Tracks With Multiple Artists: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Sometimes, a release includes songs by more than one artist in one single track (one after the other - for mashups, see the [[Style/Specific_types_of_releases#Mash-ups|mash-up guidelines]]. In most cases, it will be only two songs, one by each artist: just separate the titles with / ("Title 1 / Title 2") and use the [[Artist Credit|artist credit system]] to make the artist also "Artist 1 / Artist 2".
Sometimes, a release includes songs by more than one artist in one single track (one after the other - for mashups, see the [[Style/Specific_types_of_releases#Mash-ups|mash-up guidelines]]). In most cases, it will be only two songs, one by each artist: just separate the titles with / ("Title 1 / Title 2") and use the [[Artist Credit|artist credit system]] to make the artist also "Artist 1 / Artist 2".


Before we could do this, we used to store these with "Title 1 / Artist 2 - Title 2" as the title, and Artist 1 as artist. There is a list of a lot of [[Tracks With Multiple Artists#Tracks by '/' separated artists|places where this was done below]], feel free to fix them and remove them from the list!
Before we could do this, we used to store these with "Title 1 / Artist 2 - Title 2" as the title, and Artist 1 as artist. There is a list of a lot of [[Tracks With Multiple Artists#Tracks by '/' separated artists|places where this was done below]], feel free to fix them and remove them from the list!
Line 27: Line 27:
* [[Release:3572d604-600f-480e-aa07-ef3332a58544|Dance Sessions (disc 3: Progressive)]]
* [[Release:3572d604-600f-480e-aa07-ef3332a58544|Dance Sessions (disc 3: Progressive)]]
* [[Release:bafc5062-ad56-4615-bbaa-46eaa61cd4b2|Dance Sessions (disc 4: House)]]
* [[Release:bafc5062-ad56-4615-bbaa-46eaa61cd4b2|Dance Sessions (disc 4: House)]]
* [[Release:c83e6685-cd2a-45ef-83e4-3ba77982b75f|Dawn of the Dead: Unreleased Soundtrack Music]] ([[Track:0191c448-6a38-4e5b-aff1-c7778ea13609|track #10]])
* [[Release:c83e6685-cd2a-45ef-83e4-3ba77982b75f|Dawn of the Dead: Unreleased Soundtrack Music]] ([[recording:0191c448-6a38-4e5b-aff1-c7778ea13609|track #10]])
* [[Release:49a22830-a03f-4a6f-97ea-15018df74359|Death Before Distemper 4]]
* [[Release:49a22830-a03f-4a6f-97ea-15018df74359|Death Before Distemper 4]]
* [[Release:ac9257a4-c0ac-4c76-9d88-7fe152dbe373|Excursions (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:ac9257a4-c0ac-4c76-9d88-7fe152dbe373|Excursions (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:92247720-f32c-4a4e-af40-e10163ff30ec|Get on This!!! (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:92247720-f32c-4a4e-af40-e10163ff30ec|Get on This!!! (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:7957c224-35db-4318-a815-f15425124597|Global House Culture, Volume 2]]
* [[Release:7957c224-35db-4318-a815-f15425124597|Global House Culture, Volume 2]]
* [[Release:646dbf8f-ac16-4c89-a083-57c94a7cf159|Hard Energy: Your Xxxtreme Night Out]] ([[Track:f2c1efc7-9c39-4dae-83a9-c2288761acd7|track #21]] & [[Track:4587251b-8cd5-45bc-9796-61748cc2f88b|track #42]])
* [[Release:646dbf8f-ac16-4c89-a083-57c94a7cf159|Hard Energy: Your Xxxtreme Night Out]] ([[recording:f2c1efc7-9c39-4dae-83a9-c2288761acd7|track #21]] & [[recording:4587251b-8cd5-45bc-9796-61748cc2f88b|track #42]])
* [[Release:8c14fea7-d465-4218-9f42-26a162c9cebc|How to Kill the DJ, Part 2 (disc 1: Optimo)]]
* [[Release:8c14fea7-d465-4218-9f42-26a162c9cebc|How to Kill the DJ, Part 2 (disc 1: Optimo)]]
* [[Release:697f7f7d-9711-44a1-80eb-a4d95371beb6|I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]
* [[Release:697f7f7d-9711-44a1-80eb-a4d95371beb6|I'm Gonna Git You Sucka]]
Line 43: Line 43:
* [[Release:f7355b52-a9c5-434f-b2f6-e020793ea85a|Laboratoire Mix (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f7355b52-a9c5-434f-b2f6-e020793ea85a|Laboratoire Mix (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:96b1d5d2-95fd-4153-af29-7ada478b8ebf|Laboratoire Mix (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:96b1d5d2-95fd-4153-af29-7ada478b8ebf|Laboratoire Mix (disc 2)]]
* [[Release:315cd823-7546-4255-844f-f61a2a648a09|Les oiseaux de passage]] ([[Track:5dab999c-b309-422e-9441-188d4567fbdd|track #15]])
* [[Release:315cd823-7546-4255-844f-f61a2a648a09|Les oiseaux de passage]] ([[recording:5dab999c-b309-422e-9441-188d4567fbdd|track #15]])
* [[Release:afe7c2a9-a071-4b2f-8110-f5b8fb3dd263|La Musique de Paris Dernière 7]] ([[Track:1dc0ed9e-f726-471c-922c-58067a6febae| track #15]])
* [[Release:afe7c2a9-a071-4b2f-8110-f5b8fb3dd263|La Musique de Paris Dernière 7]] ([[recording:1dc0ed9e-f726-471c-922c-58067a6febae| track #15]])
* [[Release:f4bbf26a-5b11-4f9b-b33b-2b6419ab63fa|Live at Freeflow, Helsinki 16/07/03]]
* [[Release:f4bbf26a-5b11-4f9b-b33b-2b6419ab63fa|Live at Freeflow, Helsinki 16/07/03]]
* [[Release:a2335ec9-4c72-4322-831a-45df5f7c8d38|Live in Detroit 1999]]
* [[Release:a2335ec9-4c72-4322-831a-45df5f7c8d38|Live in Detroit 1999]]
Line 92: Line 92:
==Tracks by '/' separated artists==
==Tracks by '/' separated artists==


