Difference between revisions of "User:BrianSchweitzer/Choirmaster Position Relationship Type Proposal"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Add do not infer guidance, add (invisible for the moment) stub descriptions for examples, add guest attribute)
Line 22: Line 22:
 
|linkText1 = is/was a choirmaster/choirmistress for
 
|linkText1 = is/was a choirmaster/choirmistress for
 
|linkedTo1 = Artist
 
|linkedTo1 = Artist
  +
|exampleDescription1 = A basic choirmaster relationship, with no attributes
   
 
|linkedFrom2 = Artist
 
|linkedFrom2 = Artist
 
|linkText2 = has/had choirmaster(s)/choirmistress(es)
 
|linkText2 = has/had choirmaster(s)/choirmistress(es)
 
|linkedTo2 = Artist
 
|linkedTo2 = Artist
  +
  +
|exampleDescription3 = Assistant choirmaster
  +
  +
|exampleDescription5 = Associate choirmaster
  +
  +
|exampleDescription7 = Choirmaster emeritus
  +
  +
|exampleDescription9 = Principal choirmaster
  +
  +
|exampleDescription11 = A choirmaster for only specific vocal sections within the group
  +
  +
|exampleDescription16 = Correct use of the 'guest' attribute for a choirmaster holding the position of 'guest choirmaster'...
  +
   
 
|attributeDescriptionBegin = This indicates the first date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the choirmaster position.
 
|attributeDescriptionBegin = This indicates the first date that the [[Artist|artist]] held the choirmaster position.
Line 64: Line 78:
 
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] has/had <nowiki>{{vocal}}</nowiki> choirmaster(s)/choirmistress(es) [[Artist]]</ul>
 
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] has/had <nowiki>{{vocal}}</nowiki> choirmaster(s)/choirmistress(es) [[Artist]]</ul>
 
|attributePage5 = Vocal Relationship Attribute
 
|attributePage5 = Vocal Relationship Attribute
  +
  +
|attributeName6 = guest
  +
|attributeDescription6 = This indicates that the choirmaster held a 'guest choirmaster' or 'visiting choirmaster' '''position'''. It does '''not''' indicate merely that a choirmaster was given a "guest conductor" or "guest choirmaster" credit on a particular release, release group, recording, or track.
  +
<dd>'''Link Phrases:'''
  +
<ul><li>[[Artist]] is/was a guest choirmaster/choirmistress for [[Artist]]
  +
<li>[[Artist|Artist]] has/had guest choirmaster(s)/choirmistress(es) [[Artist]]</ul>
  +
|attributePage6 = Guest Relationship Attribute
   
 
|summary = This indicates that an [[Artist|artist]] is, or was, a choirmaster for an [[Artist|artist]].
 
|summary = This indicates that an [[Artist|artist]] is, or was, a choirmaster for an [[Artist|artist]].
Line 75: Line 96:
 
:: This title, in the classical era, typically indicated a choirmaster. '''''Caution:''''' In the modern era, this title typically indicates a [[Proposal:Music Director Position Relationship Type Proposal|music director]], not a choirmaster.
 
:: This title, in the classical era, typically indicated a choirmaster. '''''Caution:''''' In the modern era, this title typically indicates a [[Proposal:Music Director Position Relationship Type Proposal|music director]], not a choirmaster.
   
|style = * The position (and any attribute used) should be documented; it must not be assumed.
+
|style = # The position (and any attribute used) should be documented; it must not be assumed.
* At any one time, an [[Artist|artist]] may have more than one choirmaster, but never more than one principal choirmaster.
+
# At any one time, an [[Artist|artist]] may have more than one choirmaster, but never more than one principal choirmaster.
* A choirmaster must be a person [[Artist|artist]].
+
# A choirmaster must be a person [[Artist|artist]].
* The [[Artist|artist]] conducted by the choirmaster must be a group [[Artist|artist]].
+
# The [[Artist|artist]] conducted by the choirmaster must be a group [[Artist|artist]].
* Only one of the attributes 'assistant', 'associate', 'emeritus', or 'principal' should be used at the same time.
+
# Only one of the attributes 'assistant', 'associate', 'emeritus', or 'principal' should be used at the same time.
* This musical position specifically involves the training, leading, and/or conducting of a ''choir'' or ''chorus''. If the position did not involve a choir, then [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]], not this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used.
+
# This musical position specifically involves the training, leading, and/or conducting of a ''choir'' or ''chorus''. If the position did not involve a choir, then [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]], not this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used.
:* In some cases, both an orchestra and a choir coexist, and are conducted by the same [[Artist|artist]]. In such cases, both this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''and'' [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]] should be used.
+
#: In some cases, both an orchestra and a choir coexist, and are conducted by the same [[Artist|artist]]. In such cases, both this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] ''and'' [[Proposal:Conductor Position Relationship Type Proposal|Conductor Position Relationship Type]] should be used.
* This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] describes a [[WikiPedia:Conducting|choirmaster]] ''position'' one [[Artist|artist]] holds with another [[Artist|artist]]. [[Conductor Relationship Type]], ''not'' this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used to describe the fact that an [[Artist|artist]] was the choirmaster on a [[Track|track]] or [[Release|release]].
+
# This [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]] describes a [[WikiPedia:Conducting|choirmaster]] ''position'' one [[Artist|artist]] holds with another [[Artist|artist]]. [[Conductor Relationship Type]], ''not'' this [[:Category:Relationship Type|relationship type]], should be used to describe the fact that an [[Artist|artist]] was the choirmaster on a [[Track|track]] or [[Release|release]].
  +
# '''Do not infer attributes.''' An inexperienced choirmaster is not automatically an assistant or associate choirmaster, nor is a very experienced choirmaster automatically a choirmaster emeritus. Likewise, 'guest choirmaster' is a specific position title; simply because a choirmaster is credited with "guest conducting" on a release, that choirmaster '''does not''' automatically become a 'guest choirmaster'.
 
}}
 
}}
   

Revision as of 04:14, 17 December 2010


Status: This page describes an active advanced relationship proposal and is not official.



Proposal number: RFC-264
Champion: BrianFreud
Current status: RFC
Initial Discussion



Template:Relationship

Template:References