Difference between revisions of "User:LordSputnik/Proposals/Recording Title"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
m (comma goes where)
(Changed ETI guidance to be more in line with current guidelines. Also added a section to update the Live recordings section to point back to recording title guideline.)
Line 14: Line 14:
  
 
==Title==
 
==Title==
The recording title should generally be based on the titles of tracks using that recording.
+
The recording title should generally be based on the titles of tracks using that recording:
  
If the recording has tracks from official albums, choose the most common title from official tracks as the basis for the recording title. Otherwise, choose the most common track title. For standalone recordings, the title should be based on the title given by the original source.
+
* If the recording has tracks from official albums, choose the most common title from official tracks as the basis for the recording title.
 +
* Otherwise, choose the most common track title.
 +
* For standalone recordings, the title should be based on the title given by the original source.
  
Any [[Style/Titles/Extra_title_information|extra title information]] in the chosen title should be kept with the recording. ETI which is the name of a specific version of the song (e.g. a named remix, mix or edit), should be included in the recording title, but all other ETI should be moved to the disambiguation comment of the recording.
+
For almost all recordings, [[Style/Titles/Extra_title_information|extra title information]] should be kept in the recording title. The exception is live recordings, where any performance information should be transferred to the disambiguation using the [[Style/Recording#Live_recordings|Live recordings]] guideline.
 
 
See the [[Style/Titles|title guidelines]] for general information about titles.
 
  
 
===Examples===
 
===Examples===
 
*The majority of the official tracks using the recording [[recording:9aa77fa3-1a7d-4ff9-a5ce-8c3dc072fa52|…Baby One More Time]] are called "…Baby One More Time", so the recording title should be "…Baby One More Time" and not "Baby One More Time" or "…Baby One More Time (radio version)".
 
*The majority of the official tracks using the recording [[recording:9aa77fa3-1a7d-4ff9-a5ce-8c3dc072fa52|…Baby One More Time]] are called "…Baby One More Time", so the recording title should be "…Baby One More Time" and not "Baby One More Time" or "…Baby One More Time (radio version)".
 
*The recording [[recording:d0a7f90b-9d4f-4737-80ff-1f87704999f4|Mailman, Bring Me More Blues]] is actually the song "Mailman, Bring Me No More Blues". But because there is only one track using the recording, the title of this track should be used as the recording title.
 
*The recording [[recording:d0a7f90b-9d4f-4737-80ff-1f87704999f4|Mailman, Bring Me More Blues]] is actually the song "Mailman, Bring Me No More Blues". But because there is only one track using the recording, the title of this track should be used as the recording title.
 +
 +
==Specific types of recording==
 +
===Live recordings===
 +
For live recordings, enter the recording title as described in the [[Style/Recording#Title|recording title]] guideline, and use "live" as the recording disambiguation comment. ...

Revision as of 16:42, 25 August 2013


Status: This page describes an active style guideline proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-STYLE-230
Champion: LordSputnik
Current status: RFC
[[1] Initial Discussion]


JIRA ticket http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/STYLE-230

To replace http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Style/Recording#Title:

Title

The recording title should generally be based on the titles of tracks using that recording:

  • If the recording has tracks from official albums, choose the most common title from official tracks as the basis for the recording title.
  • Otherwise, choose the most common track title.
  • For standalone recordings, the title should be based on the title given by the original source.

For almost all recordings, extra title information should be kept in the recording title. The exception is live recordings, where any performance information should be transferred to the disambiguation using the Live recordings guideline.

Examples

  • The majority of the official tracks using the recording …Baby One More Time are called "…Baby One More Time", so the recording title should be "…Baby One More Time" and not "Baby One More Time" or "…Baby One More Time (radio version)".
  • The recording Mailman, Bring Me More Blues is actually the song "Mailman, Bring Me No More Blues". But because there is only one track using the recording, the title of this track should be used as the recording title.

Specific types of recording

Live recordings

For live recordings, enter the recording title as described in the recording title guideline, and use "live" as the recording disambiguation comment. ...