If a track has two songs, '''Song A''' by '''Artist A''' and '''Song B''' by '''Artist B''', it is highly recommended to make '''Artist A''' the [[Track Artist|TrackArtist]] and '''Song A / Artist B - Song B''' the [[Track Title|TrackTitle]]. This way, no bogus [[Artist]]s are created. ''Artist A / Artist B'' as [[Track Artist|TrackArtist]] would imply both artists collaborated in some way; for these tracks, that is not the case.
* [[Release:78bf15d5-9c6c-45e7-9561-7789f92e5681|"In the Still of the Nite (I'll Remember)" / Album Snippets]]
* [[Release:78bf15d5-9c6c-45e7-9561-7789f92e5681|"In the Still of the Nite (I'll Remember)" / Album Snippets]]
* [[Release:25c0a40d-ff80-48be-9fff-82f335718770|0161]]
* [[Release:25c0a40d-ff80-48be-9fff-82f335718770|0161]]
Line 101: Line 100:
* [[Release:beb592ac-b240-4c10-98a3-8f59d81c6c76|2000-02-26: Sanremo Festival, Sanremo, Italy]]
* [[Release:beb592ac-b240-4c10-98a3-8f59d81c6c76|2000-02-26: Sanremo Festival, Sanremo, Italy]]
* [[Release:e8d39fb2-3356-4a6f-8789-ea29d09250af|2007-07-07: Live Earth, Wembley Stadium, London, UK]] (Track 8, 2 instances)
* [[Release:e8d39fb2-3356-4a6f-8789-ea29d09250af|2007-07-07: Live Earth, Wembley Stadium, London, UK]] (Track 8, 2 instances)
* [[Release:11505434-ca01-4286-a1fd-b2136b3eff2d|50 Silly Songs (disc 1)]] ([[Track:5c225dc0-d80c-417a-890d-88eaba1bb858|track #15]])
* [[Release:11505434-ca01-4286-a1fd-b2136b3eff2d|50 Silly Songs (disc 1)]] ([[recording:5c225dc0-d80c-417a-890d-88eaba1bb858|track #15]])
* [[Release:cd7e5c65-866f-4404-bf44-b61b318637e5|51 bandes originales pour 51 Films, Volume 2 (disc 5: Le Bal)]]
* [[Release:cd7e5c65-866f-4404-bf44-b61b318637e5|51 bandes originales pour 51 Films, Volume 2 (disc 5: Le Bal)]]
* [[Release:6d137977-db7c-4a36-b987-334e28ce1713|58.46 Radio Mix]]
* [[Release:6d137977-db7c-4a36-b987-334e28ce1713|58.46 Radio Mix]]
Line 195: Line 194:
* [[Release:95116ed4-c23c-4459-a2d6-c0d2813317be|Global Underground: 24:7 Danny Howells (disc 2: Night)]]
* [[Release:95116ed4-c23c-4459-a2d6-c0d2813317be|Global Underground: 24:7 Danny Howells (disc 2: Night)]]
* [[Release:5dc2d407-ddcd-44dd-a5b0-361d0ff5b663|Gold Teeth Thief]]
* [[Release:5dc2d407-ddcd-44dd-a5b0-361d0ff5b663|Gold Teeth Thief]]
* [[Release:49732772-1ed9-418a-a8f7-a82cd3723bdf|Grand Theft Auto: London 1969]]
* [[Release:afa62db0-f3cd-4acd-bbc6-f876b8b47303|Headman: Dance Modern]]
* [[Release:afa62db0-f3cd-4acd-bbc6-f876b8b47303|Headman: Dance Modern]]
* [[Release:49c1cd61-1dcc-4543-abe0-3098655002e8|Hed Kandi: The Mix Summer 2008 (disc 1: Twisted Disco)]] (track #15, it's a mash-up)
* [[Release:49c1cd61-1dcc-4543-abe0-3098655002e8|Hed Kandi: The Mix Summer 2008 (disc 1: Twisted Disco)]] (track #15, it's a mash-up)
Line 287: Line 285:
* [[Release:e9f7a0ed-dd7d-4658-9ebf-321eb5f9621d|Rolling Stone: Rare Trax, Volume 1: Unreleased Material & Collector's Items]]
* [[Release:e9f7a0ed-dd7d-4658-9ebf-321eb5f9621d|Rolling Stone: Rare Trax, Volume 1: Unreleased Material & Collector's Items]]
* [[Release:8f3434ef-d269-45b3-a01b-418190c69806|Schizophrenic]]
* [[Release:8f3434ef-d269-45b3-a01b-418190c69806|Schizophrenic]]
* [[Release:ae68b819-fe43-4754-a751-b695b430b132|Scion CD Sampler, Volume 18: Ninja Tune Mix by Darko of Spank Rock]]
* [[Release:51836e92-d73f-4576-974f-361ef6865e41|Scrubs: My Musical]]
