History talk:Proposals/History: Difference between revisions

From MusicBrainz Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 467: Line 467:
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-21: Linking Different Artist Names</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-21
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> [[Linking Different Artist Names]]
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects -->
| <!-- Trac ticket -->
| <!-- Status --> Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC -->
| <!-- RFC Date -->
| <!-- RFV --> N/A
| <!-- RFV Date --> N/A
| <!-- Passage Date --> N/A
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-103: Add Changed Name To AR</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-103
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> Add Changed Name To AR
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects --> New artist-artist AR
| <!-- Trac ticket -->
| <!-- Status --> Discussion died (this RFC has been independently attempted multiple times). Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC --> one RFC (''link missing''), [http://lists.musicbrainz.org/pipermail/musicbrainz-style/2007-May/004907.html one RFC], others
| <!-- RFC Date --> 2007-05, 2008-02-09, others
| <!-- RFV -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-95: Add Live Journal</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-95
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> [[LiveJournal|Add Live Journal]]
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects --> New artist-URL AR
| <!-- Trac ticket -->
| <!-- Status --> Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC -->
| <!-- RFC Date -->
| <!-- RFV -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-97: Expanded Samples Relationship Type</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-97
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> [[Expanded Samples Relationship Type]]
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects --> AR enhancement
| <!-- Trac ticket -->
| <!-- Status --> Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC -->
| <!-- RFC Date -->
| <!-- RFV -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-86: Add Release-Track Relationship for pre-gap tracks</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-86
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> Add Release-Track Relationship for pre-gap tracks
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects --> New track-release AR
| <!-- Trac ticket --> [http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/4235 4235]
| <!-- Status --> Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC -->
| <!-- RFC Date -->
| <!-- RFV -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->
|-
| <h4 style='display: none'>RFC-110: Same Artist With Different Names Suggestion</h4>
<!-- RFC # -->RFC-110
| <!-- Title & Wikipage --> [[Same Artist With Different Names Suggestion]]
| <!-- Champion --> Abandoned
| <!-- Affects --> AR style guideline changes
| <!-- Trac ticket -->
| <!-- Status --> Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010
| <!-- RFC -->
| <!-- RFC Date -->
| <!-- RFV -->
| <!-- RFV Date -->
| <!-- Passage Date -->

|}
|}


Revision as of 11:53, 24 March 2010

Comments

Note: Comments on particular proposals should be sent on the style list in the appropriate thread. They do not belong here.  :)

Old proposals that have migrated here until something better is done with them

Allow Instrument Attribute for Members of a Band

Should MemberOfBandRelationshipType not have an instrument attribute? --DonRedman

This would introduce some additional complexity in interpreting artist roles: see ArtistRoleInheritance --MatthewExon

Another thought: the instrument attribute doesn't have "vocals", so this wouldn't work for recording singers. Maybe the InstrumentRelationshipAttribute hierarchy should include the VocalRelationshipAttribute hierarchy, and "Performed instrument on" be merged with "Performed vocal on"? There are other roles for members of a band as well: The Prodigy has two dancers as "official" members. IMO these could probably be adequately covered by "other" --MatthewExon

Also Known As

The current Alias property should be repurposed now that AR is ready. Artist who have recorded under multiple names should have a relationship instead. The existing Alias property would still be usefully for misspelled names but there are some artists like Aphex Twin and Wynonna Judd who have recorded under different names and the release should be reflected correctly for those artists. The current "is the legal name/is the performing name" is insufficient since in some cases an artist might perform under two names and neither is their legal name (i.e. Wynonna and Wynonna Judd) --WolfSong

Rename Legal Name to Birth Name

I propose renaming this simply because more often than not, finding someone's birth name is more plausible than their legal name since names can be changed and although in the US such information becomes public record, this may not be the case everywhere. This was actually changed from official name to legal name due to discussions over Wendy/Walter Carlos. In this scenario Wendy is probably the legal name and Walter is the birth name. Both names should be listed separately since this person has released recordings under each name. --WolfSong

Proposals Pending Implementation

Style Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

Advanced Relationship Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

RFC-2: Has Score At relationship

RFC-2

Has Score At relationship mbuser838171846981 New release-URL AR
New track-URL AR 		5634 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFC 2010-02-20 RFV 2010-03-01 2010-03-03

