Purpose of Disc IDs
Issues with (or because of) Disc IDs
The ability to attach pregrap tracks directly to the release is a long wanted feature and tracked in MBS-967. You can't add a Pregap Track as track 0 when a Disc ID is attached to the release (tracklist is locked). Removing the Disc ID could work, but the release can only be found by clients with TOC lookup support (see below). Removing Disc IDs altogether would extend the problem to all releases.
The additional "track" would confuse many tagger tools, so the pregap track should only be included when explicitely requested, not as a normal track.
When disc IDs are attached, the track times can't be set manually. Setting times to one of the disc IDs is the only option.
- I didn't grasp yet when it is the case that no correct disc ID is available and there is a better source for the correct time. The notes mention Video CDs, which possibly shouldn't get disc IDs attached in the first place? (when there are no audio tracks). Otherwise I don't see why we should mess around with length of data tracks. --JonnyJD (talk) 14:24, 25 September 2013 (UTC)
Client support with and without full TOC
The main client library for disc ID support is libdiscid:
- submission url provided includes DiscID and TOC, to save the TOC on the server
- web service url provided also includes both, but is outdated (WS/1)
- only the disc ID can be gathered directly with the API (as of 0.5.2)
- there will be an upcoming release (0.6.0) with a "toc string API" (LIB-41)
The web service does allow lookup by disc ID and, if it doesn't match, a fuzzy lookup by TOC. The result of a match by disc ID and a fuzzy match by TOC looks completely different (see comment in LMB-36) A syntactically valid (though not existing) disc ID is always required and a match by TOC is currently always fuzzy.