User:Symphonick/CSG roadmap: Difference between revisions
Symphonick (talk | contribs) m (→Revision) |
Symphonick (talk | contribs) (→Recordings: update - expected new MB recordings title guideline) |
||
(13 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
As parent works don't show up in search results, we are forced to append all titles from the parent work to all sub-parts. |
As parent works don't show up in search results, we are forced to append all titles from the parent work to all sub-parts. |
||
This workaround will not continue in the upcoming works title guideline. |
This workaround will not continue in the upcoming works title guideline. |
||
A solution is probably needed (Benji's ticket [[Jira:MBS-3374|MBS-3374]] is similar) before we can implement work titles |
A solution is probably needed (Benji's ticket [[Jira:MBS-3374|MBS-3374]] is similar) before we can implement work titles. |
||
===Guidelines=== |
===Guidelines=== |
||
Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
Definition of a work. |
Definition of a work. |
||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | |||
Minor update. |
|||
=====Part II: Titles===== |
=====Part II: Titles===== |
||
[[User:Symphonick/CSG Work Titles]] ''WIP'' |
[[User:Symphonick/CSG Work Titles]] ''WIP'' |
||
⚫ | |||
Sourcing titles. Language. Titles for works with a title by the composer and titles for works with lyrics.<br /> |
|||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | |||
''if part II gets too messy'' |
|||
How to format titles for untitled/generic works. |
|||
====Recordings==== |
====Recordings==== |
||
''Defaults to the standard MusicBrainz recording guideline. Not sure a specific CSG version is required.''<br /> |
|||
''planned - works titles has to be in place first'' |
|||
''Possibly for more info about how to decide language for multi-language sources, but it wouldn't actually change the standard guideline, just explain it.'' |
|||
Language. Appending titles. Constructing titles when works and recordings don't match. |
|||
====Tracks==== |
====Tracks==== |
||
[[Image:Attention.png]] ''originally planned to be done before the other proposals, on hold awaiting schema change (track group titles/headings)'' |
[[Image:Attention.png]] ''originally planned to be done before the other proposals, on hold awaiting a schema change (track group titles/headings) that sounded very close two years ago or something... :-('' |
||
What to include in track titles. Releases with multiple languages |
What to include in track titles. Releases with multiple languages.<br /> |
||
⚫ | |||
=====Tracks part II: Pseudo-tracklists===== |
|||
Old-style CSG tracktitles, for those who want them. |
|||
===ARs=== |
===ARs=== |
||
====Revision==== |
====Revision==== |
||
[http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Revision_Relationship_Type Revision Relationship Type] [[Image:Checkmark.png]] Accepted |
|||
⚫ | |||
'''RFC''' ''awaiting +1'' |
|||
====Arrangement==== |
====Arrangement==== |
||
[http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Has_Arrangement_Relationship_Type Has Arrangement Relationship Type] [[Image:Checkmark.png]] Accepted |
|||
[[User:Symphonick/Works_versions]] |
|||
'''RFC''' ''awaiting +1'' |
|||
====Orchestration (arrangement subtype)==== |
====Orchestration (arrangement subtype)==== |
||
[http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Orchestration_Relationship_Type Orchestration Relationship Type] [[Image:Checkmark.png]] Accepted |
|||
''planned'' |
|||
====Transcription (arrangement subtype)==== |
====Transcription (arrangement subtype)==== |
||
Line 60: | Line 56: | ||
===Other proposals=== |
===Other proposals=== |
||
* Appliance of CSG - ''didn't caller#6 start this long ago? |
* Appliance of CSG - ''didn't caller#6 start this long ago?'' |
||
** [http://musicbrainz.1054305.n4.nabble.com/pre-RFC-When-does-the-CSG-apply-tp4439312.html Thread on Nabble] [[User:Caller number six|Caller_number_six]] ([[User talk:Caller number six|talk]]) |
|||
* [[User:DavitoF/How_To_Link_Works_Together|How to link works together]] by davitof [http://musicbrainz.1054305.n4.nabble.com/Work-Work-summary-tp4649671.html (thread)] |
* [[User:DavitoF/How_To_Link_Works_Together|How to link works together]] by davitof [http://musicbrainz.1054305.n4.nabble.com/Work-Work-summary-tp4649671.html (thread)] |
||
* Everyone should have a CSG roadmap! [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vngQFtV5JGkMowQEzgRN0v142QpySzstO6cdKVKqQ2w/edit Alex's] |
* Everyone should have a CSG roadmap! [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vngQFtV5JGkMowQEzgRN0v142QpySzstO6cdKVKqQ2w/edit Alex's] |
Latest revision as of 08:47, 21 August 2013
Planned proposals, links to old discussions and more.
Proposals
Schema & UI changes
Show parent works in search results
As parent works don't show up in search results, we are forced to append all titles from the parent work to all sub-parts. This workaround will not continue in the upcoming works title guideline. A solution is probably needed (Benji's ticket MBS-3374 is similar) before we can implement work titles.
Guidelines
Works
Part I
Style/Classical/Works Accepted
Definition of a work. For clarity, the RFC should include deprecating the old opera guideline.
Part Ia
User:Symphonick/CSG_Excerpt_works WIP
Minor update.
Part II: Titles
User:Symphonick/CSG Work Titles WIP
Most likely schema changes will be necessary, or we
Recordings
Defaults to the standard MusicBrainz recording guideline. Not sure a specific CSG version is required.
Possibly for more info about how to decide language for multi-language sources, but it wouldn't actually change the standard guideline, just explain it.
Tracks
originally planned to be done before the other proposals, on hold awaiting a schema change (track group titles/headings) that sounded very close two years ago or something... :-(
What to include in track titles. Releases with multiple languages.
Tracks part II: Pseudo-tracklists
Old-style CSG tracktitles, for those who want them.
ARs
Revision
Revision Relationship Type Accepted
Arrangement
Has Arrangement Relationship Type Accepted
Orchestration (arrangement subtype)
Orchestration Relationship Type Accepted
Transcription (arrangement subtype)
Lorenz made a pre-RFC in 2011
Other proposals
- Appliance of CSG - didn't caller#6 start this long ago?
- How to link works together by davitof (thread)
- Everyone should have a CSG roadmap! Alex's