Tracks With Multiple Artists: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Textures (disc 1) has been fixed up.)
(18 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Sometimes, a release includes songs by more than one artist in one single track (one after the other - for mashups, see the [[Style/Specific_types_of_releases#Mash-ups|mash-up guidelines]]). In most cases, it will be only two songs, one by each artist: just separate the titles with / ("Title 1 / Title 2") and use the [[Artist Credit|artist credit system]] to make the artist also "Artist 1 / Artist 2".
This page tries to list all releases that have tracks that consist of more than one song by more than one artist. An example:


Before we could do this, we used to store these with "Title 1 / Artist 2 - Title 2" as the title, and Artist 1 as artist. There is a list of a lot of [[Tracks With Multiple Artists#Tracks by '/' separated artists|places where this was done below]], feel free to fix them and remove them from the list!
This [[Track:35e23fc4-0449-4772-997d-fe9f909c9eec|track]] has two songs on it: ''5:55'' by ''Durango 95'', followed by ''Liquid Love'' by ''Casper Pound''. These artists did not cooperate on this track; it's merely a technical issue where two songs are put on one track. Were the two songs by the same artist [[Multiple Title Style|MultipleTitleStyle]] would apply. Note that this is '''not''' the same as a track where the artist is a collaboration, e.g. ''Mick Jagger & David Bowie''.

It is recommended to add a [[Release Annotation|ReleaseAnnotation]] with a link to this page to [[Release]]s that have one or more tracks with multiple artists, and also add the release to one of the lists below.

The reason for this existence of this page is that in the future, when hopefully the system is able to deal with these cases, these tracks can be located easily and edited.


