User:BrianSchweitzer/Music Director Position Relationship Type Proposal: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Template:proposal
{{Template:proposal
|proposal=
|proposal=269
|discussion=http://lists.musicbrainz.org/pipermail/musicbrainz-style/2010-March/009236.html
|discussion=
|champion=[[User:brianfreud|brianfreud]]
|champion=[[BrianFreud]]
|rfc=
|rfc=
|rfv=
|rfv=
|status=In development
|status=Pre-RFC
|ar=true
|ar=true
|style=
|style=
Line 11: Line 11:
}}
}}


== Description ==
{{Relationship


This indicates that an [[Artist|artist]] is, or was, the music director for an [[Artist|artist]]. This is an [[Artist|artist]] who not only acts as conductor, but also as the artistic leader for a musical group. This typically includes:
|type = Bandleader
|typeURL = Bandleader
|proposal = 1

|class = Musical Association

|linkedFrom1 = Artist
|linkText1 = was music director for
|linkedTo1 = Artist

|linkedFrom2 = Artist
|linkText2 = had music director(s)
|linkedTo2 = Artist

|attributeDescriptionBegin = This indicates the first date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the music director position.
|attributeDescriptionEnd = This indicates the last date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the music director position.

|summary = This indicates that an [[Artist|artist]] is, or was, the music director for an [[Artist|artist]].

|description = This is an [[Artist|artist]] who not only acts as conductor, but also as the artistic leader for a musical group. This typically includes:
:* Sole authority over hiring and firing musicians within the group
:* Sole authority over hiring and firing musicians within the group
:* Fund-raising responsibilities
:* Fund-raising responsibilities
Line 38: Line 19:
:* Responsibility for hiring guest conductors and soloists
:* Responsibility for hiring guest conductors and soloists
:* Acting as the public face for the group
:* Acting as the public face for the group
In musical theater and opera, the music director(s) is/are also principally responsible for the overall musical performance.
The titles typically used to describe this position are:
----
The titles typically used to describe this position are:
:; [[Wikipedia:Director musices|Director musices]]
:; [[Wikipedia:Director musices|Director musices]]
:: Latin for 'music director', this title was typically used in Europe at universities and cathedrals. While it has fallen out of favor, it still is in active use in Sweden.
:: Latin for 'music director', this title was typically used in Europe at universities and cathedrals. While it has fallen out of favor, it still is in active use in Sweden.
::* ''Director musices'' is also a title granted by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church. The title is ''honorary''. This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''should not'' be used simply because an [[Artist|artist]] is a recipient of the honorary ''director musices'' title.
::* ''Director musices'' is also one of two musical titles granted by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church. The title is ''honorary''. This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''should not'' be used simply because an [[Artist|artist]] is a recipient of the honorary ''director musices'' title.
:; Director cantus
:: This is the other honorary musical title granted by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church. The title is '''always''' honorary, and should ''not'' be used to indicate this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]].
:; [[WikiPedia:Music director|Director of Music]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Music director|Director of Music]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Music director|Music Director]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Music director|Music Director]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Kapellmeister#Contemporary_usage|Kapellmeister]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Kapellmeister#Contemporary_usage|Kapellmeister]]
:: In the classical era, this title indicated a [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|conductor]] role, as the church or nobleman was responsible for employment of musicians, fiscal matters, and most repertoire selection. In modern times, however, while the title has become less frequent, when it is used, it indicates the same general responsibilities of a Music Director.
:: In the classical era, this title indicated a [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|conductor]] role, ''not'' a Music Director role, as the church or nobleman was responsible for employment of musicians, fiscal matters, and most repertoire selection. In modern times, however, while the title has become less frequent, when it is used, it indicates the same general responsibilities of a Music Director.
::* Exception: When used by the Kapellmeister of a ''military'' band, the title is most equivalent to a [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Bandmaster]], and not a Music Director.
::* Exception: When Kapellmeister is used to describe a position with a ''military'' band, the title is most equivalent to a [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Bandmaster]], not a Music Director.
:; [[WikiPedia:Organist and Master of the Choristers|Organist and Master of the Choristers]]
:; [[WikiPedia:Organist and Master of the Choristers|Organist and Master of the Choristers]]
:: A title typically given to the Director of Music at a cathedral, most commonly at Anglican cathedrals in the United Kingdom. This title also implies additional roles beyond those typical to a music director:
:: A title typically given to the Director of Music at a cathedral, most commonly at Anglican cathedrals in the United Kingdom. This title also implies additional roles beyond those typical to a music director:
Line 52: Line 37:
::* This [[Artist|artist]] is the choirmaster for the cathedral choir. [[Proposal:Choirmaster Position Relationship Type Proposal|Choirmaster Position Relationship Type]] should also be used.
::* This [[Artist|artist]] is the choirmaster for the cathedral choir. [[Proposal:Choirmaster Position Relationship Type Proposal|Choirmaster Position Relationship Type]] should also be used.
::* Finally, in addition to conducting the cathedral choir, this [[Artist|artist]] is also responsible for training the singers in the choir. [[Proposal:Vocal Coach Position Relationship Type Proposal|Vocal Coach Position Relationship Type]] should also be used.
::* Finally, in addition to conducting the cathedral choir, this [[Artist|artist]] is also responsible for training the singers in the choir. [[Proposal:Vocal Coach Position Relationship Type Proposal|Vocal Coach Position Relationship Type]] should also be used.
:; [[WikiPedia:Artistic director (music)|Artistic Director]] (or sometimes simply 'Director')
:; [[WikiPedia:Artistic director (music)|Artistic Director]] (or simply 'Director')
:: An Artistic Director typically works with a smaller, less well-funded institutional group - the group may even be newly formed, not yet even having [[Member Of Band Relationship Type|performers]], and thus requiring the Artistic Director to seek out performers. Music directors with this title typically have multiple roles besides the music director roles, and may thus need multiple other assorted [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationships]] to describe their responsibilities.
:: An Artistic Director typically works with a smaller, less well-funded institutional group - the group may even be newly formed, not yet even having [[Member Of Band Relationship Type|performers]], and thus requiring the Artistic Director to seek out performers. Music directors with this title typically have multiple roles besides the music director roles, and may thus need multiple other assorted [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationships]] to describe their responsibilities.


