Style/Recording: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
Line 16: Line 16:
* shouldn't merge different performances (which includes re-recordings, live versions and versions with different lyrics)
* shouldn't merge different performances (which includes re-recordings, live versions and versions with different lyrics)
* shouldn't merge different recordings of a performance (e.g. a live bootleg recorded by multiple people)
* shouldn't merge different recordings of a performance (e.g. a live bootleg recorded by multiple people)
* shouldn't merge different edits, mixes or remixes of a performance.
* shouldn't merge different edits, mixes, remixes or remasters of a performance.
* shouldn't merge recordings which have conflicting relationships.
* shouldn't merge recordings which have conflicting relationships.



Revision as of 10:58, 18 May 2011

Status: This is an official style guideline.

Title

See the guidelines for recording and release group titles for how to enter the recording's title.

Artist

The artist should usually be the same as the first release of the recording.

What should and shouldn't be merged together?

A recording is intended to represent unique audio. This means you:

  • should normally merge recordings with the same ISRC.
  • should normally not merge recordings with different ISRCs.
  • shouldn't merge different performances (which includes re-recordings, live versions and versions with different lyrics)
  • shouldn't merge different recordings of a performance (e.g. a live bootleg recorded by multiple people)
  • shouldn't merge different edits, mixes, remixes or remasters of a performance.
  • shouldn't merge recordings which have conflicting relationships.

ISRCs

An ISRC should, in theory, correspond to a single recording in MusicBrainz and a recording should correspond to a single ISRC. However, in practice, mistakes are sometimes made. In such cases, annotations are recommended.