Talk:Production Relationship Class

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

I could not find the follwoing two in the interface are they just planned or what?

  • Recorded at: The RecordedAtRelationshipType allows the place that a work was recorded to be added as a relationship.
  • Label: This links a work to the label that it is published under.


I have to comment here, that I think there's far too much detail available in this class. I think that data should be recorded only where there's a real use for it, and I can't think of any conceivable use for recording "arranged the travel for", or several other of the relationship types given here, and I can't think why anyone would ever be bothered to add this information. These relationship types seem only to obscure the genuinely important ones, like "produced" and label relationships. I would like to see this simplified. I should probably therefore come up with a more concrete proposal and add it as an AdvancedRelationshipTypeProposal. I'll get on to that RSN. --Matthew Exon

  • The source file was incorrectly copied. The types you complained about are all sub-types of the Misc type. I moved them out of here because they cluttered the page. I still think they are good because they should allow to represent all the details that are written in the liner notes. --DonRedman
    • That's a big improvement. With all that stuff on a separate page, it seems like much less of a problem :-) Thanks. --MatthewExon