User:Ssundell: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
((Imported from MoinMoin))
((Imported from MoinMoin))
Line 42: Line 42:
* Led Zeppelin's [[Album:73ad55fe-5cc4-4780-9d5e-65106aa94e09|Early Days]] has a much too long Stairway to Heaven, but only in release page, not on DiscIDs. '''according to my copy of disc, it should be 8:03 - joan whittaker'''
* Led Zeppelin's [[Album:73ad55fe-5cc4-4780-9d5e-65106aa94e09|Early Days]] has a much too long Stairway to Heaven, but only in release page, not on DiscIDs. '''according to my copy of disc, it should be 8:03 - joan whittaker'''
* Atari Teenage Riot's [[Album:35250a5b-f251-49b4-8281-aa38497a41d9|60 Second Wipe Out]] has wrong track times.
* Atari Teenage Riot's [[Album:35250a5b-f251-49b4-8281-aa38497a41d9|60 Second Wipe Out]] has wrong track times.
* David Bowie's [[Album:6cd16d0d-4269-4cd2-ac9a-067d746d5c94|Station to Station]] has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=46655&show=times#discid DiscID] that has totally different track times from the others. The DiscID is about to be removed (vote [http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=5879721 here]), but the track times need adjusting.


==Multiple releases under same entry==
==Multiple releases under same entry==
Line 56: Line 57:
* [[Album:03d85e2b-3183-4698-b632-c7119646f102|Seal]] by Seal has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=3542&show=times#discid DiscID] with "Crazy", track 3, over a minute shorter than in my copy...
* [[Album:03d85e2b-3183-4698-b632-c7119646f102|Seal]] by Seal has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=3542&show=times#discid DiscID] with "Crazy", track 3, over a minute shorter than in my copy...
* [[Album:7214f50e-e7d6-4948-806a-024a00a1eda7|Led Zeppelin]] has two [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=2269&show=times#discid DiscID's] that are clearly a different version of the album.
* [[Album:7214f50e-e7d6-4948-806a-024a00a1eda7|Led Zeppelin]] has two [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=2269&show=times#discid DiscID's] that are clearly a different version of the album.
* David Bowie's [[Album:6cd16d0d-4269-4cd2-ac9a-067d746d5c94|Station to Station]] has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=46655&show=times#discid DiscID] that has totally different track times from the others.
* [[Album:495652e1-d9b7-40c5-8490-10a87b91dba6|The Fellowship of the Ring]] has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=248696&show=times#discid DiscID] that differs from others drastically on two tracks.
* [[Album:495652e1-d9b7-40c5-8490-10a87b91dba6|The Fellowship of the Ring]] has a [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=248696&show=times#discid DiscID] that differs from others drastically on two tracks.
* [[Album:10bfa756-9237-4616-ac21-5f323a492327|Nirvana]] by Nirvana has [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=90727&show=times#discid DiscID] which has several different tracks.
* [[Album:10bfa756-9237-4616-ac21-5f323a492327|Nirvana]] by Nirvana has [http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/details.html?releaseid=90727&show=times#discid DiscID] which has several different tracks.

Revision as of 08:26, 29 October 2006

Currently an auto-editor in MusicBrainz, I've been mostly going through my own record collection. This means quite a lot of Finnish rock with some occasional apetizers. On the side I'm also trying to add useful information about the bands or artists in general when I find the time.

However, I often lose myself in finding and adding information: I may end up adding age-old clay singles, because someone has covered an old song in Finnish and I end up looking for the earliest release to link it to.

Currently I'm spending time trying to make sense about PUIDs; I'm going through my own collection and try to remove PUIDs from conflicting versions - for example, same PUID is not likely to be generated from a live and studio release, so away they go.

Languages

  • * * * =Wonderings=

Late Night Tales series

Late Night Tales is a series where each volume contains tracks chosen by a single artist. See, for example, Jamiroquai or Flaming Lips.

For some reason, each of these volumes is attributed to the artist who has chosen the tracks. Why? They are pretty obvious VA compilations. Do I get my own page in MusicBrainz if I start to compile my very own releases of other artists' tracks?

Smile

As I try to enter complete information into the database, I often find myself searching for the earliest releases. But what if that just isn't available? I welcome you in search of Smile, the original release of Charlie Chaplin's classic.

Is the earliest release the one we hear in Modern Times? If it is, do we count the movie as the first release - that's what the piece was composed for, after all. Did they release soundtracks back in 1936?

Or is the earliest release the one with lyrics added, from 1954? Turner/Parsons did a great job with the lyrics, and they complete the song as the version we know today. Was Nat King Cole's recording the first, or were there others before him?

To be fixed

Wrong tracks?

  • Crossing All Over vol.10 has Skunk Anansie's Lately in the track listing, but it has the same track length and it's sharing its only PUID with You'll Follow Me Down.
  • Nirvana's The Best Of has Big Long Now which has same track length and it's sharing its PUID with Mexican Seafood.
  • They Might Be Giants' Apollo 18 has a zillion PUIDs on tracks that are only few seconds in length. Sort of strange, considering MusicIP software doesn't analyze that sort tracks.

Track times

Multiple releases under same entry

Questionable albums

  • A Tribute to U2 - on U2's own catalog?
  • Star Profile by R.E.M. isn't the official Star Profile, and the track times are so close to studio album lengths that I doubt it's a live either.

Other things

Template:lang fi-native Template:lang en-fluent Template:lang sv-some Template:lang fr-some