'''BEWARE:''' It is very well possible that some tracks on the releases listed below are actually mash-ups instead of tracks with multiple artists. This needs to be sorted out.
'''BEWARE:''' It is very well possible that some tracks on the releases listed below are actually mash-ups instead of tracks with multiple artists. This needs to be sorted out.
Line 31: Line 27:
* [[Release:3572d604-600f-480e-aa07-ef3332a58544|Dance Sessions (disc 3: Progressive)]]
* [[Release:3572d604-600f-480e-aa07-ef3332a58544|Dance Sessions (disc 3: Progressive)]]
* [[Release:bafc5062-ad56-4615-bbaa-46eaa61cd4b2|Dance Sessions (disc 4: House)]]
* [[Release:bafc5062-ad56-4615-bbaa-46eaa61cd4b2|Dance Sessions (disc 4: House)]]
* [[Release:c83e6685-cd2a-45ef-83e4-3ba77982b75f|Dawn of the Dead: Unreleased Soundtrack Music]] ([[Track:0191c448-6a38-4e5b-aff1-c7778ea13609|track #10]])
* [[Release:c83e6685-cd2a-45ef-83e4-3ba77982b75f|Dawn of the Dead: Unreleased Soundtrack Music]] ([[recording:0191c448-6a38-4e5b-aff1-c7778ea13609|track #10]])
* [[Release:49a22830-a03f-4a6f-97ea-15018df74359|Death Before Distemper 4]]
* [[Release:49a22830-a03f-4a6f-97ea-15018df74359|Death Before Distemper 4]]
* [[Release:ac9257a4-c0ac-4c76-9d88-7fe152dbe373|Excursions (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:ac9257a4-c0ac-4c76-9d88-7fe152dbe373|Excursions (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:92247720-f32c-4a4e-af40-e10163ff30ec|Get on This!!! (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:92247720-f32c-4a4e-af40-e10163ff30ec|Get on This!!! (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:7957c224-35db-4318-a815-f15425124597|Global House Culture, Volume 2]]
* [[Release:7957c224-35db-4318-a815-f15425124597|Global House Culture, Volume 2]]
* [[Release:646dbf8f-ac16-4c89-a083-57c94a7cf159|Hard Energy: Your Xxxtreme Night Out]] ([[Track:f2c1efc7-9c39-4dae-83a9-c2288761acd7|track #21]] & [[Track:4587251b-8cd5-45bc-9796-61748cc2f88b|track #42]])
* [[Release:646dbf8f-ac16-4c89-a083-57c94a7cf159|Hard Energy: Your Xxxtreme Night Out]] ([[recording:f2c1efc7-9c39-4dae-83a9-c2288761acd7|track #21]] & [[recording:4587251b-8cd5-45bc-9796-61748cc2f88b|track #42]])
* [[Release:8c14fea7-d465-4218-9f42-26a162c9cebc|How to Kill the DJ, Part 2 (disc 1: Optimo)]]
* [[Release:8c14fea7-d465-4218-9f42-26a162c9cebc|How to Kill the DJ, Part 2 (disc 1: Optimo)]]
* [[Release:697f7f7d-9711-44a1-80eb-a4d95371beb6|I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]
* [[Release:697f7f7d-9711-44a1-80eb-a4d95371beb6|I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]
Line 47: Line 43:
* [[Release:f7355b52-a9c5-434f-b2f6-e020793ea85a|Laboratoire Mix (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f7355b52-a9c5-434f-b2f6-e020793ea85a|Laboratoire Mix (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:96b1d5d2-95fd-4153-af29-7ada478b8ebf|Laboratoire Mix (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:96b1d5d2-95fd-4153-af29-7ada478b8ebf|Laboratoire Mix (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:315cd823-7546-4255-844f-f61a2a648a09|Les oiseaux de passage]] ([[Track:5dab999c-b309-422e-9441-188d4567fbdd|track #15]])
* [[Release:315cd823-7546-4255-844f-f61a2a648a09|Les oiseaux de passage]] ([[recording:5dab999c-b309-422e-9441-188d4567fbdd|track #15]])
* [[Release:afe7c2a9-a071-4b2f-8110-f5b8fb3dd263|La Musique de Paris Dernière 7]] ([[Track:1dc0ed9e-f726-471c-922c-58067a6febae| track #15]])
* [[Release:afe7c2a9-a071-4b2f-8110-f5b8fb3dd263|La Musique de Paris Dernière 7]] ([[recording:1dc0ed9e-f726-471c-922c-58067a6febae| track #15]])
* [[Release:f4bbf26a-5b11-4f9b-b33b-2b6419ab63fa|Live at Freeflow, Helsinki 16/07/03]]
* [[Release:f4bbf26a-5b11-4f9b-b33b-2b6419ab63fa|Live at Freeflow, Helsinki 16/07/03]]
* [[Release:a2335ec9-4c72-4322-831a-45df5f7c8d38|Live in Detroit 1999]]
* [[Release:a2335ec9-4c72-4322-831a-45df5f7c8d38|Live in Detroit 1999]]
Line 84: Line 80:
* [[Release:d2d2bbe4-731a-4273-8a59-c98ead8a1767|This Is House... (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:d2d2bbe4-731a-4273-8a59-c98ead8a1767|This Is House... (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:9adfed05-0799-4e6c-8348-b01540b07613|Through the Eyes presented by Roni Size (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:9adfed05-0799-4e6c-8348-b01540b07613|Through the Eyes presented by Roni Size (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:a6b6e102-879f-4e1a-8fc0-9e2c6126704c|Tone Tales From Tomorrow Too]]
* [[Release:48863347-1afb-418e-89d4-4f2f9f9221a1|Trance Nation '94 (disc 3: Special Vinyl Turnable Mix by DJ Jens Mahlstedt)]]
* [[Release:48863347-1afb-418e-89d4-4f2f9f9221a1|Trance Nation '94 (disc 3: Special Vinyl Turnable Mix by DJ Jens Mahlstedt)]]
* [[Release:d58330ab-eb89-4189-887b-320b0ce68194|Trance Nation '95 (disc 3: Special Vinyl Turntable Mix by DJ Jens Mahlstedt)]]
* [[Release:d58330ab-eb89-4189-887b-320b0ce68194|Trance Nation '95 (disc 3: Special Vinyl Turntable Mix by DJ Jens Mahlstedt)]]
Line 95: Line 92:
==Tracks by '/' separated artists==
==Tracks by '/' separated artists==


