Difference between revisions of "User:BrianSchweitzer/Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Add some examples, add the do not infer attribs guidance)
Line 129: Line 129:
 
#* In some cases, both an orchestra and a choir coexist, and are conducted by the same [[Artist|artist]]. In such cases, both this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''and'' [[Proposal:Choirmaster Position Relationship Type Proposal|Choirmaster Position Relationship Type]] should be used.
 
#* In some cases, both an orchestra and a choir coexist, and are conducted by the same [[Artist|artist]]. In such cases, both this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''and'' [[Proposal:Choirmaster Position Relationship Type Proposal|Choirmaster Position Relationship Type]] should be used.
 
# This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] describes a [[WikiPedia:Conducting|conductor]] ''position'' one [[Artist|artist]] holds with another [[Artist|artist]]. [[Conductor Relationship Type]], ''not'' this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used to describe the fact that an [[Artist|artist]] ''conducted'' on a recorded [[Track|track]] or [[Release|release]].
 
# This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] describes a [[WikiPedia:Conducting|conductor]] ''position'' one [[Artist|artist]] holds with another [[Artist|artist]]. [[Conductor Relationship Type]], ''not'' this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used to describe the fact that an [[Artist|artist]] ''conducted'' on a recorded [[Track|track]] or [[Release|release]].
# '''Do not infer attributes.''' An inexperienced conductor is not automatically an assistant or associate conductor, nor is a very experienced conductor automatically a conductor emeritus. Likewise, 'guest conductor' is a specific position title; simply because a conductor is credited with "guest conducting" on a release, that conductor '''does not''' automatically become a 'guest conductor'.
+
# '''Do not infer attributes.''' The use of any relationship attribute to indicate a specific position should be documented, and not assumed. An inexperienced conductor is not automatically an assistant or associate conductor, nor is a very experienced conductor automatically a conductor emeritus. Likewise, 'guest conductor' is a specific position title; simply because a conductor is credited with "guest conducting" on a release, that conductor '''does not''' automatically become a 'guest conductor'.
 
}}
 
}}
   

Revision as of 04:15, 17 December 2010


Status: This page describes an active advanced relationship proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-266
Champion: BrianFreud
Current status: RFC
Initial Discussion



Template:Relationship

Notes and references