User talk:Jormangeud/Release Restructuring: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
1. A medium and even a content may have an artist different to release and to a medium. Examples of a mediums with different artists: [[http://musicbrainz.org/release/fec0ed35-fc40-492a-bde4-bae1b235e454]] So the '''support for artist''' should be added to '''Medium''' and to '''Content''' |
--[[User:RocknRollArchivist|RocknRollArchivist]] 10:00, 8 July 2012 (UTC)1. A medium and even a content may have an artist different to release and to a medium. Examples of a mediums with different artists: [[http://musicbrainz.org/release/fec0ed35-fc40-492a-bde4-bae1b235e454]] So the '''support for artist''' should be added to '''Medium''' and to '''Content''' |
||
2. A medium in the release may have a packaging different to the release packaging. E.g. an LP or CD box (packaging=other, as the '''box''' packaging is so far not present in MB) has the mediums in jewel case, or |
2. A medium in the release may have a packaging different to the release packaging. E.g. an LP or CD box (packaging=other, as the '''box''' packaging is so far not present in MB) has the mediums in jewel case, or cardboard/paper sleeve, or without a packaging (in the releases such as digipak, digibook, etc.). And even the mediums included to the same release may have a different packaging, e.g. jewel case and double jewel case (so far not present in MB). So the '''support for packaging''' should be added to '''Medium'''. |
||
| ⚫ | 3. A medium in the release may have a date and a barcode different to the release date and barcode. E.g., these two releases [[http://musicbrainz.org/release/dbbf8006-7b3f-4a93-a342-b4ba370e8f06]] (1995, barcode 090431563229) and [[http://musicbrainz.org/release/29af1268-a14a-4077-891d-f9f10df4f5f3]] (1994, barcode 790431547228) exist: 1) as separate releases, and also 2) as mediums of the bundled release "The Five Keys: 2 CD Box Set" [[http://www.amazon.com/Best-Capitol-Aladdin-Years-Five/dp/B0000516W9]] (so far not present in MB just in consequence of insufficient support for the mediums) issued in 2000-11-28 with the barcode 090431007921. |
||
3. A medium in the release may have a date and a barcode different to the release date and barcode. E.g., these two releases |
|||
[[http://musicbrainz.org/release/dbbf8006-7b3f-4a93-a342-b4ba370e8f06]] (1995, barcode 090431563229) and |
|||
| ⚫ | [[http://musicbrainz.org/release/29af1268-a14a-4077-891d-f9f10df4f5f3]] (1994, barcode 790431547228) exist: 1) as separate releases, and also 2) as mediums of the bundled release "The Five Keys: 2 CD Box Set" [[http://www.amazon.com/Best-Capitol-Aladdin-Years-Five/dp/B0000516W9]] (so far not present in MB just in consequence of insufficient support for the mediums) issued in 2000-11-28 with the barcode 090431007921. |
||
So the '''support for date and for barcode''' should be added to '''Medium'''. |
So the '''support for date and for barcode''' should be added to '''Medium'''. |
||
| Line 12: | Line 10: | ||
5. ''Medium: [...] Forced sides on predefined formats (vinyl, cassette, DualDisc, DVDplus, VinylDisc)'' |
5. ''Medium: [...] Forced sides on predefined formats (vinyl, cassette, DualDisc, DVDplus, VinylDisc)'' |
||
A vinyl medium (e.g., a single 7-inch) has sometimes a sole side, so the forced sides should not be applied for it. |
A vinyl medium (e.g., a single 7-inch) has sometimes a sole side, so the forced sides should not be applied for it. |
||
--[[User:RocknRollArchivist|RocknRollArchivist]] 09:36, 8 July 2012 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 10:00, 8 July 2012
--RocknRollArchivist 10:00, 8 July 2012 (UTC)1. A medium and even a content may have an artist different to release and to a medium. Examples of a mediums with different artists: [[1]] So the support for artist should be added to Medium and to Content
2. A medium in the release may have a packaging different to the release packaging. E.g. an LP or CD box (packaging=other, as the box packaging is so far not present in MB) has the mediums in jewel case, or cardboard/paper sleeve, or without a packaging (in the releases such as digipak, digibook, etc.). And even the mediums included to the same release may have a different packaging, e.g. jewel case and double jewel case (so far not present in MB). So the support for packaging should be added to Medium.
3. A medium in the release may have a date and a barcode different to the release date and barcode. E.g., these two releases [[2]] (1995, barcode 090431563229) and [[3]] (1994, barcode 790431547228) exist: 1) as separate releases, and also 2) as mediums of the bundled release "The Five Keys: 2 CD Box Set" [[4]] (so far not present in MB just in consequence of insufficient support for the mediums) issued in 2000-11-28 with the barcode 090431007921. So the support for date and for barcode should be added to Medium.
4. A medium may have an annotation, a disambiguation and even a status, a language, a script, a country, a label different to the release. For sum up: a medium should have a full support which exists now for a release.
5. Medium: [...] Forced sides on predefined formats (vinyl, cassette, DualDisc, DVDplus, VinylDisc) A vinyl medium (e.g., a single 7-inch) has sometimes a sole side, so the forced sides should not be applied for it.