If a track has two songs, '''Song A''' by '''Artist A''' and '''Song B''' by '''Artist B''', it is highly recommended to make '''Artist A''' the [[Track Artist|TrackArtist]] and '''Song A / Artist B - Song B''' the [[Track Title|TrackTitle]]. This way, no bogus [[Artist]]s are created. ''Artist A / Artist B'' as [[Track Artist|TrackArtist]] would imply both artists collaborated in some way; for these tracks, that is not the case.
* [[Release:78bf15d5-9c6c-45e7-9561-7789f92e5681|"In the Still of the Nite (I'll Remember)" / Album Snippets]]
* [[Release:78bf15d5-9c6c-45e7-9561-7789f92e5681|"In the Still of the Nite (I'll Remember)" / Album Snippets]]
* [[Release:25c0a40d-ff80-48be-9fff-82f335718770|0161]]
* [[Release:25c0a40d-ff80-48be-9fff-82f335718770|0161]]
Line 104: Line 100:
* [[Release:beb592ac-b240-4c10-98a3-8f59d81c6c76|2000-02-26: Sanremo Festival, Sanremo, Italy]]
* [[Release:beb592ac-b240-4c10-98a3-8f59d81c6c76|2000-02-26: Sanremo Festival, Sanremo, Italy]]
* [[Release:e8d39fb2-3356-4a6f-8789-ea29d09250af|2007-07-07: Live Earth, Wembley Stadium, London, UK]] (Track 8, 2 instances)
* [[Release:e8d39fb2-3356-4a6f-8789-ea29d09250af|2007-07-07: Live Earth, Wembley Stadium, London, UK]] (Track 8, 2 instances)
* [[Release:11505434-ca01-4286-a1fd-b2136b3eff2d|50 Silly Songs (disc 1)]] ([[Track:5c225dc0-d80c-417a-890d-88eaba1bb858|track #15]])
* [[Release:11505434-ca01-4286-a1fd-b2136b3eff2d|50 Silly Songs (disc 1)]] ([[recording:5c225dc0-d80c-417a-890d-88eaba1bb858|track #15]])
* [[Release:cd7e5c65-866f-4404-bf44-b61b318637e5|51 bandes originales pour 51 Films, Volume 2 (disc 5: Le Bal)]]
* [[Release:6d137977-db7c-4a36-b987-334e28ce1713|58.46 Radio Mix]]
* [[Release:6d137977-db7c-4a36-b987-334e28ce1713|58.46 Radio Mix]]
* [[Release:13d24cdb-cbe3-4764-97a7-b71a270c7fa1|A Bugged Out Mix With Erol Alkan (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:13d24cdb-cbe3-4764-97a7-b71a270c7fa1|A Bugged Out Mix With Erol Alkan (disc 1)]]
Line 111: Line 108:
* [[Release:49dfe0ed-2cd3-4f7a-977c-1a7cfb8a373e|A Tribute to Woody Guthrie]]
* [[Release:49dfe0ed-2cd3-4f7a-977c-1a7cfb8a373e|A Tribute to Woody Guthrie]]
* [[Release:5864e7f9-329e-4931-8cda-c59c4981a1a3|Absolute Power]]
* [[Release:5864e7f9-329e-4931-8cda-c59c4981a1a3|Absolute Power]]
* [[Release:e69aa29d-a6a7-48db-8b1f-0e5e80c680ea|Addicted to Movies]] (tracks 9, 14 and 15)
* [[Release:ad93f8d6-7ce1-4660-a2cc-6aad4378759b|Alive 2007]]
* [[Release:ad93f8d6-7ce1-4660-a2cc-6aad4378759b|Alive 2007]]
* [[Release:def847d5-48a6-4bb6-8887-ae4f7f945e6c|Alive 2007 (Deluxe Edition)]]
* [[Release:def847d5-48a6-4bb6-8887-ae4f7f945e6c|Alive 2007 (Deluxe Edition)]]
Line 125: Line 123:
* [[Release:78e3e537-1a94-4514-98d4-3561fc61f307|Beneath the Surface]]
* [[Release:78e3e537-1a94-4514-98d4-3561fc61f307|Beneath the Surface]]
* [[Release:899acdf7-3487-4c84-b159-67104458c1a4|Big Floor Funk]]