RFC-18: Engineer Relationship Type

RFC-18

Engineer Relationship Type Gecks New artist-release AR
New artist-track AR 		3565 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented ? 2007-05-22 RFV RFV 2008-02-01 2008-03-02

RFC-70: Add attribute 'translated' to Lyricist Relationship Type

RFC-70

Add attribute 'translated' to Lyricist Relationship Type (related attribute page) zout Artist-Track and Artist-Release AR enhancement 4424 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFC3 RFC4 2010-02-27 RFV 2010-03-06 2010-03-08

RFC-82: Resolve FoundingMemberDatesQuestion

RFC-82

Resolve FoundingMemberDatesQuestion BrianFreud artist-artist AR 1009 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFC 2010-03-01 RFV 2010-03-08 2010-03-10

RFC-85: Adding vocal attribute to Arranger AR

RFC-85

Adding vocal attribute to Arranger AR Chris B (Gecks) New artist-release AR
New artist-track AR 		3564 MBS-488 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFV 2008-01-08 2008-01-??

RFC-90: Has Lyrics At Extension

RFC-90

Has Lyrics At Extension BrianFreud New artist-URL AR 5637 Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFC 2010-02-28 RFV 2010-03-07 2010-03-09

RFC-91: Fix Production Relationship Class

RFC-91

Fix Production Relationship Class (aka: convert the current Miscellaneous Production and Engineer Relationship Types to Relationship Classes, fix/implement the unimplemented but already-passed specific Engineer Relationship types, and fix Programming Relationship Type) BrianFreud Fixes problems within Production Relationship Class, also implements RFC-18 and RFC-85 Passed, all doc changes made, ARs waiting to be implemented RFC 2010-02-28 RFV 2010-03-07 2010-03-10

RFC-92: Create three new AR Classes, remove 3 existing AR Classes, move Affiliate RC, merge 2 existing AR Types

RFC-92

Create three new AR Classes, remove 3 existing AR Classes, move Affiliate RC, merge 2 existing AR Types BrianFreud Reorganization of 4 Relationship Classes, merge 2 Relationship Types Passed, to be implemented RFC 2010-02-28 RFV 2010-03-07 2010-03-10

RFC-102: Add attribute 'translated' to Librettist Relationship Type

RFC-102

Add attribute 'translated' to Librettist Relationship Type (related attribute page) BrianFreud AR enhancement Passed, doc updated, AR table changes to be implemented RFC 2010-03-06 RFV 2010-03-13 2010-03-15

RFC-74: Contains samples from <IMDb link> AR

RFC-74

Contains samples from <IMDb link> AR Chris B (Gecks) New track-URL / release-URL AR 3032 Passed, doc updated, waiting for AR table implementation RFC 2010-03-09 RFV 2010-03-16 2010-03-18

Other Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

Closed Proposals

Style Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

RFC-12: Classical Release Language

RFC-12

Classical Release Language ? ? ? Replaced by RFC-67 ? ? ? ?

RFC-13: Classical Release Title Style

RFC-13

Classical Release Title Style Andrew Conkling Release titles for classical N/A Replaced by RFC-67 Proposal N/A N/A N/A N/A

RFC-14: Classical Track Title Partnumber Style

RFC-14

Classical Track Title Partnumber Style ? Track titles for classical ? Replaced by RFC-67 Never sent N/A N/A N/A N/A

RFC-22: Live Bootleg Style

RFC-22

Live Bootleg Style BrianFreud Replacement for Untitled Bootleg Style 1053 Passed and implemented RFC 2010-02-22 RFV 2010-03-01 2010-03-03

RFC-23: Live Track Style

RFC-23

Live Track Style BrianFreud Replacement for Untitled Bootleg Style 2141 Passed and implemented RFC 2010-02-22 RFV 2010-03-01 2010-03-03

RFC-45: Release Event Style

RFC-45

Release Event Style ? Release events 2145 Adopted and resumed as RFC-64 ? ? ? ?

