Difference between revisions of "User:Azertus/Potential IMDb Relationship Type Problem"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
(copy from User:Azertus)
 
(Would this constitute confirmation?)
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
There's one between a soundtrack-IMDb (and ibdb & iobdb) and one between an album-IMDb (when containing samples from a movie; henceforth the soundtrack AR and the samples AR. I'm guessing the Artist-URL soundtrack AR and the Track-URL samples AR were no problem to convert. According to this table, the Album-URL ARs should have been [[Next_Generation_Schema/Relationships_Conversion|converted/migrated]] as follows:
+
The problem is as follows: the relationship '27 Dresses has an IMDb page at (...)' (see [http://classic.musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=14287302 this edit]) became (post NGS-migration) the relationship '[27 Dresses] samples IMDb entry (...)' (see [http://musicbrainz.org/release-group/2fd46c28-3543-3a78-a2a3-b34f17ae5aaf/relationships this relationship]).
 +
 
 +
There exists an [[IMDb Relationship Type|AR between a soundtrack and IMDb]] (and also [[IBDb Relationship Type|IBDb]] and [[IOBDb Relationship Type|IOBDb]], btw) and an [[Samples From Relationship Type|AR between an album containing samples from a movie and IMDb]]; henceforth called the soundtrack AR and the samples AR.  
 +
 
 +
I'm guessing the Artist-URL soundtrack AR and the Track-URL samples AR were no problem to convert. <br>
 +
According to this table, the Album-URL soundtrack and sample ARs should have been [[Next_Generation_Schema/Relationships_Conversion|converted/migrated]] as follows:
 
{| width='80%'
 
{| width='80%'
 
! AR Type
 
! AR Type
Line 20: Line 25:
 
|}
 
|}
  
Example soundtrack:
+
Something seems to have gone wrong with this.
Release-group 'Star Wars: A New Hope' is the soundtrack from 'Star Wars'
+
The question is: is only the link name wrong, or have the soundtrack AR and the samples AR become the same?
http://musicbrainz.org/release-group/80fe84a4-b606-3491-a170-f2ca17501493/relationships
 
  
Example samples:
+
The samples AR still works as intended (but perhaps we need an example of a release-URL AR added pre-NGS to be sure; [[DeleteWhenCooked]]):
Recording 'Release Me' contains samples from 'Independence Day'.
+
::Recording 'Release Me' contains samples from 'Independence Day'.
http://musicbrainz.org/recording/170e12d4-cbe7-46a6-add9-b71958abaa60/relationships
+
::http://musicbrainz.org/recording/170e12d4-cbe7-46a6-add9-b71958abaa60/relationships
 
+
:::[http://classic.musicbrainz.org/release/0008c285-4aa4-4ba4-a7cf-63fddeab22a6.html] and [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release/0008c285-4aa4-4ba4-a7cf-63fddeab22a6/relationships] look fine (no relationship for the release group - [http://test.musicbrainz.org/release-group/791876e7-cbe8-370e-8fca-2ded9e032bc1/relationships]) so it seems like it's migrated them fine but just used the wrong relationship name. If someone else can confirm that, I can just edit the relationship type. --[[User:Nikki|Nikki]] 03:00, 27 May 2011 (UTC)
The question is: is only the link name wrong, or have the soundtrack AR and the samples AR become the same?
 
  
Tangentially: we decided once that a track-URL soundtrack AR was not needed. However, would it not be useful? I note we did have (pre-NGS?; what happened to those? [[AnswerMe]]) a track-URL IBDb and IOBDb AR.
+
::::Would this constitute confirmation?: Release with "has IMDB page" [http://classic.musicbrainz.org/release/4be66310-bf50-465d-8d9c-26cea85c04eb.html] at the release level on the old site and now with "samples IMDb entry" in NGS [http://musicbrainz.org/release-group/ded8689b-f46a-4e31-89b5-96b3e13c7c7d/relationships] at the release group level. --[[User:Time Dilation|Time Dilation]] 17:30, 3 June 2011 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 17:30, 3 June 2011

The problem is as follows: the relationship '27 Dresses has an IMDb page at (...)' (see this edit) became (post NGS-migration) the relationship '[27 Dresses] samples IMDb entry (...)' (see this relationship).

There exists an AR between a soundtrack and IMDb (and also IBDb and IOBDb, btw) and an AR between an album containing samples from a movie and IMDb; henceforth called the soundtrack AR and the samples AR.

I'm guessing the Artist-URL soundtrack AR and the Track-URL samples AR were no problem to convert.
According to this table, the Album-URL soundtrack and sample ARs should have been converted/migrated as follows:

AR Type     Now         NGS         Comment     Status in migration scripts
IMDb, ibdb, iobdb Album-URL ReleaseGroup-URL ok OK
IMDb samples Album-URL Release-URL OK

Something seems to have gone wrong with this. The question is: is only the link name wrong, or have the soundtrack AR and the samples AR become the same?

The samples AR still works as intended (but perhaps we need an example of a release-URL AR added pre-NGS to be sure; DeleteWhenCooked):

Recording 'Release Me' contains samples from 'Independence Day'.
http://musicbrainz.org/recording/170e12d4-cbe7-46a6-add9-b71958abaa60/relationships
[1] and [2] look fine (no relationship for the release group - [3]) so it seems like it's migrated them fine but just used the wrong relationship name. If someone else can confirm that, I can just edit the relationship type. --Nikki 03:00, 27 May 2011 (UTC)
Would this constitute confirmation?: Release with "has IMDB page" [4] at the release level on the old site and now with "samples IMDb entry" in NGS [5] at the release group level. --Time Dilation 17:30, 3 June 2011 (UTC)