* [[Release:899acdf7-3487-4c84-b159-67104458c1a4|Big Floor Funk]]
* [[Release:11e59e56-8c85-4691-bede-c467adea1c1f|Blech]] (track 19)
* [[Release:da8ebcc3-3da5-4cc8-be41-9e82ba17bea6|Blechsdöttir: The Nexus Phase]]
* [[Release:da8ebcc3-3da5-4cc8-be41-9e82ba17bea6|Blechsdöttir: The Nexus Phase]]
* [[Release:7111c8bc-8549-4abc-8ab9-db13f65b4a55|Blueprint 2.1]]
* [[Release:7111c8bc-8549-4abc-8ab9-db13f65b4a55|Blueprint 2.1]]
Line 131: Line 130:
* [[Release:83bcbeae-3572-42bb-93e6-75a37b70739e|Buggin' Da Beats]]
* [[Release:83bcbeae-3572-42bb-93e6-75a37b70739e|Buggin' Da Beats]]
* [[Release:7f0513c2-288f-4a4d-b4d3-954c89e10300|Bytes]]
* [[Release:7f0513c2-288f-4a4d-b4d3-954c89e10300|Bytes]]
* [[Release:8e068c13-7d70-4b5d-824b-3f23364fb9da|Circus & Chibuku present: Yousef & Krafty Kuts (disc 2: Krafty Kuts)]]
* [[Release:8e068c13-7d70-4b5d-824b-3f23364fb9da|Circus & Chibuku present: Yousef & Krafty Kuts (disc 2: Krafty Kuts)]]
* [[Release:131ae12d-7ff5-401a-992f-1874a8fb2101|Club Classics, Volume 2 (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f5f592c4-ea6e-4047-87ae-8d317c1fc0e3|Cocktail Mol6t8v : La bande son de la révolte (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f5f592c4-ea6e-4047-87ae-8d317c1fc0e3|Cocktail Mol6t8v : La bande son de la révolte (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:c82898f1-66bf-4364-abdf-08ae88228ff7|Cocktail Mol6t8v : La bande son de la révolte (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:c82898f1-66bf-4364-abdf-08ae88228ff7|Cocktail Mol6t8v : La bande son de la révolte (disc 2)]]
Line 229: Line 229:
* [[Release:9bc7bf82-792a-4c4a-8a1b-adf023ec4103|Mashed Two (disc 1: jiggyjiggybootyrock)]]
* [[Release:9bc7bf82-792a-4c4a-8a1b-adf023ec4103|Mashed Two (disc 1: jiggyjiggybootyrock)]]
* [[Release:e67cc638-1885-406c-9aa8-e18c20e9c7d4|Mashed Two (disc 2: aciidravelectropop)]]
* [[Release:e67cc638-1885-406c-9aa8-e18c20e9c7d4|Mashed Two (disc 2: aciidravelectropop)]]
* [[Release:2145a564-6266-4472-89e4-92b07c917b1a|Meatballs]]
* [[Release:2145a564-6266-4472-89e4-92b07c917b1a|Meatballs]]
* [[Release:9de19561-8c47-4a50-b05e-086fb164108f|Megasoft Office 2001]]
* [[Release:c261f3ff-b3ae-409b-8602-98b061d23691|Merry Chrismix 2007]]
* [[Release:c261f3ff-b3ae-409b-8602-98b061d23691|Merry Chrismix 2007]]
* [[Release:49bca853-1e09-407d-ac0d-2533833e69b3|Midwinter (disc 1: Past & Presents)]]
* [[Release:49bca853-1e09-407d-ac0d-2533833e69b3|Midwinter (disc 1: Past & Presents)]]
Line 259: Line 260:
* [[Release:cf76333c-7c36-423d-a0ae-6e1e01cdff40|Night of the Living Dead]]
* [[Release:cf76333c-7c36-423d-a0ae-6e1e01cdff40|Night of the Living Dead]]
* [[Release:6a21b14d-aadb-4216-85fc-4ec067830816|Nightlife 4]]
* [[Release:6a21b14d-aadb-4216-85fc-4ec067830816|Nightlife 4]]
* [[Release:483f5cd5-6335-45f2-b012-7f20cd18bcca|No Hidden Catch: Eesti Depeche Mode'i tribuut]]
