Difference between revisions of "User:RobertKaye/Works Definition"

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(New page: In a recent blog post I tried to define a Work as: <blockquote> ''A Work is a musical composition that will at some point be performed and possibly recorded, in which case it will become ...)
 
Line 12: Line 12:
   
 
By allowing a wider definition of a Work we can capture more information about the Work. For instance, if a compilation of music is considered a Work, then the release level information/ARs can capture the information about the recordings contained in the compilation and the Work level information/ARs can capture the information about the compilation itself.
 
By allowing a wider definition of a Work we can capture more information about the Work. For instance, if a compilation of music is considered a Work, then the release level information/ARs can capture the information about the recordings contained in the compilation and the Work level information/ARs can capture the information about the compilation itself.
  +
  +
== Alternative 1 ==
  +
  +
:''A work represents an abstract musical creation/concept which can be performed and recorded to create a recording. Alternatively, a work can be creatively manipulated (i.e. arranged, remixed, sampled, mashed-up, etc.) into a new work, which can then have its own performances and recordings.
  +
  +
I took a stab at a definition, hopefully it's not too wordy. --[[User:PavanChander|navap]] 20:37, 10 September 2010 (UTC)

Revision as of 20:37, 10 September 2010

In a recent blog post I tried to define a Work as:

A Work is a musical composition that will at some point be performed and possibly recorded, in which case it will become a Recording.

This definition makes it difficult to address compilations, DJ-mixes and mash-ups. What if we're more liberal in our definition of Work:

A Work is a new musical creation or a creative combination of existing musical creations. Works can be performed and recorded to create recordings or recordings can be creatively combined to create new recordings.

By allowing a wider definition of a Work we can capture more information about the Work. For instance, if a compilation of music is considered a Work, then the release level information/ARs can capture the information about the recordings contained in the compilation and the Work level information/ARs can capture the information about the compilation itself.

Alternative 1

A work represents an abstract musical creation/concept which can be performed and recorded to create a recording. Alternatively, a work can be creatively manipulated (i.e. arranged, remixed, sampled, mashed-up, etc.) into a new work, which can then have its own performances and recordings.

I took a stab at a definition, hopefully it's not too wordy. --navap 20:37, 10 September 2010 (UTC)