== Link Phrases ==
|attributeName1 = principal
|attributeDescription1 = This indicates that the group had multiple music directors who were led by this music director.
<dd>'''Link Phrases:'''
<ul><li>[[Artist]] was the principal music director for [[Artist]]
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] had principal music director(s) [[Artist]]</ul>
|attributePage1 = Principal Position Relationship Attribute


* [[Artist]] is/was music director for [[Artist]]
|attributeName2 = emeritus
* [[Artist]] has/had music director(s) [[Artist]]
|attributeDescription2 = This title indicates that a music director has at least partially retired, and no longer plays an active role with the group.
* [[Artist]] is/was an assistant music director emeritus for [[Artist]]
<dd>'''Link Phrases:'''
<ul><li>[[Artist]] was a music director emeritus for [[Artist]]
* [[Artist|Artist]] has/had assistant music director(s) [[Artist]]
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] had music director emeritus/emeriti [[Artist]]</ul>
* [[Artist]] is/was an associate music director for [[Artist]]
* [[Artist|Artist]] has/had associate music director(s) [[Artist]]
|attributePage2 = Emeritus Position Relationship Attribute
* [[Artist]] is/was a music director emeritus for [[Artist]]
* [[Artist|Artist]] has/had music director emeritus/emeriti [[Artist]]
* [[Artist]] is/was the principal music director for [[Artist]]
* [[Artist|Artist]] has/had principal music director(s) [[Artist]]


== Attributes ==
|attributeName3 = associate
|attributeDescription3 = This title indicates a less experienced music director who works under the direction of the principal music director.
<dd>'''Link Phrases:'''
<ul><li>[[Artist]] was an associate music director for [[Artist]]
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] had associate music director [[Artist]]</ul>
|attributePage3 = Associate Relationship Attribute


*; '''start date'''
|attributeName4 = assistant
|attributeDescription4 = This title indicates a less experienced, or first-time music director, who works under the direction of a more experienced music director.
: This indicates the first date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the music director position.
<dd>'''Link Phrases:'''
<ul><li>[[Artist]] was an assistant music director emeritus for [[Artist]]
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] had assistant music director(s) [[Artist]]</ul>
|attributePage4 = Assistant Relationship Attribute


*; '''end date'''
|style = * [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]] should be used in addition to this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]].
: This indicates the last date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the music director position.
* The position (and attribute) should be documented; it must not be assumed.