RFC-7: Capitalization Standard Spanish

RFC-7

Capitalization Standard Spanish Toni Panadès (t0n3t) and reosarevok New guideline 5635 Passed and implemented RFC 2010-03-05 RFV 2010-03-12 2010-03-14

RFC-101: Capitalization Standard Catalan

RFC-101

Capitalization Standard Catalan Toni Panadès (t0n3t) New guideline None Passed and implemented RFC 2010-03-05 RFV 2010-03-12 2010-03-14
RFC-114 Composer Relationship Type: Guideline for use of the begin date fields User:DavitoF New guideline None Passed and implemented RFC 2010-03-07 RFV 2010-03-14 2010-03-16
RFC-115 Composer Relationship Type: Guideline for use of the end date fields User:DavitoF New guideline None Passed and implemented RFC 2010-03-08 RFV 2010-03-15 2010-03-17

RFC-203: Replacement Sortname Style

RFC-203

Replacement Sortname Style BrianFreud Replacement guideline RFC RFC 2010-03-14 RFV 2010-03-21 2010-03-23

RFC-10: Capitalization Standard Vietnamese (alternate)

RFC-10

Capitalization Standard Vietnamese (alternate) Abandoned New guideline Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010 N/A N/A N/A

RFC-46: Release Region Style

RFC-46

Release Region Style Abandoned New guideline Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010 N/A N/A N/A

RFC-66: User Tags Standards

RFC-66

User Tags Standards Abandoned New guideline, folksonomy Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010 N/A N/A N/A

Advanced Relationship Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

RFC-73: (invalid)

RFC-73

(invalid; duplicate entry for RFC-36 and RFC-4) ? AR modification N/A

RFC-94: Decommission Label Relationship Class

RFC-94

Decommission Label Relationship Class BrianFreud Removes 1 Relationship Class Passed and implemented RFC 2010-03-01 RFV 2010-03-08 2010-03-10

RFC-104: Expansion of the Librettist Relationship Type

RFC-104

Expansion of the Librettist Relationship Type BrianFreud New track-artist AR Passed and implemented RFC 2008-02-09 2008-02-15 2008-02-25

RFC-96: AR documentation cleanup

RFC-96

AR documentation cleanup BrianFreud AR documentation cleanup Passed, doc updated RFC 2010-03-01 RFV 2010-03-08 2010-03-10

RFC-98: Allow Instrument Attribute for Members of a Band

RFC-98

Allow Instrument Attribute for Members of a Band Abandoned AR enhancement See RFC-69

RFC-21: Linking Different Artist Names

RFC-21

Linking Different Artist Names Abandoned Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010 N/A N/A N/A

RFC-103: Add Changed Name To AR

RFC-103

Add Changed Name To AR Abandoned New artist-artist AR Discussion died (this RFC has been independently attempted multiple times). Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010 one RFC (link missing), one RFC, others 2007-05, 2008-02-09, others

RFC-95: Add Live Journal

RFC-95

Add Live Journal Abandoned New artist-URL AR Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010

RFC-97: Expanded Samples Relationship Type

RFC-97

Expanded Samples Relationship Type Abandoned AR enhancement Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010

RFC-86: Add Release-Track Relationship for pre-gap tracks

RFC-86

Add Release-Track Relationship for pre-gap tracks Abandoned New track-release AR 4235 Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010

RFC-110: Same Artist With Different Names Suggestion

RFC-110

Same Artist With Different Names Suggestion Abandoned AR style guideline changes Officially closed as Abandoned, March 24, 2010

Other Proposals

RFC # Title & Wikipage Champion Affects Trac ticket Status RFC RFC Date RFV RFV Date Passage Date

RFC-51: Set Track Times From Disc ID

RFC-51

Set Track Times From Disc ID ? ? ? Passed and Implemented ? ? ? ? ?

RFC-72: NGS: Alternate Genders

RFC-72

NGS: Alternate Genders BrianFreud NGS development MBS-344 Passed, jira updated RFC 2010-02-22 RFV 2010-03-03 2010-03-05

RFC-71: NGS: Groups and Gender

RFC-71

NGS: Groups and Gender BrianFreud NGS development MBS-450 Passed; decision reported in jira RFC 2010-02-22 RFV 2010-03-08 2010-03-10

RFC-205: Throttling RFCs in the proposal process

RFC-205

Throttling RFCs in the proposal process PBryan Proposals Withdrawn 2010-03-17 RFC 2010-03-16
Retrieved from "https://wiki.musicbrainz.org/index.php?title=History_talk:Proposals/History&oldid=37775"