User:Reosarevok/Classical Edge Cases: Difference between revisions
From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(New page: ==J.S. Bach== ===Brandenburg Concertos=== ;No 3, second movement: as written, consists of one measure. Performances sometimes are just that one measure, sometimes improvisation, sometimes ...) |
Reosarevok (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
For meaningful discussion on how to get the best possible support for "classical" (or "art" or... you know what I mean) music, we need to think of the hardest / less obvious cases we can come up with. This is a place to list those - please add all you can! |
|||
==J.S. Bach== |
==J.S. Bach== |
||
===Brandenburg Concertos=== |
===Brandenburg Concertos=== |
||
;No 3, second movement: as written, consists of one measure. Performances sometimes are just that one measure, sometimes improvisation, sometimes inserting an entirely different work. Wendy Carlos composed three different extended versions (for Switched-On Bach, Switched-on Brandenburgs, and Switched-On Bach 2000). |
;No 3, second movement: as written, consists of one measure. Performances sometimes are just that one measure, sometimes improvisation, sometimes inserting an entirely different work. Wendy Carlos composed three different extended versions (for Switched-On Bach, Switched-on Brandenburgs, and Switched-On Bach 2000). |
||
==Gustav Holst== |
==Gustav Holst== |
||
===The Planets Suite=== |
|||
A movement (“Pluto”) was composed much later by a different composer, but of course could be considered part of the suite. It also makes minor modifications to the end of the 7th part. |
Revision as of 23:21, 7 February 2012
For meaningful discussion on how to get the best possible support for "classical" (or "art" or... you know what I mean) music, we need to think of the hardest / less obvious cases we can come up with. This is a place to list those - please add all you can!
J.S. Bach
Brandenburg Concertos
- No 3, second movement
- as written, consists of one measure. Performances sometimes are just that one measure, sometimes improvisation, sometimes inserting an entirely different work. Wendy Carlos composed three different extended versions (for Switched-On Bach, Switched-on Brandenburgs, and Switched-On Bach 2000).
Gustav Holst
The Planets Suite
A movement (“Pluto”) was composed much later by a different composer, but of course could be considered part of the suite. It also makes minor modifications to the end of the 7th part.