*; assistant
: This title indicates a less experienced, or first-time music director, who works under the direction of a more experienced music director.

*; associate
: This title indicates a less experienced music director who works under the direction of the principal music director.

*; emeritus
: This title indicates that a music director has at least partially retired, and no longer plays an active role with the group.

*; principal
: This indicates that the group had multiple music directors who were led by this music director.

== Guidelines ==

* [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]] should be used in addition to this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]].
* The position (and any attribute used) should be documented; it must not be assumed.
* At any one time, an [[Artist|artist]] may have more than one music director, but never more than one principal music director.
* At any one time, an [[Artist|artist]] may have more than one music director, but never more than one principal music director.
* A music director must be a person [[Artist|artist]].
* A music director must be a person [[Artist|artist]].
* The target artist must be a group [[Artist|artist]].
* The target artist must be a group [[Artist|artist]].
* A music director is almost never also a [[Member Of Band Relationship Type|member]] of the group.
* A music director is almost never also a [[Member Of Band Relationship Type|member]] of the group.
* Only one of the attributes should be used at the same time.
* Only one of the attributes 'assistant', 'associate', 'emeritus', or 'principal' should be used at the same time.

}}
[[Category:Proposed Relationship Type]]

Latest revision as of 22:16, 3 May 2014


Status: This page describes an active advanced relationship proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-269
Champion: BrianFreud
Current status: Pre-RFC
Initial Discussion



Description

This indicates that an artist is, or was, the music director for an artist. This is an artist who not only acts as conductor, but also as the artistic leader for a musical group. This typically includes:

  • Sole authority over hiring and firing musicians within the group
  • Fund-raising responsibilities
  • Concert programming
  • Responsibility for hiring guest conductors and soloists
  • Acting as the public face for the group

In musical theater and opera, the music director(s) is/are also principally responsible for the overall musical performance.


The titles typically used to describe this position are:

Director musices
Latin for 'music director', this title was typically used in Europe at universities and cathedrals. While it has fallen out of favor, it still is in active use in Sweden.
  • Director musices is also one of two musical titles granted by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church. The title is honorary. This relationship type should not be used simply because an artist is a recipient of the honorary director musices title.
Director cantus
This is the other honorary musical title granted by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church. The title is always honorary, and should not be used to indicate this relationship type.
Director of Music
Music Director
Kapellmeister
In the classical era, this title indicated a conductor role, not a Music Director role, as the church or nobleman was responsible for employment of musicians, fiscal matters, and most repertoire selection. In modern times, however, while the title has become less frequent, when it is used, it indicates the same general responsibilities of a Music Director.
  • Exception: When Kapellmeister is used to describe a position with a military band, the title is most equivalent to a Bandmaster, not a Music Director.
Organist and Master of the Choristers
A title typically given to the Director of Music at a cathedral, most commonly at Anglican cathedrals in the United Kingdom. This title also implies additional roles beyond those typical to a music director:
Artistic Director (or simply 'Director')
An Artistic Director typically works with a smaller, less well-funded institutional group - the group may even be newly formed, not yet even having performers, and thus requiring the Artistic Director to seek out performers. Music directors with this title typically have multiple roles besides the music director roles, and may thus need multiple other assorted relationships to describe their responsibilities.

Link Phrases

Attributes

  • start date
This indicates the first date that the artist held the music director position.
  • end date
This indicates the last date that the artist held the music director position.
  • assistant
This title indicates a less experienced, or first-time music director, who works under the direction of a more experienced music director.
  • associate
This title indicates a less experienced music director who works under the direction of the principal music director.
  • emeritus
This title indicates that a music director has at least partially retired, and no longer plays an active role with the group.
  • principal
This indicates that the group had multiple music directors who were led by this music director.

Guidelines

  • Conductor Position Relationship Type should be used in addition to this relationship type.
  • The position (and any attribute used) should be documented; it must not be assumed.
  • At any one time, an artist may have more than one music director, but never more than one principal music director.
  • A music director must be a person artist.
  • The target artist must be a group artist.
  • A music director is almost never also a member of the group.
  • Only one of the attributes 'assistant', 'associate', 'emeritus', or 'principal' should be used at the same time.