User:Ianmcorvidae/How To Write Edit Notes

From MusicBrainz Wiki

Whenever you edit MusicBrainz data, you will be asked to add an Edit Note. Most edits need to be voted on by other MusicBrainz users, to catch errors and bad data. Edit Notes are there to help the voters determine if an edit is correct.

If a voter disagrees with an edit or needs more information they should add a note asking for clarification (see below).

Each edit note is sent by email to the original editor and everyone who voted on an edit but did not abstain.

When writing any edit note, please keep the Code of Conduct in mind.

How to add edit notes when changing data

The primary reason for Edit Notes is to help voters to decide if an edit is correct. It is optional to add an edit note, but you are strongly encouraged to add one. Edit Notes can also be useful later, when data is subsequently edited and past sources need to be consulted.

What should be included?

  1. A URL with some sort of proof your edit is reasonable and correct.
  2. A link to relevant MusicBrainz Style Guidelines
  3. What you're doing, unless it's outstandingly obvious
  4. Why you're doing it, unless it's outstandingly obvious

What constitutes good proof?

In approximate order of preference:

  1. More than one of the below
  2. Scans of liner materials
  3. Official sites for the artist/label
  4. Other sites with a review process, such as discogs or Encyclopaedia Metallum
  5. Reputable online shops like Amazon and iTunes

Note that online stores are often good proof of the existence of a release, but often have incorrect information about the release. These should be paired with other proof whenever possible.

What doesn't constitute good proof?

  • FreeDB
  • Other user-editable sites that lack a review process

How to add edits notes when voting and answering

Anyone can add an edit note to an already entered edit. This includes already applied and not-yet-applied edits.

When should I leave an edit note when I am not the original editor?

  1. If you vote No on an edit
  2. If you need clarification or better proof in order to vote
  3. If there is an ongoing discussion in a given edit's notes to which you can contribute

What should I include in such an edit note?

  1. Say what you need, or why you voted No.
  2. Include links to MusicBrainz Style Guidelines or URLs with proof, if these are relevant
  3. Be concise, but also complete. Especially terse edit notes are intimidating to new editors and unuseful to new voters; especially long ones may not be read.

How should I respond to these edit notes, if I am the original editor?

  1. Provide clarification or better proof, if requested
  2. Explain further why the editor should vote Yes or abstain, if your edit received a No vote
  3. If you agree with the concerns of the other editor, cancel your edit and explain this in the edit note when you cancel