Difference between revisions of "Talk:What Is A Cover"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (New page: ''This discussion stems from before AdvancedRelationships were released'' Reading the above, I would suggest instead distinguishing "recordings" from "composit...)
Line 1: Line 1:
#REDIRECT [[Talk:Cover_Relationship_Type]]
''This discussion stems from before [[Advanced Relationships|AdvancedRelationships]] were released''
Reading the above, I would suggest instead distinguishing "recordings" from "compositions". All cover recordings of a work would then be related to the same composition, as would "the original." --JoeG
Thinking of Jazz, that seems very logical to me. In Jazz musicans don't do covers, they make versions of songs but they give credit to the original composer. So I would argue that the [[Composer Relationship Type|ComposerRelationshipType]] is factual, and that the [[Cover Relationship Type|CoverRelationshipType]] includes the opinion of the moderator, which song was the original for that specific recording. --[[User:DonRedman|DonRedman]]
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">This somewhat applies to the folk and traditional music scene as well, for the record. -- [[User:FrederikSOlesen|FrederikSOlesen]] 09:00, 10 May 2007 (UTC)
The question of parodies [http://lists.musicbrainz.org/pipermail/musicbrainz-users/2005-June/020966.html was raised] on the [[Users Mailing List|UsersMailingList]]. These possibly count as covers too, although there's no consensus yet. --[[User:MatthewExon|MatthewExon]]
<ul><li style="list-style-type:none">I think this too could be solved by the idea mentioned above, decoupling compositions from recordings. While there may be debate over whether a song parody constitutes a cover of the original recording, it definitely uses the music or lyrics from it. --[[User:LarryGilbert|LarryGilbert]]
I think we also need to distinguish, based on the initial definition, that a cover is not an artist recording their own song again. "A new rendition of a previously recorded song" could be mis-interpreted that way. -- [[User:BrianFreud|BrianFreud]]
There is also a difficulty determining what the "original" recording would be for interactions between classical and non-classical recordings. When a rock band covers a track from an opera, especially if that opera was composed prior to the age of music, there would be no target recording that could be pointed to under the current definition. -- [[User:BrianFreud|BrianFreud]]

Latest revision as of 16:08, 17 March 2010