Difference between revisions of "Proposal:Audiobook Style"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
(link official style)
Line 11: Line 11:
 
}}
 
}}
  
=Style for narrations of works of literature=
+
'''Official guideline is now: [[Style/Specific types of releases/Audiobook]]'''
 +
 
 +
== Style for narrations of works of literature ==
  
 
Initially the old [[Style Dude|StyleDude]] decided not to have a guideline for audio books. However, an AudioBookStyle for [[Audio Books|AudioBook]] has been under way on the style mailing lists.
 
Initially the old [[Style Dude|StyleDude]] decided not to have a guideline for audio books. However, an AudioBookStyle for [[Audio Books|AudioBook]] has been under way on the style mailing lists.

Revision as of 17:14, 19 November 2013


Status: This page describes an active style guideline proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-1
Champion: Jormangeud
Current status: In development
Initial Discussion


Trac ticket # 2147

Official guideline is now: Style/Specific types of releases/Audiobook

Style for narrations of works of literature

Initially the old StyleDude decided not to have a guideline for audio books. However, an AudioBookStyle for AudioBook has been under way on the style mailing lists.

Initial "Style": NoAudioBookGuideline

TarragonAllen wrote on 2004-08-28:

  • As the database is set up primarily as a music resource audio books and other related spoken word releases do not map very well into the current data-set. As such, audio books and other related spoken word releases are allowed in the database but there will be no official standards for how they are entered, sorted or categorised, nor will there be any official style guidelines for them. If people wish to create their own style guidelines for audio books and other related spoken word releases they are free to do so, but there will be NoAudioBookGuideline.

New Guideline for Audio Books

The most important characteristic of such a guideline is to ensure that the tracks are sorted in the right sequence, if a user chooses to rename the tracks without the track number -> encode Chapter and Sub-chapters into the trackname.

I'd like to propose the following naming Scheme:

  • Include the Chapter number in titles like
    • "Chapter 01: Name of Chapter"
      • Note that the numbers are always expanded to 2 digits (add 0 before if number<10)
      • If the current chapter is continued from a previous medium, append (continued)
  • For chapters spread over more than one physical track, include the sequence number of the current subchapter sequence number
    • "Chapter 01-01: Title of subchapter" or
    • "Chapter 01-01: Title of chapter" (if the subchapter has no title)

Next possible steps to take:

  • browse albums and see what a mess the audiobooks section really is and
  • have a look at the albums of J.K. Rowling to see a somewhat organized listing, but with different numbering styles, and decide if we could make the proposal above official -- Keschte

Example

Bonjour tristesse (disc 1, disc 2, disc 3)