User:Tommycrock/Performance Relationship Type links

1

Long forward

[Recording] contains a {live} {medley:medley including a} {partial} {instrumental} {cover:cover|version} of [Work]

Short forward

{live} {medley:medley including a} {partial} {instrumental} {cover:cover|version} of [Work]

reverse

{cover:covered|recorded} {live} {partial:(partial)} {instrumental:(instrumental)} {medley:as part of a medley} in

Notes

For the forward phrase I wanted to separate medley (which is about a set of works) from partial (which is specific to the performance/recording), and instrumental and cover (which are, or can be, specific to one work). Previously, "performance of" was changed to "recording of" because we can have multiple recordings of one performance and because performance is a slightly dubious term for the relationship in some cases. The same can be said for medleys. I think this can be dropped from the forward version of the phrase. I'm not sure there is the perfect link phrase because the relationship will be used in circumstances where (a) 1 recording includes versions of many works, (b) a medley is split across multiple recordings, (c) a recording includes things that aren't related to a work, as well as works, (d) a recording is the only recording of a work.

examples

Lady Madonna contains a version of Lady Madonna

• version of: Lady Madonnna
• recorded in: Lady Madonna

Don't Push / Garden Grove / Right Back / New Thrash contains a live medley including a version of Don't Push

• live medley including a version of: Don't Push
• recorded live as part of a medley in: Don't Push / Garden Grove / Right Back / New Thrash

5446 / House of Suffering contains a live medley including a cover of 54-46 (That's My Number)

• live medley including a cover of: 54-46 (That's My Number)
• covered live as part of a medley in: 5446 / House of Suffering

Adult Books / It's Who You Know contains a live partial cover of Adult Books

• live partial cover of: Adult Books
• covered live (partial) in: Adult Books / It's Who You know

Doin' Time (Wyclef instrumental remix) contains a instrumental version of Doin' Time

• instrumental version of: Doin' Time
• recorded (instrumental) in: Doin' Time (Wyclef instrumental remix)