User:Hrglgrmpf/Artist Ranking: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 7: Line 7:
** The artist and all members (for groups) have ''all'' available artist info filled in ([[IPI]](!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
** The artist and all members (for groups) have ''all'' available artist info filled in ([[IPI]](!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
** All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
** All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
** All duplicate artists merged, artist comment set for all artists with the same name.
* '''Silver'''
* '''Silver'''
** All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
** All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
Line 20: Line 21:


If an artist is in ''Platinum'' state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.
If an artist is in ''Platinum'' state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.

== Platinum ==

* [[Artist:52938df0-6e1a-4b70-82bf-c14a2259a000|New Look]] (Italo-disco act of the mid 1980s)


== Gold ==
== Gold ==
Line 29: Line 34:


* [[Artist:5bed0ef8-0745-44f2-b5b4-dfa6150732be|Angelika Express]]
* [[Artist:5bed0ef8-0745-44f2-b5b4-dfa6150732be|Angelika Express]]
* [[Artist:b759968a-9ca0-40f1-97de-71c937292c4a|New Look]] (Canadian duo Adam Pavao and Sarah Ruba)


== Bronze ==
== Bronze ==

Revision as of 21:33, 26 August 2011

The idea is to have a ranking of artists, based on mostly objective criteria. The reason for this is more fun to clean up artists (like: I want to have my favorite band be fully cleaned up, and let others know). These artists are then also a show case what can be achieved with the full level of MusicBrainz interlinked data!

The proposed criteria are (only for artists that have a discography):

  • Bronze
    • Has "full" discography on overview page, which means all release groups are cleaned up (merged, have correct type) and all official studio albums / EPs / singles are present as release groups. Usually this means the overview page obsoletes the Wikipedia discography.
    • All musical artist relationships are set (performs as, all band members).
    • The artist and all members (for groups) have all available artist info filled in (IPI(!), begin/end date, country, gender, ...)
    • All external links are set (official homepage, lyrics, allmusic, discogs, youtube, twitter, facebook, ...).
    • All duplicate artists merged, artist comment set for all artists with the same name.
  • Silver
    • All releases are cleaned up, which means medium type, date, label, barcode, ASIN and discogs links are set so they exist, duplicates merged.
    • All official releases are present (e.g. there is no non-promo/non-bootleg release in Discogs which is not in MusicBrainz).
  • Gold
    • All recordings are cleaned up, which means there are no two recordings with the same name and no recording comment.
    • All recordings (besides ones like [silence], etc.) are linked to at least one work.
    • All works have the correct type and have an ISWC set if available (if not, note in annotation!).
  • Platinum
    • All external links are set (lyrics, allmusic, discogs, ASIN, ...) for all entities (works, releases, release groups, ...).
    • All works have correct writer/composer/lyricist relationships
    • All available (through liner notes, other trustful sources) musical relationships set (mastered by, recorded by, guest vocalists, ...)

If an artist is in Platinum state nothing more can be added/corrected for the artist, except when MusicBrainz gets new features or new releases appear or new information is available.

Platinum

  • New Look (Italo-disco act of the mid 1980s)

Gold

Silver

Bronze