Difference between revisions of "User:Hrglgrmpf/Artist Ranking"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(→‎Platinum: Add "Beachniks")
 
(20 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The idea is to have a ranking of artists, based on partly objective criteria. The reason for this is more fun to clean up artists (like: I want to have my favorite band be fully cleaned up, and let others know). These artists are then also a show case what can be achieved with the full level of MusicBrainz interlinked data!
+
The idea is to have a ranking of artists, based on mostly objective criteria. The reason for this is more fun to clean up artists (like: I want to have my favorite band be fully cleaned up, and let others know). These artists are then also a show case what can be achieved with the full level of MusicBrainz interlinked data!
   
 
The proposed criteria are (only for artists that have a discography):
 
The proposed criteria are (only for artists that have a discography):
  +
* '''Bronze'''
* unknown: default
 
* bronze: has "full" discography on overview page (release groups cleaned up), all artist relationships (performs as, band members) set, IPI set for artist and/or all band members
+
** Has "full" discography on overview page, which means all release groups are cleaned up (merged, have correct type) and all official studio albums / EPs / singles are present as release groups. Usually this means the overview page obsoletes the Wikipedia discography.
  +
** All musical artist relationships are set (performs as, all band members).
* silver: all releases/release groups cleaned up (date, label, barcode, ASIN/discogs links)
 
  +
** The artist and all members (for groups) have ''all'' available artist info filled in ([[IPI]](!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
* gold: all recordings cleaned up (comments for live recordings / recordings with same name, identical ones merged), works cleaned up, every recording is associated with at least one work, all works have ISWC if they have any
 
* platinum: all external links set (lyrics, allmusic, discogs, ASIN, ...), all relationships set (writer, composer, ...); in this state nothing more can be done for the artist, except when musicbrainz gets new features or new releases appear.
+
** All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
  +
** All duplicate artists merged, artist comment set for all artists with the same name.
  +
* '''Silver'''
  +
** All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
  +
** All official releases are present (e.g. there is no non-promo/non-bootleg release in Discogs which is not in MusicBrainz).
  +
* '''Gold'''
  +
** All recordings are cleaned up, which means there are no two recordings with the same name and no disambiguation (ISRC, comment, ...)
  +
** All recordings (besides ones like [silence], etc.) are linked to works.
  +
** All works have the correct type and have an [[ISWC]] set if available.
  +
* '''Platinum'''
  +
** All external links are set (lyrics, allmusic, discogs, ASIN, ...) for all entities (works, releases, release groups, ...).
  +
** All works have (correct) writer/composer/lyricist relationships
  +
** All available (through liner notes, other trustful sources) musical relationships set (mastered by, recorded by, guest vocalists, ...)
  +
  +
If an artist is in ''Platinum'' state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.
  +
  +
== Platinum ==
  +
  +
* [[Artist:d68c99b2-3471-4d66-a69a-e491009cde06|Beachniks]]
  +
* [[Artist:859216c4-5d01-479b-b6c3-e20cc591a86a|Daphni]]
  +
* [[Artist:c57510e4-9fed-466a-b4f4-7e48443aad8d|Inbase]]
  +
* [[Artist:52938df0-6e1a-4b70-82bf-c14a2259a000|New Look]] (Italo-disco act of the mid 1980s)
   
 
== Gold ==
 
== Gold ==
   
 
* [[Artist:f1b4fda6-a681-4f63-a9a3-bd9b219e09cf|Esben and the Witch]]
 
* [[Artist:f1b4fda6-a681-4f63-a9a3-bd9b219e09cf|Esben and the Witch]]
  +
* [[Artist:849ef638-dd1e-434b-9a22-c0474e31fbad|French Films]]
 
* [[Artist:7c69f6ff-36d3-41d2-8ac9-6fee84a6ff17|Knarf Rellöm Trinity]]
 
* [[Artist:7c69f6ff-36d3-41d2-8ac9-6fee84a6ff17|Knarf Rellöm Trinity]]
  +
* [[Artist:b759968a-9ca0-40f1-97de-71c937292c4a|New Look]] (Canadian duo Adam Pavao and Sarah Ruba)
  +
* [[Artist:a430d12f-62c9-4088-aac5-95309ed349b2|Ter Haar]]
   
 
== Silver ==
 
== Silver ==
   
 
* [[Artist:5bed0ef8-0745-44f2-b5b4-dfa6150732be|Angelika Express]]
 
* [[Artist:5bed0ef8-0745-44f2-b5b4-dfa6150732be|Angelika Express]]
  +
* [[Artist:2e260f6b-a0a0-4cc5-bce3-4124abc7d6f7|Comix]]
  +
* [[Artist:47b42008-a94c-4e50-b554-6aac48a996fe|Cwtch]]
  +
  +
== Bronze ==
  +
  +
* [[Artist:ba853904-ae25-4ebb-89d6-c44cfbd71bd2|Blur]]
  +
* [[Artist:612231ce-633b-4ebc-99bf-9b14e8d1cb74|Frankmusik]]
  +
* [[Artist:03ad1736-b7c9-412a-b442-82536d63a5c4|Elliott Smith]] (US singer-songwriter)
  +
* [[Artist:735e3514-a8ae-401f-af3b-6300df1b8d2c|Caribou]]
  +
* [[Artist:6907d8f2-70fd-4e8c-94d6-ce005fddba05|Manitoba]]
  +
* [[Artist:9a465fde-6939-4a02-a800-9ccba4b01c20|Saalschutz]]
  +
* [[Artist:10780286-e1e1-4760-a176-c47673c2d6c0|Räuberhöhle]]
  +
* [[Artist:da02702b-d06c-41ea-a711-f3f17a9af91d|Frankie Rose and the Outs]]

Latest revision as of 21:46, 6 January 2014

The idea is to have a ranking of artists, based on mostly objective criteria. The reason for this is more fun to clean up artists (like: I want to have my favorite band be fully cleaned up, and let others know). These artists are then also a show case what can be achieved with the full level of MusicBrainz interlinked data!

The proposed criteria are (only for artists that have a discography):

  • Bronze
    • Has "full" discography on overview page, which means all release groups are cleaned up (merged, have correct type) and all official studio albums / EPs / singles are present as release groups. Usually this means the overview page obsoletes the Wikipedia discography.
    • All musical artist relationships are set (performs as, all band members).
    • The artist and all members (for groups) have all available artist info filled in (IPI(!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
    • All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
    • All duplicate artists merged, artist comment set for all artists with the same name.
  • Silver
    • All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
    • All official releases are present (e.g. there is no non-promo/non-bootleg release in Discogs which is not in MusicBrainz).
  • Gold
    • All recordings are cleaned up, which means there are no two recordings with the same name and no disambiguation (ISRC, comment, ...)
    • All recordings (besides ones like [silence], etc.) are linked to works.
    • All works have the correct type and have an ISWC set if available.
  • Platinum
    • All external links are set (lyrics, allmusic, discogs, ASIN, ...) for all entities (works, releases, release groups, ...).
    • All works have (correct) writer/composer/lyricist relationships
    • All available (through liner notes, other trustful sources) musical relationships set (mastered by, recorded by, guest vocalists, ...)

If an artist is in Platinum state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.

Platinum

Gold

Silver

Bronze