* [[Release:483f5cd5-6335-45f2-b012-7f20cd18bcca|No Hidden Catch: Eesti Depeche Mode'i tribuut]]
* [[Release:65c210c6-69b4-4637-9647-a202a4162988|Northern Exposure 2 (disc 1: East Coast) -- Special case: songs are different version of the same song, and both track artists are actually aliases of the same group of two producers Gez Dewar & Nick Hale]]
* [[Release:1ec02095-f5e0-480d-b6d6-3f05807bf3f8|O Mickey Where Art Thou?]]
* [[Release:1ec02095-f5e0-480d-b6d6-3f05807bf3f8|O Mickey Where Art Thou?]]
* [[Release:041d08af-ce1a-471f-b33f-56fb762781c8|One+One (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:041d08af-ce1a-471f-b33f-56fb762781c8|One+One (disc 2)]]
Line 284: Line 286:
* [[Release:e9f7a0ed-dd7d-4658-9ebf-321eb5f9621d|Rolling Stone: Rare Trax, Volume 1: Unreleased Material & Collector's Items]]
* [[Release:e9f7a0ed-dd7d-4658-9ebf-321eb5f9621d|Rolling Stone: Rare Trax, Volume 1: Unreleased Material & Collector's Items]]
* [[Release:8f3434ef-d269-45b3-a01b-418190c69806|Schizophrenic]]
* [[Release:8f3434ef-d269-45b3-a01b-418190c69806|Schizophrenic]]
* [[Release:ae68b819-fe43-4754-a751-b695b430b132|Scion CD Sampler, Volume 18: Ninja Tune Mix by Darko of Spank Rock]]
* [[Release:51836e92-d73f-4576-974f-361ef6865e41|Scrubs: My Musical]]
* [[Release:51836e92-d73f-4576-974f-361ef6865e41|Scrubs: My Musical]]
* [[Release:028121a1-4c02-4eb5-ab08-d2fc54529b53|Sessions: NastyDirtySexMusic (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:028121a1-4c02-4eb5-ab08-d2fc54529b53|Sessions: NastyDirtySexMusic (disc 1)]]
Line 309: Line 310:
* [[Release:28f1eff8-6db1-45ce-b18b-b0bace7dab7a|Symphonic]]
* [[Release:28f1eff8-6db1-45ce-b18b-b0bace7dab7a|Symphonic]]
* [[Release:c07aae61-b4f6-427e-9476-311bae709ba2|Taste]]
* [[Release:c07aae61-b4f6-427e-9476-311bae709ba2|Taste]]
* [[Release:a89a96fb-711c-4b60-9bad-df58aeffa9f9|Textures (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f08f2f39-e628-4567-94c1-f9c11a78efc0|The Ambient Cookbook II (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:f08f2f39-e628-4567-94c1-f9c11a78efc0|The Ambient Cookbook II (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:21c38f96-faaf-49f0-a714-61a46ee69edc|The Best of Mixmag Live]]
* [[Release:21c38f96-faaf-49f0-a714-61a46ee69edc|The Best of Mixmag Live]]
Line 316: Line 316:
* [[Release:af678580-4708-4e67-a3cd-98701b21d3e9|The Changeling (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:af678580-4708-4e67-a3cd-98701b21d3e9|The Changeling (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:79ada63e-e4a7-402e-b46d-328f67a61ab5|The Dirtchamber Sessions, Volume One]]
* [[Release:79ada63e-e4a7-402e-b46d-328f67a61ab5|The Dirtchamber Sessions, Volume One]]
* [[Release:f92d2239-fef1-4e43-9566-945d282d3d52|The Godfather, Part II]]
* [[Release:007187d7-6690-4a1f-95e5-24a1b4ab7e38|The Godfather, Part III]]