* [[Release:51836e92-d73f-4576-974f-361ef6865e41|Scrubs: My Musical]]
* [[Release:028121a1-4c02-4eb5-ab08-d2fc54529b53|Sessions: NastyDirtySexMusic (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:028121a1-4c02-4eb5-ab08-d2fc54529b53|Sessions: NastyDirtySexMusic (disc 1)]]
Line 312: Line 309:
* [[Release:28f1eff8-6db1-45ce-b18b-b0bace7dab7a|Symphonic]]
* [[Release:28f1eff8-6db1-45ce-b18b-b0bace7dab7a|Symphonic]]
* [[Release:c07aae61-b4f6-427e-9476-311bae709ba2|Taste]]
* [[Release:c07aae61-b4f6-427e-9476-311bae709ba2|Taste]]
* [[Release:a89a96fb-711c-4b60-9bad-df58aeffa9f9|Textures (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:f08f2f39-e628-4567-94c1-f9c11a78efc0|The Ambient Cookbook II (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:f08f2f39-e628-4567-94c1-f9c11a78efc0|The Ambient Cookbook II (disc 3)]]
* [[Release:21c38f96-faaf-49f0-a714-61a46ee69edc|The Best of Mixmag Live]]
* [[Release:21c38f96-faaf-49f0-a714-61a46ee69edc|The Best of Mixmag Live]]
Line 319: Line 315:
* [[Release:af678580-4708-4e67-a3cd-98701b21d3e9|The Changeling (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:af678580-4708-4e67-a3cd-98701b21d3e9|The Changeling (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:79ada63e-e4a7-402e-b46d-328f67a61ab5|The Dirtchamber Sessions, Volume One]]
* [[Release:79ada63e-e4a7-402e-b46d-328f67a61ab5|The Dirtchamber Sessions, Volume One]]
* [[Release:f92d2239-fef1-4e43-9566-945d282d3d52|The Godfather, Part II]]
* [[Release:007187d7-6690-4a1f-95e5-24a1b4ab7e38|The Godfather, Part III]]
* [[Release:0f026007-58db-42e7-9b1d-07eade81a263|The Great Soundclash Swindle (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:0f026007-58db-42e7-9b1d-07eade81a263|The Great Soundclash Swindle (disc 1)]]
* [[Release:37d3eecb-89b4-458f-98cf-22cb0e833eb5|The House Collection: Club Classics, Volume 3 (disc 2) (Mixed by Luvdup)]]
* [[Release:37d3eecb-89b4-458f-98cf-22cb0e833eb5|The House Collection: Club Classics, Volume 3 (disc 2) (Mixed by Luvdup)]]
Line 358: Line 352:
[[Release:45eb29d7-1988-42d5-bdcd-c0eb630b6748|Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno]]
[[Release:45eb29d7-1988-42d5-bdcd-c0eb630b6748|Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno]]


[[Category:Metadata]] [[Category:Community Project]]
[[Category:Metadata]] [[Category:Community Project]] [[Category:To Be Reviewed]]

Latest revision as of 23:13, 3 July 2022

Sometimes, a release includes songs by more than one artist in one single track (one after the other - for mashups, see the mash-up guidelines). In most cases, it will be only two songs, one by each artist: just separate the titles with / ("Title 1 / Title 2") and use the artist credit system to make the artist also "Artist 1 / Artist 2".

Before we could do this, we used to store these with "Title 1 / Artist 2 - Title 2" as the title, and Artist 1 as artist. There is a list of a lot of places where this was done below, feel free to fix them and remove them from the list!

BEWARE: It is very well possible that some tracks on the releases listed below are actually mash-ups instead of tracks with multiple artists. This needs to be sorted out.

Tracks by Various Artists

Tracks by '/' separated artists

Both at the Same Time

Di tresette ce n'è uno tutti gli altri son nessuno