Difference between revisions of "Versus Means Different Things"
m (Conversion script moved page Versus Means Different Things to versus Means Different Things: Converting page titles to lowercase)
m (Ianmcorvidae moved page versus Means Different Things to Versus Means Different Things over redirect)
Revision as of 03:41, 19 September 2012
When an Artist Name or Track Title has the form X vs. Y (or v or vs or versus) there are three possible meanings it can have. It is important to determine which case applies, and to follow the relevant Style Guideline specified in Versus Style. The three cases are:
1 — Two artists collaborating
This is just another way of saying
- "Artist A & Artist B"
- "Artist A (feat. Artist B)".
This case is handled by Featuring Artist Style.
Juno Reactor and Don Davis' work on The Matrix Revolutions soundtrack.
The tracks where they collaborated are listed using FeaturingArtistStyle, once with the variant (vs. Don Davis) rather than (feat. Don Davis)
- Artist: Don Davis
- Title: Tetsujin (feat. Juno Reactor)
- Artist: Juno Reactor
- Title: Navras (vs. Don Davis)
2 — One artist remixing another
Usually this means a later artist has remixed an older song.
This case is handled by Remix Style.
- Need a good example without a lot of conflicting database entries here. (It's Like That is not a good example)
3 — Two tracks mixed together to make a "new" song
Also known as a Mash-up, this means that two pieces of music by different artists are mixed together, over each other, or otherwise combined into a single track (usually by a third artist). These are usually unofficial and unsanctioned by the original artists, and sometime it's impossible to find out who mixed/mashed the tracks together.
This case is handled under VersusStyle.
A Henry Rollins spoken word monologue has been mixed over Nine Inch Nails' "A Warm Place" and can be found on P2P networks as
- "Henry Rollins vs. Nine Inch Nails" - A Warm Place
- "Henry Rollins vs. Nine Inch Nails" - I Know You
Note: This isn't actually entered into MusicBrainz currently.