* [[Release:0f026007-58db-42e7-9b1d-07eade81a263|The Great Soundclash Swindle (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:0f026007-58db-42e7-9b1d-07eade81a263|The Great Soundclash Swindle (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:37d3eecb-89b4-458f-98cf-22cb0e833eb5|The House Collection: Club Classics, Volume 3 (disc 2) (Mixed by Luvdup)]]
* [[Release:37d3eecb-89b4-458f-98cf-22cb0e833eb5|The House Collection: Club Classics, Volume 3 (disc 2) (Mixed by Luvdup)]]
Line 330: Line 328:
* [[Release:5ff65952-1690-41eb-a423-92719928afab|Tobias Thomas: Smallville]]
* [[Release:5ff65952-1690-41eb-a423-92719928afab|Tobias Thomas: Smallville]]
* [[Release:cd3d4a2b-eb8f-4b6e-b675-320ac13ef0bf|Tonal Evidence 7]]
* [[Release:cd3d4a2b-eb8f-4b6e-b675-320ac13ef0bf|Tonal Evidence 7]]
* [[Release:53ed00ed-901b-4bf0-aded-e7c85ce8cd0e|Toolroom Knights (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:54b83539-f033-4dbe-95b7-d2f5313d9780|Tour de Traum]]
* [[Release:54b83539-f033-4dbe-95b7-d2f5313d9780|Tour de Traum]]
* [[Release:6f6d226c-2526-448a-bb58-869f669f8cd9|Tutti Frutti]]
* [[Release:6f6d226c-2526-448a-bb58-869f669f8cd9|Tutti Frutti]]
Line 349: Line 348:
* [[Release:a8f4d230-a172-407b-8aef-d0c1442afe48|Y4K → Dub Pistols: Next Level Breaks]]
* [[Release:a8f4d230-a172-407b-8aef-d0c1442afe48|Y4K → Dub Pistols: Next Level Breaks]]
* [[Release:9f8d8ed5-67e6-4e04-814d-f40c9c7e2c6e|Dubstep Allstars, Volume 07 (disc 1: Mixed by Chef)]]
* [[Release:9f8d8ed5-67e6-4e04-814d-f40c9c7e2c6e|Dubstep Allstars, Volume 07 (disc 1: Mixed by Chef)]]
* [[Release:3ef97e43-e02a-44c2-97b0-862b442673cd|Ready-Made Vocal Beds, Volume 2]]


==Both at the Same Time==
==Both at the Same Time==
[[Release:45eb29d7-1988-42d5-bdcd-c0eb630b6748|Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno]]
[[Release:45eb29d7-1988-42d5-bdcd-c0eb630b6748|Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno]]


[[Category:Metadata]]
[[Category:Metadata]] [[Category:Community Project]] [[Category:To Be Reviewed]]

Revision as of 10:33, 5 November 2014

Sometimes, a release includes songs by more than one artist in one single track (one after the other - for mashups, see the mash-up guidelines). In most cases, it will be only two songs, one by each artist: just separate the titles with / ("Title 1 / Title 2") and use the artist credit system to make the artist also "Artist 1 / Artist 2".

Before we could do this, we used to store these with "Title 1 / Artist 2 - Title 2" as the title, and Artist 1 as artist. There is a list of a lot of places where this was done below, feel free to fix them and remove them from the list!

BEWARE: It is very well possible that some tracks on the releases listed below are actually mash-ups instead of tracks with multiple artists. This needs to be sorted out.

Tracks by Various Artists

Tracks by '/' separated artists

Both at the Same Time

Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno