User:Hrglgrmpf/Artist Ranking

The idea is to have a ranking of artists, based on mostly objective criteria. The reason for this is more fun to clean up artists (like: I want to have my favorite band be fully cleaned up, and let others know). These artists are then also a show case what can be achieved with the full level of MusicBrainz interlinked data!

The proposed criteria are (only for artists that have a discography):

• Bronze
  • Has "full" discography on overview page, which means all release groups are cleaned up (merged, have correct type) and all official studio albums / EPs / singles are present as release groups. Usually this means the overview page obsoletes the Wikipedia discography.
  • All musical artist relationships are set (performs as, all band members).
  • The artist and all members (for groups) have all available artist info filled in (IPI(!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
  • All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
  • All duplicate artists merged, artist comment set for all artists with the same name.
• Silver
  • All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
  • All official releases are present (e.g. there is no non-promo/non-bootleg release in Discogs which is not in MusicBrainz).
• Gold
  • All recordings are cleaned up, which means there are no two recordings with the same name and no recording comment.
  • All recordings (besides ones like [silence], etc.) are linked to at least one work.
  • All works have the correct type and have an ISWC set if available (if not, note in annotation!).
• Platinum
  • All external links are set (lyrics, allmusic, discogs, ASIN, ...) for all entities (works, releases, release groups, ...).
  • All works have correct writer/composer/lyricist relationships
  • All available (through liner notes, other trustful sources) musical relationships set (mastered by, recorded by, guest vocalists, ...)

If an artist is in Platinum state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.

Platinum

• New Look (Italo-disco act of the mid 1980s)

Gold

• Esben and the Witch
• Knarf Rellöm Trinity

Silver

• Angelika Express
• New Look (Canadian duo Adam Pavao and Sarah Ruba)

Bronze

• Frankmusik
• Elliott Smith (US singer-songwriter)
• Caribou
• Manitoba
• Daphni