Style/Work: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
< Style
Jump to navigationJump to search
Reosarevok (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Reosarevok (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
* [[work:c366ec5b-9d61-3057-827c-afd61a237b23|Beethoven's ''Sonata Pathétique'']] is set to "Sonata", but [[work:e1c58466-6c16-3e01-a52c-2483f041b84f|its first movement]] should not have a type, since it's not itself a sonata (nor does it fit any other existing work type). |
* [[work:c366ec5b-9d61-3057-827c-afd61a237b23|Beethoven's ''Sonata Pathétique'']] is set to "Sonata", but [[work:e1c58466-6c16-3e01-a52c-2483f041b84f|its first movement]] should not have a type, since it's not itself a sonata (nor does it fit any other existing work type). |
||
* [[work:16a894eb-3164-4e69-b2e3-d0b1db71c2a8|Schubert's ''Winterreise'']] is set to "Song-cycle", while [[work:485e9c1b-8b7f-32cd-8511-83f0259088e8|its first part, ''Gute Nacht'']] is set to "Song". |
* [[work:16a894eb-3164-4e69-b2e3-d0b1db71c2a8|Schubert's ''Winterreise'']] is set to "Song-cycle", while [[work:485e9c1b-8b7f-32cd-8511-83f0259088e8|its first part, ''Gute Nacht'']] is set to "Song". |
||
* [[work:2df0e3f6-8007-41ee-b4d7-fda3e3657597|John Williams' soundtrack for ''Star Wars, Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back'']] is set to "Soundtrack", but [[work:c06f8010-b294-3c41-be3e-da4a834668e4|the Imperial March]] should not be. |
* [[work:2df0e3f6-8007-41ee-b4d7-fda3e3657597|John Williams' soundtrack for ''Star Wars, Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back'']] is set to "Soundtrack", but [[work:c06f8010-b294-3c41-be3e-da4a834668e4|the Imperial March]] should not be, since it's not itself a soundtrack, just part of one. |
||
== Disambiguation comment== |
== Disambiguation comment== |
||
Revision as of 18:56, 23 February 2018
| Status: This is an official style guideline. |
Type
Work types should only be used on works that specifically match the chosen type (not every work needs to have a work type!).
- Beethoven's Sonata Pathétique is set to "Sonata", but its first movement should not have a type, since it's not itself a sonata (nor does it fit any other existing work type).
- Schubert's Winterreise is set to "Song-cycle", while its first part, Gute Nacht is set to "Song".
- John Williams' soundtrack for Star Wars, Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back is set to "Soundtrack", but the Imperial March should not be, since it's not itself a soundtrack, just part of one.
Disambiguation comment
Add disambiguation comments only when two (or more) works are similar enough to be confused, not just because they have the same name. For example, there's not much use in adding "Scorpions song" to Blackout just because other artists have songs called Blackout. On the other hand, a translation of a work with the same name as the original might deserve a disambiguation to make it more obvious, like with Dreams come true ("Japanese version") by BoA and the original Korean version.
