

I just added a new (PerformanceName) artist to the database. Should I go ahead and create another entry for the LegalName as well?

Usually, no - you may just add that information to the ArtistAnnotation.

What to do if a musician uses multiple different PerformanceNames on various different releases?

You should create one artist entry for each different PerformanceName - though, please read the section below about cases when it doesn't make sense to create such new entries.

Should I also create artist entries for "other" nicknames?

MusicBrainz focuses mainly on documenting releases: if the nickname in question is not used on any release (but only by the artist relatives for example), then this is not relevant and you shouldn't create an artist entry for it (though you may add the detail to the ArtistAnnotation).

If a musician has multiple different performance names, how will these multiple entries be related?

Various different PerformanceNames for a given artist may be related using a PerformanceNameRelationshipType. As to avoid making circular relations and other linking nightmare (see DontMakeRelationshipClusters), we relate all PerformanceNames to the artist LegalName, instead of linking each PerformanceName to each other.

Specifically, this is were LegalNames are useful, and you may now create a new artist entry using the artist LegalName as a name, then relate all the artist's PerformanceNames to this new entry.

But, what to do if the musician had multiple different LegalNames?

The concept of LegalName itself is a quite debated one, and this was the subject of many discussions and various suggestions. Our policy at that time is simple: use only one LegalName for the artist (pick the birth name, usually found on birth certificates). If no one knows for sure, just pick the most probable one, and write an annotation mentioning all that.

Does it always make sense to create distinct entries?

No. In a lot of cases, the name variation (either between different PerformanceNames, or between the LegalName and a given PerformanceName) is minor enough to make the splitting not worth the effort. In such cases, you should not create distinct entries (you may still use the ArtistAnnotation to provide additional details, and possibly use ArtistAliases to enhance search results).

A few examples of when there is little benefit in creating distinct artist entries:

• common use abbreviations for first names (Robert Marley vs Bob Marley)
• first names shortened to initials (Kate Tunstall vs K.T. Tunstall)
• middle names added/omitted (Elvin Ray Jones vs Elvin Jones)
• additional nicknames ("Baron" Charles Mingus vs Charles Mingus)

Remember, though, that ArtistIntent may come into play - and some artists may put a lot of meaning into a minor name variation. Ultimately, reasonable judgment, common sense and knowledge about the artist production should prevail in choosing which name differences are significant or not.

Should I duplicate the artist birth and death dates between the Legal and Performance names?

Though this issue was debated in the past, it's now agreed that the duplication is not essentially bad, so, yes, you may add birth and death dates to both the Legal and Performance names.

What about personal relationships? Should I duplicate them as well?

No, personal relationships should not be duplicated, and you should favor using the LegalName to hold them.

Examples

• Declan Patrick MacManus is the Legal Name of Elvis Costello. Abbey Lincoln is a performance name for the person Anna Marie Wooldridge (who later changed her legal name to Animata Moseka). Though, as she only performs as Abbey Lincoln, only this entry was created in the database. Aphex Twin, AFX and Caustic Window are all Performance Names of Richard David James.

History and advanced readings

There were for a long time a number of issues surrounding these problems. If you're interested in the various discussions and solutions that were raised, you may take a look at DateOfBirthStyle and LinkingDifferentArtistNames.

---