Talk:BrianFreud/Special Purpose Artist: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==warp's comments== |
|||
This page looks rather messy to me, my comments here are not about the guideline itself, but should be viewed in the context of trying to clean things up for a Post NGS (see [[User:kuno/Post_NGS_Style]])). |
This page looks rather messy to me, my comments here are not about the guideline itself, but should be viewed in the context of trying to clean things up for a Post NGS (see [[User:kuno/Post_NGS_Style]])). |
||
===toc=== |
|||
The table of contents is completely unreadable, can you remove "Special Purpose Artists" from all of the headings? We're already on |
The table of contents is completely unreadable, can you remove "Special Purpose Artists" from all of the headings? We're already on |
||
the SPA page, it doesn't have to be repeated in every heading. |
the SPA page, it doesn't have to be repeated in every heading. |
||
===Adding new Special Purpose Artists=== |
|||
I am not sure the "Adding new SPAs" stuff is needed. I'm trying to get the guidelines as clear and concise as possible, and this seems like clutter. This will be an official guideline, I think it is sufficient to have a statement somewhere else that any changes to the official guidelines need to go through the StyleCouncil -- this doesn't have to be included in a guideline page. |
I am not sure the "Adding new SPAs" stuff is needed. I'm trying to get the guidelines as clear and concise as possible, and this seems like clutter. This will be an official guideline, I think it is sufficient to have a statement somewhere else that any changes to the official guidelines need to go through the StyleCouncil -- this doesn't have to be included in a guideline page. |
Revision as of 08:36, 6 December 2009
warp's comments
This page looks rather messy to me, my comments here are not about the guideline itself, but should be viewed in the context of trying to clean things up for a Post NGS (see User:kuno/Post_NGS_Style)).
The table of contents is completely unreadable, can you remove "Special Purpose Artists" from all of the headings? We're already on the SPA page, it doesn't have to be repeated in every heading.
I am not sure the "Adding new SPAs" stuff is needed. I'm trying to get the guidelines as clear and concise as possible, and this seems like clutter. This will be an official guideline, I think it is sufficient to have a statement somewhere else that any changes to the official guidelines need to go through the StyleCouncil -- this doesn't have to be included in a guideline page.