User:CatCat/BB Formats

From MusicBrainz Wiki
< User:CatCat
Revision as of 12:32, 30 November 2020 by Mr monkey (talk | contribs)

Edition format types

These could be topmost,. then possibly we can have sub-options or similar, so that something like "pocketbook" or "softback" are subs of paperback, meaning that if you do not know it is better to chose paperback and be less specific, than to chose pocket and be wrong.


  • hardback (glued/sewn, paper/vellum?)
  • paperback
  • spiralbound
  • booklet/magazine/digest (it may have a spine)
  • paper/newspaper/pamphlet (any distinction between glossy/non glossy?)
  • audiobook (physical or digital)
  • scroll/parchment
  • stone/clay tablet
  • non-bound/unregular/loose pages
  • other

should we make a distinction between sewn(ie hardback) and glued (ie boardbook)

Format Description
Manuscript traditionally, any document that is written by hand. modernly, any written, typed, etc, copy of the author's work, distinguished from the printed version.(seems the only distinction between incunable/manuscript is printed/handwritten, the modern idea creates problems)

it maybe a codex(bound), or it may be a scroll the diffe between scroll and codex seems to be the bounding of codices then. paper, vellum, papyrus. Manuscript seems a very broad general, perhaps more suitable as a tag than a type of format, given that manuscripts can *be* other types "...may be a codex or a scroll"

stone/clay/wood tablet my addition
scroll/parchment my addition
Codex historical ancestor of book, vellum/papyrus/etc
Incunable medieval books, written by hand
Post-Incunable (honestly seems unnecessary as a differentiation.)
Broadside ie poster, apparently incunables are included here???
Chapbook small paper-covered booklets
Facsimile rigorous reproduction of (often) ancient releases
Board Book kids books printed on cardboard-type material "paperboard".
Padded Baby Book distinction between "padded" or "hard/soft/board" back though? I can only imagine crossover/gradient will be common.
Pop-Up Book (I would prefer Interactive book) interesting, but, I've seen both hardback and boardbooks with this ability. the norwegian term is "utbrettsbok" (folding out book). the "animated book" (Livre animé) of french is also a nice term. I'm unsure if this is "its own thing". I think something can be *both* hardback and interactive, etc. Hell I even own greeting-cards that are somewhat like this.
multiple media
my gut instinct here is to a) link it to mb, b) each "type of medium" is "It's Own Thing"™ so we need no "combo format". if we eventually have "types of audio format" and "multi medium editions" as on mb, this solves itself. For now, I think we ignore "additional (non-book) things attached to editions", and leave that info for annotations.
Paperback + Flexi-Disc 15
Paperback + CD 303
Hardback + CD 307
Paperback + Cassette 23
no idea
Box Set sure, but usually individual things inside (this is "packaging")
Stamped/Die Cut Stories ?
Club Edition club edition is what?
Flexibound ?
Promo in what way?
Journal what is this? unclear
BARD Cartridge ?????
Sheet Music in what way? seems more a "genre"
Monograph seems to be not a physical "format"
Soundbook how is diff from electronic/audiobook? what is it?
conventional "book"
acc to : "In the U.S., there are "mass-market paperbacks" and larger, more durable "trade paperbacks". In the U.K., there are A-format, B-format, and the largest C-format sizes." so these are "market specific formats" the differences between them are minimal. I think they might be used as sub-types, but given that the same thing will be defined differently in different markets, this is also problematic (also we should not be US-centric (or any other market for that matter) but defining our formats 1:1 with their definitions.
Paperback also known as a softcover or softback, often held together with glue (not stitches or staples)
-> Mass-Market Paperback
-> Trade Paperback
Softcover same as paperback? (I'd prefer this term as an analogue to "hardcover")
Pocket book literally the same as "paperback"in eng., norwegian makes a distinction between "pocketbook" and Paperback but then goes on to describe them identically. english doesn't really add any clarification either, imho.
Hardback bound with cardboard covered with cloth, plastic, or leather.
Hardcover wp makes no distinction between Hback and hcover, infact redirects this to the other.
oversized hardback imho, this and the below are irrelevant (oversized to one person is regular to another. types need to be obvious to fogure out and select for users.)
Oversized Hardcover as above
Miniature book just small books? an image search seem to say so, if they are bound like bigger books they are still "hardback/softback/spiral/etc"
Spiralbound we *might* make a distinction between those with two hard/solid boards and those without.
conventional "magazine"
Magazine periodical publication (high gloss paper)
Bedsheet Magazine just a special US size of magazine
Pulp Magazine perhaps to magazines what softbacks are to hardcovers? (seems more genre-y though)
Zine or perhaps just "doujinshi" as a term. however how different from "magazine" is it?
Digest size between magazine and paperback (perhaps journal also fits here?)
Pamphlet booklet, leaflet, manual, flyer, thin, small and informative? there is A LOT of crossover of names and terms and definitions for unbound non-periodical papers. how is it different from broadside and Posters?
newspaper fairly straightforward, do we distinguish between month/week/daily, tabloid/serious? (my gut says no.)
Audiobook Audiobook; cd, cassette, digital (maybe better if mb stores the specifics?)
Printing/Uncorrected Proof
Loose-leaf/Binder ringperm, papers with holes set in a binder.
Digital are the following really different "formats"?:
-> eZine/e-Zine
-> e-Book
Other always there is need for "other" :D

formats of electronic books basically falls into the same holes as digital formats of music: we have format types, mobi, epub, pdf, etc, which is irrelevant as usually they're either available as several or, they can be converted. we have distribution channels: amazon, archive, ebooks etc, which can vary from the exact same file to completely unique per platform. we have no actual physical borders to lean on so the size, format and even page numbers (see community post) are irrelevant.

the only separation I'd make between "digitals" is if it's words or audio (ie audiobook)

finally, what to do with tactiles, ie braille books? gut instinct tells me this should be a separate category.