User:DavitoF/How To Link Works Together: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
* when several works are assembled into one, use [[Medley_Relationship_Type|Medley]] |
* when several works are assembled into one, use [[Medley_Relationship_Type|Medley]] |
||
* to describe how a work is made of sub-parts, use [[Parts_Relationship_Type|Parts]] |
* to describe how a work is made of sub-parts, use [[Parts_Relationship_Type|Parts]] |
||
I won't use Stravinsky's Petroushka ([http://musicbrainz.org/work/cb04cba5-603f-4d40-b128-a7ae4a356197 1911 version]/[http://musicbrainz.org/work/57deae1f-4fb3-40c3-aa4f-3167ea0e806a 1947 version]) in the examples because I can't decide if the title should use the French or the English spelling : but should Revision or Version AR be used? |
|||
Revision as of 17:35, 5 March 2013
There are several relations you can enter between works. It is sometimes difficult to choose the correct one. Here are a few hints.
- for new versions of the work by the same author (similar instrumentation), use Revision
- for arrangements (modifications in the music such as adding or removing sections, ) use Arrangement
- for transciptions (same music but different instrument(s)) use Transcription (Bach choral/Busoni transcription)
- for new versions of the work by a different author, use Other version
- when works are too different to use the arrangement relation, use Based on (Bach partita/Gounod Ave maria)
- when several works are assembled into one, use Medley
- to describe how a work is made of sub-parts, use Parts
